Neither the British nor US governments’ will make clear whether information gathered by the census falls under the American PATRIOT Act if gathered in part by a US-owned company, i.e. the UK census data can be passed on to the US government from Lockheed Martin. Additionally, all information outsourced to the USA may be made widely available in that country, not only for law enforcement purposes, but also to private entities. We have no legal precedence as to whether, under the pretext of national security, this census information can be acquired by the US government. The Office of National Statistics claims that our data will be safe but the UK government has demonstrated on several occasions that it cannot be trusted with managing digital data containing personal records.
The data gathered by the ten-yearly census is easily the most the comprehensive data set in the UK, and it is used extensively for various socio-economic purposes. Following the 2001 census 6% of households in the UK failed to comply with submitting their household information. This means that about three million people were ‘uncounted’. An investigation into this established that the largest group of people who did not comply was minority Muslims. These were people who mistrust the state, especially America – its government and corporations. Having Lockheed Martin gather census information is hardly likely to encourage compliance and this will result in increasingly unreliable census data.
By contracting Lockheed Martin to do this work, what was a perfectly respectable and useful socio-economic activity may now be perceived as part of the security world of intelligence and surveillance. There will be a range of ethical reasons as to why people may not wish to comply. Given that there is a strong movement in the UK for not investing in unethical companies, and that the Green Party will not wish to boost the profits of a weapon’s manufacturing company through participating in this business venture, the Green Party should state that it will give support to people who do not wish to comply with the 2011 UK national census, and will terminate the census contract with Lockheed Martin after 2011.
Comments
Hide the following 8 comments
CACI in Scotland
29.10.2009 20:14
Perhaps the most iconic photograph of Abu Ghraib is of a innocent hooded prisoner standing on a box with electrodes on his genitals, standing Christ-like with out-stretched arms. The first question the man on the box was asked was: "Are you Sunni or Shia?" Even in those horrific circumstances he was taken aback.
"It was the first time I had ever heard this question" he says, explaining that before in Iraq even in Saddams personal status laws for marriage you were not asked which school of religion you belong to.
CACI interrogators will now be asking the religious persuasion of everyone in Scotland on threat of legal prosecution.
Danny
OK...
30.10.2009 01:13
Emmett
You are not obliged to talk to Lockheed Martin
30.10.2009 07:02
Suitably phrased and done by enough people that excludes Lockheed Martin from collecting the Census Data without people being prosecuted for failure to provide census data - after all talking to a military contractor is not a legal requirement of the collection process.
Should enough people do this the census contract (but not the census) becomes frustrated.
Ned Ludd
Oh Danny, puhleeze
30.10.2009 07:51
anon
Sad boy
30.10.2009 11:03
Since the orginal poster hasn't accused me of trying to derail this thread, it looks as if it's you who are doing that. Again. Not got anything better to do with your life eh? Sad.
Danny
OH DANNY BOY
30.10.2009 12:08
@narchist
Feel the love
30.10.2009 13:02
Ned Ludd made a great suggestion but there is a legal requirement to fill in the census that will cow most people into participating. There are a range of options for people to oppose the census that I've been looking at, but I hate to go on so. Maybe anon @narchist would like to explain what their suggestion to scrap the census are, or what they've already done about it?
Danny
Scrap the corporate census
01.11.2009 16:45
Emmet - "So, can I refuse to fill in a census or take any other action?"
At the very least don't give your true religion. This question is optional, but rather than ignoring it you can register your protest through it even if you do decide to fill it in. There are a range of possible answers that would count as a protest, and it'd be best if everyone agreed on a common approach. Everyone could answer 'Muslim', like 'I am Sparticus'. In Scotland I'm hoping that clergy of all faiths will promote an 'umbrella religion' as an answer. My suggestion here is 'Churches Against Corporate Impunity', as that is appropriate for CACI, and people of all faiths or no faith can use it as a undeniable protest.
You can refuse to fill out the census but you will possibly face an as yet unspecified prosecution. At worst it is a small fine or a slap on the wrist, and the more people who refuse, the less likely any punishment is because it jams up the courts. In the past, accountable protests that have only had only hundreds or thousands of participants have seen prosecutions being abandoned for that reason. I've still never paid my Poll Tax for instance. You could just claim never to have received the form, because that will happen in any national administrative event. Some people have never filled in the census and have never been punished - personally I don't know anyone who has been punished.
Another legal mass-action possible is a mass-camp out during the census. This would be a more visible form of protest and could be a lot of fun. Go camping for a week on common ground, head to Eire, whatever. Stay away for the length of the operation. If enough people do this, then they have no way of knowing if you were a participant or not. They don't yet have the resources to check everyone all the time.
Apart from that, there is the normal range of tactics that all protestors use to disrupt unjust state and corporate abuse. This stuff has been happening in Scotland for some time, especially during the 'census rehearsal' but so far I don't have any metrics to judge how successful it has been. So far it's all been utterly peaceful stuff since it's recognised that the people at your door are just poor, temporary workers but when something is so unjust then a range of tactics could be employed without criticism. For instance, this census is partly internet based but you don't need to be a hacker to hold a sit-down protest in the organisations offices stopping the work being done.
It is less than two years away and most people are unaware of it so please publicise it now. The more damage that is done to the data, the more people who drop off the census, the less likely US military-intelligence corporations will be awarded more of our money or be trusted with more of our data. This is obviously an anti-military, anti-corporate, anti-ID creep, basic anarchist issue, but I've seen people from all the political parties criticise this too. There is plenty of time to reduce the official population of the UK by a few million, and thus remove these vile corporations from all EU contracts.
Danny