The majority of victims of crime believe non-violent offenders should be punished in the community rather than being sent to jail, according to a new report.
A survey of people who have suffered at the hands of criminals found almost two thirds (62%) do not think prison is an effective way of preventing re-offending.
It found overwhelming support for schemes that focus on crime prevention with more than half (54%) saying they were in favour of making offenders work in the community on projects in schools, old people's homes or parks to stop them re-offending.
A similar number (51%) said they supported the idea of restorative punishment - making offenders meet their victims face-to-face to make amends personally.
Nearly 1,000 victims were asked for their views on appropriate punishments for crimes such as shoplifting, car theft and vandalism.
Eight out of 10 said they believed more constructive activities for young people in the community and better supervision by parents would be the best way to stop people repeatedly committing non-violent low-level crime.
And nearly half of respondents (49%) backed drug treatment programmes under supervision in the community for drug addicts who commit crime.
The survey was carried out by ICM on behalf of SmartJustice, a five-year campaign which promotes community-based solutions to crime.
Lucie Russell, director of SmartJustice, said she wanted the Government to start tackling the causes of crime not just to appear to be tough on crime itself.
She said: "Eighty days into his 100 day deadline and all John Reid has come up with are 8,000 new prison places. This Government is obsessed with being tough on crime and is not paying enough attention to why offenders commit crime in the first place. It's no good just building more prisons, when most offenders come out worse than when they went in."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/uklatest/story/0,,-6014002,00.html
Related:
Police, Politicians and Drug Cartels
We need POLICE in Australia, not COPS or PIGS.
http://adelaide.indymedia.org/newswire/display_any/19527
More jails, more laws, longer sentences, and more recidivism, iemma?
Because there are no gang laws? Because there are no penalties for riots? Because there are no penalties for committing a crime? Because we need more jails? Because we need more recidivism?
http://adelaide.indymedia.org/newswire/display_any/19405
Book/prisons Western Hemisphere
Dear Friends,
This is a special effort by CURE in the US. We have pasted the first part and the section about the US on the bottom for those who can't download the 1.8mb book. It gives a sense of what we could do.
http://adelaide.indymedia.org/newswire/display_any/19449
Comments
Hide the following comment
UK/ 14 Pentonville screws suspended
15.08.2006 01:01
· Allegations thought to include drug trafficking
· Pentonville to conduct internal inquiry
Fourteen prison officers were suspended yesterday after allegations of corruption believed to involve trafficking in mobile phones and cannabis, and of "inappropriate relationships" with inmates.
The allegations against the suspended prison officers at Pentonville prison in north London are to be investigated in an internal inquiry led by governors from other London prisons. They involve one senior prison officer and 13 other officers and those suspended include male and female staff. "If any alleged or otherwise suspected criminal activity is uncovered during the investigations relevant information will be passed to the police," a Prison Service spokeswoman said.
The decision by Pentonville's governor to suspend the 14 officers immediately triggered an overcrowding crisis at the prison, where 1,125 inmates are packed into a jail with an official "operational capacity" of 1,127. The situation reflects the national crisis in prison numbers in England and Wales, which hit a new record last Friday when they reached 79,094 - just 705 spaces short of the total capacity of the system.
The Prison Service said Pentonville would briefly reduce its operational capacity by 116 places to 1,011 in the next two days to ensure that the regime at the prison was unaffected by the change in staffing numbers.
The director general of the Prison Service, Phil Wheatley, said: "I will not tolerate staff corruption of any sort by any member of the Prison Service. Allegations of corruption will be investigated thoroughly and where evidence is found to support those allegations, the appropriate disciplinary action will be taken."
But Colin Moses, the chairman of the Prison Officers' Association, who was at Pentonville yesterday, said more stringent vetting of prison officers was needed and claimed some of the problems were caused by a policy of local recruitment.
He also called for external police investigation: "I am concerned that the current internal disciplinary procedures only require a case to be tested on the balance of probabilities, which is not appropriate in this instance. All allegations of such serious proportion must be tested and proven beyond all reasonable doubt to ensure justice prevails."
The shadow home secretary, David Davis, said he was alarmed that the suspension had triggered an overcrowding crisis: "This government has failed to address the lack of capacity in our prisons. Consequently when an issue like this arises, one of the side-effects is that there is no additional capacity to cope with these arrangements and serious damage is done. The ability to both punish and rehabilitate offenders is dramatically undermined."
The launch of the investigation follows the disclosure last month of a joint Metropolitan police and Prison Service report which suggested that around 1,000 prison officers across England and Wales were involved in corruption, ranging from accepting cash bribes to move inmates to "easier" prisons to smuggling drugs into prison. The report, which was the result of a year-long investigation by the Prison Service's anti-corruption unit and the Met, said while most prison staff were honest there were about 600 "inappropriate relationships" between staff and inmates. The report also claimed that when intelligence was received about corrupt officers often no action was taken. The Prison Service professional standards unit held 1,360 formal investigations into alleged staff misconduct. There were also 192 disciplinary hearings after governors' investigations and 40 staff were dismissed for "unprofessional conduct".
The suspension of 14 staff at Pentonville has a greater than expected impact because only 129 of its 379 prison officers are on duty at any one time.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/prisons/story/0,,1844692,00.html
Parrot Press