Skip to content or view screen version

J30 - where are the class struggle anarchists?

The ghost of solidarity fetishism | 28.06.2011 16:13 | J30 Strike

For years class struggle anarchists in the UK have been waging war against lifestyle anarchists for the legitimacy of anarchist identity.

Previously lifestyle anarchists had their summit protests and 'big set pieces' much, being the most active, gaining the most attention, much to the chagrin of the class struggle anarchists who would emphasise, mostly on the internet, the importance of anarchists organising in their workplaces and in their communities. Class struggle anarchism became a badge of honour amongst anarchists who would distance themselves from any sort visible activity.

Class struggle anarchism was just waiting for their moment when the balance of class forces would mean their ideas would be relevant, and accessible to ordinary working class people.

Given most class struggle anarchists work in the public sector, and J30 is a genuine (i.e. universal) class conflict where the fuck are all the class struggle anarchists?

Do they exist? Are they a kind of inverse black bloc - they only come out when there is not class conflict to be seen on the streets? Where's the propaganda? The outreach? The organising in our workplaces? The communities of resistance?

Now should be the perfect opportunity for class struggle anarchists to stake a claim in the real world. And yet it is the lifestyle activism of UK Uncut who have ingratiated themselves with the trade unionists, with the media and with anybody who actually gives a shit about June 30th.

We say to the class struggle anarchists: WHERE ARE YOU? Stand up. Identify yourselves, make an impact, make some noise, you're not going to get a better opportunity.

The ghost of solidarity fetishism

Comments

Hide the following 9 comments

"Identify yourselves"

28.06.2011 16:48

LOL! good attempt.

Ghost of authority


where are they? what are they?

28.06.2011 17:44

Humans live of other humans, like a farmer lives of his cattle. That's the nature of human societies. A society is a pecking order, a social economic hierarchy.

'Class struggle anarchists' are those who struggle for status of their group, within the class structure, may be attempting to re-structure the social structure. They are not really 'anarchists' in the pure sense of the word, but very admirable, militant socialists.
They seek to control centralised production for the benefit of all, equally.

The much ridiculed 'life style anarchists' are those who try to live according to their principals of anarchy, living out side of and rejecting the socioeconomic structure of modern economic society. They reject the principal of centralised production altogether.

Pure philosophical anarchists won't be fighting government cuts because they reject government!

commentator


Where are they? At the grassroots, which is why you can't see them!

28.06.2011 18:08

Class struggle anarchists, true to their ideals, are doing just what they should be - building for the strike in their workplaces and neighbourhoods, working with unions and fellow workers to make it happen. They don't wear some kind of uniform! Also, you'll find leafleting while masked up has too many complications... :-P

anon


dumbed down indymedia?

28.06.2011 19:12

"Given most class struggle anarchists work in the public sector"

Do they? figures?

Shame the comment and analysis is very shallow as well as the piece itself.

Ongoing debates seem to have involved binary oppositions.

The social anarchists are calling the 'lifestyle anarchists' bourgeois
The insurrectionists are calling the social anarchists bourgeois
Reformist workerism production fetishism vs reclaiming our land
Activist ghettos vs 'engaging within your own community vs parachuting in...
Long term vs short term struggles...etc etc

Bit more complicated than the above innit!
as we know eh...

Many of us don't fit into comfortable categorisation nor like top down commands about what the anarchists need to do....

Revolution is problematic in a service economy ( ultimately a neo-fascist police state ) servicing the military industrial complex and corporate money markets fleecing the planet.

btw I don't want to be a cleaner or factory worker again or any other dumb shit slave job I've done for the fat nazi state we've sleepwalked into.





ex factory worker unemployed, landless and pissed off


hit the nail on the head

29.06.2011 00:41

Where are they? At the grassroots, which is why you can't see them!

28.06.2011 18:08
Class struggle anarchists, true to their ideals, are doing just what they should be - building for the strike in their workplaces and neighbourhoods, working with unions and fellow workers to make it happen. They don't wear some kind of uniform! Also, you'll find leafleting while masked up has too many complications... :-P

anon

=============================================

absolutely right mate.

Giuseppe Pinelli


Look and ye shall find

29.06.2011 13:54

You mean apart from helping organise the big Lewisham event, leafletting boroughs all over the city, actually being involved as strikers and agitating in workplaces and being about on the day you mean?

Just because we’re not showing up on the news or at your gaff doesn’t mean we aren’t around, it just means we’re not around in the places you usually frequent.

Rob Ray


He

29.06.2011 16:40

He's off sick!

Anon


beware of the anarchist

30.06.2011 08:51

Anarchists think that if we have a revolution -our capitalist, indiviudalist society will suddenly be able to stand on its own two feet because people will realise that "absolute power corrupts absolutley" and suddenly become enlightened. Sorry but people will not - what will happen is that there will be a dangerous survival if the fittest scenerio with everyone left to fend for themselves.

This is what is needed.
A revolution which demands that communites are put before profit.
A mass media which defends and supports a revolutionary process.
A governing body (yes a state or if it makes it more palatble to you an "assembly") which has the power and strength to defend a revolution and one that has the authority to plan for the economic welfare of its people.
A society which promotes local politcal particpation and cooperation between people for the benefit of society.

Only after a revoloutionary consciousness has been deeply embedded within the people -which would take 100s of years to develop -can more anarchist practices be considered. It is a process and we should be working with proper communists and socialist groups now to build this.

Anarchists are often dangerous because they will fight against socialists and communists in revolutionary situations out of misguided idealism.

why does everyone stay in the borders of their group


Get over yourself!

01.07.2011 12:52

Sorry but all I read in your 'article' was 'blah blah blah murray bookchin murray bookchin wank wank wank' Get off the computer and DO something instead of waffling on about different 'kinds' of 'anarchists'. If you want real change, go out and make it.

bored.com