This dialogue between Dr. Szasz and his critics allows him to once again articulate the argument he has presented so brilliantly and passionately for over four decades. . . . A profession that fails to learn from and respect those who confront it with controversial and discomforting ideas loses strength and vibrancy. Hopefully, at least some younger psychiatrists will be encouraged to read this book. They will find that their intellectual and professional lives will be enriched.
_Szasz Under Fire: The Psychiatric Abolitionist Faces His Critics_
Edited by Jeffrey A. Schaler
OPEN COURT PUBLISHERS
Chicago, Illinois
Distributed by Publishers Group West
ISBN 0-8126-9568-2
472 pages
Since he published The Myth of Mental Illness in 1961, Thomas Szasz has been a provocative and polarizing figure, bitterly denounced by some, lovingly defended by others, simultaneously baffling, exasperating, and entertaining to many.
In Szasz Under Fire, thirteen outstanding writers criticize Szasz's ideas on specific issues such as the reality of mental illness, physician-assisted suicide, addiction, and the insanity defense. Szasz replies to each criticism in detail, with his famous clarity, forcefulness, and occasional acerbity. Szasz Under Fire includes the first published autobiographical essay by Szasz and a complete bibliography of his writings.
The foremost opponent of psychiatric dogma, psychiatric practice, and the hubris of politicized medicine, Szasz has argued passionately and knowledgeably against compulsory commitment of the mentally ill, against the war on drugs, against the insanity defense in criminal trials, against the "diseasing" of addiction and homosexuality, and for the right to suicide.
His books include Sex by Prescription (1980), The Untamed Tongue (1990), Our Right to Drugs (1992), Cruel Compassion (1994), Fatal Freedom (1999), Pharmacracy (2001), and Liberation by Oppression (2002).
[Click here for high-resolution digital photograph of Szasz.]
"Anyone who has ever had qualms about the state giving psychiatrists the power to use drugs and civil commitment to control its citizens on the basis of 'mental illness' will be deeply rewarded by this stellar intellectual performance by Szasz, who not only holds his liberty-centered ground, but often gains more in direct and sometimes brutally frank responses to his critics and would-be reshapers of his life's work."
-GEORGE J. ANNAS
Professor and Chair, Department of Health, Bioethics, and Human Rights, Boston University School of Public Health, and author of The Rights of Patients
original link:
http://www.schaler.net/suf.html
Discuss this and related issues now:
http://www.boards2go.com/boards/board.cgi?action=read&id=1098404444&user=DBDouble
or, go to the general forum:
http://www.boards2go.com/boards/board.cgi?action=read&id=1098404444&user=DBDouble
Edited by Jeffrey A. Schaler
OPEN COURT PUBLISHERS
Chicago, Illinois
Distributed by Publishers Group West
ISBN 0-8126-9568-2
472 pages
Since he published The Myth of Mental Illness in 1961, Thomas Szasz has been a provocative and polarizing figure, bitterly denounced by some, lovingly defended by others, simultaneously baffling, exasperating, and entertaining to many.
In Szasz Under Fire, thirteen outstanding writers criticize Szasz's ideas on specific issues such as the reality of mental illness, physician-assisted suicide, addiction, and the insanity defense. Szasz replies to each criticism in detail, with his famous clarity, forcefulness, and occasional acerbity. Szasz Under Fire includes the first published autobiographical essay by Szasz and a complete bibliography of his writings.
The foremost opponent of psychiatric dogma, psychiatric practice, and the hubris of politicized medicine, Szasz has argued passionately and knowledgeably against compulsory commitment of the mentally ill, against the war on drugs, against the insanity defense in criminal trials, against the "diseasing" of addiction and homosexuality, and for the right to suicide.
His books include Sex by Prescription (1980), The Untamed Tongue (1990), Our Right to Drugs (1992), Cruel Compassion (1994), Fatal Freedom (1999), Pharmacracy (2001), and Liberation by Oppression (2002).
[Click here for high-resolution digital photograph of Szasz.]
"Anyone who has ever had qualms about the state giving psychiatrists the power to use drugs and civil commitment to control its citizens on the basis of 'mental illness' will be deeply rewarded by this stellar intellectual performance by Szasz, who not only holds his liberty-centered ground, but often gains more in direct and sometimes brutally frank responses to his critics and would-be reshapers of his life's work."
-GEORGE J. ANNAS
Professor and Chair, Department of Health, Bioethics, and Human Rights, Boston University School of Public Health, and author of The Rights of Patients
original link:
http://www.schaler.net/suf.html Discuss this and related issues now:
http://www.boards2go.com/boards/board.cgi?action=read&id=1098404444&user=DBDouble or, go to the general forum:
http://www.boards2go.com/boards/board.cgi?action=read&id=1098404444&user=DBDouble
Homepage:
Comments
Hide the following comment
Roll a dice?
22.10.2004 00:12
Though, from experiencd of ex-collegues, plenty of psychiatrist and psychologists abuse their power ( the ones I know make terrible bloody parents sending them off to boarding school, nannies, watch tv while I work etc. etc... ) and are frequently certifiable if to be judged using their own criteria.
Poillution, Cultural, diet, accidental/historical factors all have a part to play in the concept of what may be termedlumped in with conditions that are diverse and not necessarily particularly related such as "schizophrenia", "mental illness", "neurosis", "egotism", "anti-social behaviour", "extreme selfishness", "deviance", "exhibitionism", "shyness" etc etc etc etc. ad theory infinitum.
Why thing we can all be sure on. No fucker can explain "Being" outside of the language we all inhabit. We can try and help each other in this crazy " civilization (discuss that bloody word!) But we exist and if you try and bang your head any further you WILL HIT BEDROCK in amire of metaphysical crap 8-).
VIVA la revolution and don't let the bastards grind you down!
Foucault's Care In The Community disaster