Genocidal America
Phillip Slater | 12.11.2001 02:54
But if this is true — if Americans have always been genocidal, then the Vietnam conflict does not require any special explanation. Every society that has achieved a position of pre-eminence in the world has shown a remarkable capacity for brutality and violence — you don't get to be the bully of the block without using your fists.
I am arguing that Vietnam is different only because it occurred in the face of a host of what might be considered to be inhibiting factors — practical as well as moral —that have arisen in the past few decades. We know from vast experience, for example, that military force is ineffectual in changing attitudes, that air power is cruel but ineffectual against civilian populations, that colonial expeditionary forces are ineffectual against organized indigenous popular movements of any size and that military dictators cannot broaden their own base of support. . . . We helped to establish international principles in the U.N., at Geneva, and at Nuremberg, which we then violated or ignored. We live in a society in which the cruelties of war can be exposed in every living room through mass media. We discuss and debate constantly the appearance of any instance anywhere in the world of inhumane treatment of one person by another. We stress that every human life is a thing of value. We live, in short, in a modern, secure, civilized world, in which a single isolated act of violence is a calamity, an outrage. Yet we engage in the mass slaughter of innocent persons by the most barbarous means possible and show no qualms about it. . . . Since we are no longer crude frontiersmen or hillbillies what leads us to condone such savagery? When one observes that we devote the lion's share of our national budget to war and destruction, that capable scientists are tied up in biological and chemical warfare research that would make Frankenstein and his science-fiction colleagues look like Doctor Doolittle, we cannot avoid asking the question, do Americans hate life? Has there ever been a people who have destroyed so many living things?
The Pursuit of Loneliness: American Culture at the Breaking Point, pp. 33-34
Phillip Slater. Boston, Beacon Press. 1970
Phillip Slater
Comments
Display the following comment