These issues aside, OutRage! values the work of the PSC. We will continue to support its efforts to help secure a free Palestine. We hope that in return the PSC will work with us to pressure the PLO, Hamas and the PA to abandon their homophobia and create a truly liberated nation based on human rights for all.
The queer rights group OutRage! is "attempting to defame" the Palestine solidarity movement and is "damaging the cause of solidarity with Palestinians", according to the Palestine Solidarity Campaign (PSC).
The PSC made this claim in a letter to the left-wing Morning Star newspaper, published last Saturday, 5 June. It was objecting to OutRage!'s criticism of the officially-sanctioned persecution of queers in the Palestinian-controlled areas of Gaza and the West Bank, and to OutRage!'s revelation of attempts by PSC officials and stewards to silence this criticism.
Members of OutRage! joined the PSC demonstration in London on 15 May, supporting an end to Israel's human rights abuses against the Palestinians.
Contrary to claims by the PSC, we did not stage a "counter-demonstration". We were there in solidarity with the Palestinian struggle. Our placards said, "Israel: Stop persecuting Palestine".
But we also called for an end to the torture and murder of lesbians and gays by the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO), Hamas and the Palestinian Authority (PA). Our placards additionally read, "Palestine: Stop persecuting queers".
It was never our intention to disrupt the PSC rally or create a big commotion. We had a small, low-key presence. Our aim was to raise awareness. We wanted to alert the supporters of Palestine, in the hope they would help us pressure the Palestinian leadership to halt its oppression of queers.
What turned a minor presence into a major incident was the excessive response of the PSC organisers and stewards. They surrounded us, ordering us to the back of the demonstration. When we refused, they blocked out our placards with their own, obscuring our message. They also shouted us down, preventing us talking with journalists and other protesters who wanted to find out more about the suffering of queers in Palestine.
The PSC now denies this intimidation and censorship took place. But it was filmed by a Channel 4 documentary maker, Darren Lewey, and photographed by four professionals, including the respected left-wing and pro-Palestine photographer Paul Mattsson. They all corroborate OutRage!'s version of events.
In a bid to deflect criticism, the PSC has issued a statement saying it opposes homophobia. Fine words. But what has it done to challenge the violent homophobia of the PLO, Hamas and PA? I wrote to the PSC nine years ago, asking them to urge the PLO to stop killing queers. The PSC did nothing. I emailed the PSC office six weeks ago requesting dialogue. They never replied.
The PSC accuses OutRage! of damaging solidarity with the Palestinians. That's right PSC, blame the people who defend the victims, and let the oppressors off the hook. It is the PLO's and PA's homophobia that is damaging solidarity, by dividing gays and straights - both here and in Palestine.
While the PSC ignores the persecution of Palestinian queers and their pleas for help, OutRage! does not. We heard their appeals for solidarity and acted.
Astonishingly, the PSC letter in the Morning Star completely ignores the issue of PLO and PA violence against lesbians and gays. It offers not a word of sympathy to the victims of Palestinian homophobia, and makes no offer to raise the issue with the Palestinian authorities. The PSC is in deep and total denial. Yet again we seem to have a so-called progressive movement implying that queer lives are expendable for the sake of the greater good of a revolutionary struggle.
There is no doubt that Palestinian queers are the victims of horrendous homophobic violence. This is confirmed by the independent Israeli human rights groups B'Tselem and the Association for Civil Rights, and by the Israeli gay organisations, Aguda and Open House.
Two senior PLO officials have admitted to me privately that homophobic violence is sanctioned by the Palestinian leadership. Officially, the PLO refuses to discuss the matter. I have tried several times over the last 20 years to quietly and diplomatically raise this issue with the PLO. It has rejected all overtures and attempts at dialogue. That is why OutRage! had to protest. To do nothing would be collusion with homophobic tyranny.
The PSC implies that OutRage! has no right to campaign in solidarity with Palestinian queers, arguing that "Palestinian lesbians and gay men must be allowed to determine for themselves how they wage that struggle". We agree. That is why Outrage!, unlike the PSC, is not ignoring their desperate pleas for help.
I have supported the Palestinian struggle for national liberation for 30-plus years. But freedom for Palestine must be freedom for everyone - straight and gay. Unless we challenge the abuse of queer human rights now, homophobia will become entrenched in a new Palestinian state. If the PLO and PA get away with persecuting queers, they will also be emboldened to trample on the rights of other Palestinians too. Pressuring them to respect queer rights will help create a stronger human rights culture and that will
benefit all Palestinians.
These issues aside, OutRage! values the work of the PSC. We will continue to support its efforts to help secure a free Palestine. We hope that in return the PSC will work with us to pressure the PLO, Hamas and the PA to abandon their homophobia and create a truly liberated nation based on human rights for all.
The PSC made this claim in a letter to the left-wing Morning Star newspaper, published last Saturday, 5 June. It was objecting to OutRage!'s criticism of the officially-sanctioned persecution of queers in the Palestinian-controlled areas of Gaza and the West Bank, and to OutRage!'s revelation of attempts by PSC officials and stewards to silence this criticism.
Members of OutRage! joined the PSC demonstration in London on 15 May, supporting an end to Israel's human rights abuses against the Palestinians.
Contrary to claims by the PSC, we did not stage a "counter-demonstration". We were there in solidarity with the Palestinian struggle. Our placards said, "Israel: Stop persecuting Palestine".
But we also called for an end to the torture and murder of lesbians and gays by the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO), Hamas and the Palestinian Authority (PA). Our placards additionally read, "Palestine: Stop persecuting queers".
It was never our intention to disrupt the PSC rally or create a big commotion. We had a small, low-key presence. Our aim was to raise awareness. We wanted to alert the supporters of Palestine, in the hope they would help us pressure the Palestinian leadership to halt its oppression of queers.
What turned a minor presence into a major incident was the excessive response of the PSC organisers and stewards. They surrounded us, ordering us to the back of the demonstration. When we refused, they blocked out our placards with their own, obscuring our message. They also shouted us down, preventing us talking with journalists and other protesters who wanted to find out more about the suffering of queers in Palestine.
The PSC now denies this intimidation and censorship took place. But it was filmed by a Channel 4 documentary maker, Darren Lewey, and photographed by four professionals, including the respected left-wing and pro-Palestine photographer Paul Mattsson. They all corroborate OutRage!'s version of events.
In a bid to deflect criticism, the PSC has issued a statement saying it opposes homophobia. Fine words. But what has it done to challenge the violent homophobia of the PLO, Hamas and PA? I wrote to the PSC nine years ago, asking them to urge the PLO to stop killing queers. The PSC did nothing. I emailed the PSC office six weeks ago requesting dialogue. They never replied.
The PSC accuses OutRage! of damaging solidarity with the Palestinians. That's right PSC, blame the people who defend the victims, and let the oppressors off the hook. It is the PLO's and PA's homophobia that is damaging solidarity, by dividing gays and straights - both here and in Palestine.
While the PSC ignores the persecution of Palestinian queers and their pleas for help, OutRage! does not. We heard their appeals for solidarity and acted.
Astonishingly, the PSC letter in the Morning Star completely ignores the issue of PLO and PA violence against lesbians and gays. It offers not a word of sympathy to the victims of Palestinian homophobia, and makes no offer to raise the issue with the Palestinian authorities. The PSC is in deep and total denial. Yet again we seem to have a so-called progressive movement implying that queer lives are expendable for the sake of the greater good of a revolutionary struggle.
There is no doubt that Palestinian queers are the victims of horrendous homophobic violence. This is confirmed by the independent Israeli human rights groups B'Tselem and the Association for Civil Rights, and by the Israeli gay organisations, Aguda and Open House.
Two senior PLO officials have admitted to me privately that homophobic violence is sanctioned by the Palestinian leadership. Officially, the PLO refuses to discuss the matter. I have tried several times over the last 20 years to quietly and diplomatically raise this issue with the PLO. It has rejected all overtures and attempts at dialogue. That is why OutRage! had to protest. To do nothing would be collusion with homophobic tyranny.
The PSC implies that OutRage! has no right to campaign in solidarity with Palestinian queers, arguing that "Palestinian lesbians and gay men must be allowed to determine for themselves how they wage that struggle". We agree. That is why Outrage!, unlike the PSC, is not ignoring their desperate pleas for help.
I have supported the Palestinian struggle for national liberation for 30-plus years. But freedom for Palestine must be freedom for everyone - straight and gay. Unless we challenge the abuse of queer human rights now, homophobia will become entrenched in a new Palestinian state. If the PLO and PA get away with persecuting queers, they will also be emboldened to trample on the rights of other Palestinians too. Pressuring them to respect queer rights will help create a stronger human rights culture and that will
benefit all Palestinians.
These issues aside, OutRage! values the work of the PSC. We will continue to support its efforts to help secure a free Palestine. We hope that in return the PSC will work with us to pressure the PLO, Hamas and the PA to abandon their homophobia and create a truly liberated nation based on human rights for all.
e-mail:
Homepage:
Comments
Hide the following 3 comments
and?
15.06.2004 21:54
are outrage as outraged by jewish persecution of gays - will they draw attention to this? (eg: gay pride in jersualem - special forces on stand by to protect the mayor as reported in ha'aretz)
do outrage understand or comprehend the use of sexual abuse by israeli soldiers/interrogators as a tool of oppresion?
come on outrage, treat people as vaguely intelligent - don't give just a small part of the picture.
bandora
middle east
16.06.2004 10:18
the voice of common sense
for fucks sake Pete?!?!
17.06.2004 21:11
Do you really think Palestinians are going to give a shit about homophobia when they're victims of an ongoing genocide?
Tell me, what were your thoughts about global warming or vivisection during the occasions you were being beaten up or manhandled by Mugabe's men? Next outrage protest, remind the banner manufacturers to make plenty of "Save the Amazonian Mouse Flea" ones - and I'll come and hold all of them. Isn't the planet we live on and it's ecosystem ultimately more important than if a few humans get killed for their sexual preference? Or if you get on TV, again?
If you want to raise the issue of homophobia, why damage another campaign just for some flagrant publicity? Make the point that gay rights are not what they should be in the Arab world, but be distinct from a campaign in which you know, many people support your position, but who are sensible and not media seeking enough to keep their opinions to themselves.
When I talk with Palestinians about Abu Ghraib, a point they always mention is the disgusting homosexuality. I don't agree with them, I don't disagree with them, and this is not lost on people.
Please join my campaign requesting the people of Darfur to refrain from drinking milk as it offends my vegan sensibilities. I'm petitioning the Sudanese Embassy at 11am June 28th. See you there!!
And anyone who accuses me of being homophobic, please add anti-semitic and anti-American in the same sentence, as then I'll know to automatically ignore it.
Joel