Alex Calinicos "hissed" at NYC Conference
moose | 08.12.2001 19:12
Alex Callinicos, marxist extraordinaire, gets "hissed" at Globalization Conference in New York City.
Rumours that Alex Callinicos and the Solcialist Workers Party are getting away with their lies as they peddle them in the United States can be put to rest as many here are familiar with the misrepresentations of the SWP towards Genoa, especially within the issue of International Socialist Review. Recentty, at the Globalizaion and Resistence Conference in New York City, Callicinos was hissed as he took the podium at the closing plennary. Just a few hours before, Mr. Callinicos sat through one of the many discussions organized that day, a particular discussion because one of the speakers on the bill was a former member of the NYC Ya basta Collective (now disolved, stay tuned). She was in Genoa, and is Italian, very familiar with Negri's work, tute bianche, black block, etc. Mr Callinicos took notes, and based on this discussion (in which he said not a word) altered his plennary speech, ommitting comments that would have mirrored the feeling of his article in ISR.
Immediately after the plenary, Two individuals familiar with the article and the debate re: Genoa, confronted Mr. Callinicos, demanding he explain himself and why he equates Autonomia with Black Block, as connected historically. These individuals pointed out the hostility that many (not all, including the two confronters) anarchists and militant revolutionaries have with Negri and Autonomia (though also pointing out that this hostility rarely effects the unity anarchists have...).
Anyway, he lied and said he did not say what he obviously said. So these individuals showed him the text, word for word, as he wrote it. And suprise, he STILL denied it. As if his own words speak against the movements of his mouth!
The point is, Mr. Callinicos, and the SWP, and ISO, and other cooptational authoritarian alterior motive trot/com/len/marxist whatever groups, must be resisted in whatever fashion the time suits. Question them whenever you get a chance, openly, for all to see. Question them specifically on what they say in articles and secret memoranndum posted to the internet every now and then. Heckle them if they refuse to address criticisms of misrepresentation. Don't let they get away with it.
NYC
Immediately after the plenary, Two individuals familiar with the article and the debate re: Genoa, confronted Mr. Callinicos, demanding he explain himself and why he equates Autonomia with Black Block, as connected historically. These individuals pointed out the hostility that many (not all, including the two confronters) anarchists and militant revolutionaries have with Negri and Autonomia (though also pointing out that this hostility rarely effects the unity anarchists have...).
Anyway, he lied and said he did not say what he obviously said. So these individuals showed him the text, word for word, as he wrote it. And suprise, he STILL denied it. As if his own words speak against the movements of his mouth!
The point is, Mr. Callinicos, and the SWP, and ISO, and other cooptational authoritarian alterior motive trot/com/len/marxist whatever groups, must be resisted in whatever fashion the time suits. Question them whenever you get a chance, openly, for all to see. Question them specifically on what they say in articles and secret memoranndum posted to the internet every now and then. Heckle them if they refuse to address criticisms of misrepresentation. Don't let they get away with it.
NYC
moose
e-mail:
none
Comments
Hide the following 9 comments
Lying trot bastard.
08.12.2001 19:53
Ronnie.
Bandwagon jumpers
08.12.2001 20:11
It's quite striking that whenever anyone voices any criticism of groups like the SWP, SP et al they always pipe up saying that we shouldn't engage in sectarian bickering and work together in the name of "unity", as if they knew what the word meant. We're supposed to ignore what these people are doing and just pretend everything is cool, and that we really are a united movement as they try and take over everything. People should be free to voice criticism of the SWP because it's honest confrontation and debate that will win the day, not the underhand manipulation and control freakery that the SWP has perfected to a fine art.
As a Socialist I've come to the conclusion that terms like "Left" and "Right" are outdated, when after working with these people in the WSA (Welsh Socialist Alliance), I've come to the conclusion that they're Authoritarian in their political orientation and not Libertarian. They hold off working with people til the last minute and then they jump on the bandwagon, try and claim all the credit, and lecture people who disagree with their outdated politics. Nothing in this post surprises me, these people are one step away from Fascism, and the idea that they might hold power one day truly frightens me.
Jim
e-mail: serengoch@hotmail.com
Exactely
08.12.2001 21:59
ff
We can NEVER work with the SWP
08.12.2001 23:26
Don't engage with the bastards, ignore them on demos. Stop them from making long boring speeches in meetings. Don't let them have positions on committees, eg with the anti war movement at the moment. Stop these bandwaggon jumpers.
Every movement that let's them take over will be destroyed by these turncoats. Treat them as the vampires they are.
victor Serge
seems that Italians feel the same
08.12.2001 23:45
There have been articles on IMC Italy and the tone is very similar to here. One guy was saying "just wait, if those SWP
bastards come back here waving their flags and selling newspapers" they'll soon regret it !! or simla
seems that they are Internationally despised.
silvia
Narco babble
09.12.2001 10:18
The Multitude
e-mail: boundforflory@hotbot.com
Not 'just black block'
09.12.2001 13:28
I don't think they meant that. Just that the SWP is an authoritarian organised to take over everything (as they freely admit) organisation / political party, and as such you should view them as such.
I don't agree with stopping them speaking at meetings, their own or anyone elses.
-
its wot imc is about
09.12.2001 22:23
$X$
(swoon) what bravery!
10.12.2001 17:43
a nonny mouse