This Saturday sees a large anti-war march in central London, with the Stop The War Coalition marking five years since the largest demonstration in British history - against invading Iraq.
Below is Class War's open letter to the StWC leadership:
Five Years On - Why Are We Still Marching
IF MARCHING CHANGED ANYTHING THEY'D ABOLISH IT
Back in 2003 the Stop the War Coalition had two tactics to prevent war in Iraq: marching from A to B and then going home, and marching from B to A and then going home. Neither of these cunning plans worked, but they seemed so good to Tony Benn, Lindsey German and their friends it is all the StWC’s done to stop the war. This may let them claim the moral high ground: but how many divisions can that muster? Any superiority this might give them has, anyway, been squandered by their adherence to tactics which have failed to achieve their stated objectives. The British state has faced StWC down once and knows it can do so again if, for example, it chooses to partner the US in an attack on Iran.
ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS
Thankfully not all protestors followed the supine policies of the StWC. School and college students walked out of their institutions, disrupted traffic, and showed a willingness to wrestle with the police. When demonstrators travelled to disrupt the Fairford airbase, there was no ‘right’ to demonstrate, only the illegal actions of the police. Clearly they recognised the threat posed by direct action to the Government’s war plans, even if the StWC could not.
NO WAR BUT THE CLASS WAR
Gordon Brown is committed to the neo-conservative project. Those who celebrated Tony Blair’s resignation ought to consider that he handed over at a time of his choice to the successor of his choice who shares his politics. Britain remains in the missionary position and will remain so regardless of whether Bush, McCain, Obama or Clinton’s on top. Given this, a militant anti-war movement is as necessary as ever. Sadly the StWC is as impotent now as five years ago.
TALKING A GOOD FIGHT
To cover up its flaccid nature, the StWC has as many excuses as an incapable lover. Their 2008 pamphlet begins with the following astonishing claim by Viscount Stansgate (Tony Benn): ‘The Stop the War movement is the most powerful and influential popular political movement of my lifetime and possibly of any period of our history’. If the last five years have been a victory, we would have hated to see a defeat! Such lies can also be found amongst the witterings of the SWP leadership, with John Rees informing us that ‘Tony Blair was Britain’s worst ever prime minister’ (has he never heard of Margaret Thatcher?) and that ‘we [the StWC] had driven him out of office’. This is nothing short of collective delusion and helps explain why the 1.5 million marchers in 2003 have been followed by ever decreasing turnouts. Working class people are used to being lied to by mainstream politicians – we do not need such lies from the self-proclaimed leaders of the anti-war movement as well.
Given it has been such a flop when it matters, the Stop the War Coalition needs a good dose of Viagra. We are calling on demonstrators today to let the Stop the War Coalition leadership know their feeble approach satisfies only the state and the war-mongers.
PDF of the leaflet available here:
http://londonclasswar.org/newswire/media/3/20080311-five%20years%20on.pdf
Five Years On - Why Are We Still Marching
IF MARCHING CHANGED ANYTHING THEY'D ABOLISH IT
Back in 2003 the Stop the War Coalition had two tactics to prevent war in Iraq: marching from A to B and then going home, and marching from B to A and then going home. Neither of these cunning plans worked, but they seemed so good to Tony Benn, Lindsey German and their friends it is all the StWC’s done to stop the war. This may let them claim the moral high ground: but how many divisions can that muster? Any superiority this might give them has, anyway, been squandered by their adherence to tactics which have failed to achieve their stated objectives. The British state has faced StWC down once and knows it can do so again if, for example, it chooses to partner the US in an attack on Iran.
ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN WORDS
Thankfully not all protestors followed the supine policies of the StWC. School and college students walked out of their institutions, disrupted traffic, and showed a willingness to wrestle with the police. When demonstrators travelled to disrupt the Fairford airbase, there was no ‘right’ to demonstrate, only the illegal actions of the police. Clearly they recognised the threat posed by direct action to the Government’s war plans, even if the StWC could not.
NO WAR BUT THE CLASS WAR
Gordon Brown is committed to the neo-conservative project. Those who celebrated Tony Blair’s resignation ought to consider that he handed over at a time of his choice to the successor of his choice who shares his politics. Britain remains in the missionary position and will remain so regardless of whether Bush, McCain, Obama or Clinton’s on top. Given this, a militant anti-war movement is as necessary as ever. Sadly the StWC is as impotent now as five years ago.
TALKING A GOOD FIGHT
To cover up its flaccid nature, the StWC has as many excuses as an incapable lover. Their 2008 pamphlet begins with the following astonishing claim by Viscount Stansgate (Tony Benn): ‘The Stop the War movement is the most powerful and influential popular political movement of my lifetime and possibly of any period of our history’. If the last five years have been a victory, we would have hated to see a defeat! Such lies can also be found amongst the witterings of the SWP leadership, with John Rees informing us that ‘Tony Blair was Britain’s worst ever prime minister’ (has he never heard of Margaret Thatcher?) and that ‘we [the StWC] had driven him out of office’. This is nothing short of collective delusion and helps explain why the 1.5 million marchers in 2003 have been followed by ever decreasing turnouts. Working class people are used to being lied to by mainstream politicians – we do not need such lies from the self-proclaimed leaders of the anti-war movement as well.
Given it has been such a flop when it matters, the Stop the War Coalition needs a good dose of Viagra. We are calling on demonstrators today to let the Stop the War Coalition leadership know their feeble approach satisfies only the state and the war-mongers.
PDF of the leaflet available here:
http://londonclasswar.org/newswire/media/3/20080311-five%20years%20on.pdf
Homepage:
Comments
Hide the following 7 comments
If this fits the way YOU feel - come and join us this Saturday to hand them out…
12.03.2008 13:19
ACAB
11.45 Trafalgar Square.
12.03.2008 13:20
ACAB
Hmmm...
12.03.2008 14:25
@
If STWC believe
12.03.2008 15:29
The most likely reason for his premature and quite sudden exit is the cash for peerage enquiry thing, something that started by accident.
Unless he was too badly needed in Israel where he now spends most of his time, but I would not think so.
The change is only cosmetic anyway as both Brown and Milliband have been unapologetic about all decisions made by the Blair government they 100% supported in everything all along.
Just one example of that :
"Miliband: We would still have invaded Iraq with Gordon Brown in command"
skunk
did you know
13.03.2008 01:14
That it is the legal obligation of all citizens to withold those taxes until the war crimes are stopped and those responsible arrested and tried?
That it is the legal duty, and agreat way to have a little fun, for UK citizens to report the commission of war crimes of their government top the police so that they are forced to investigate?
Oh yes indeedy!
By obeying the law, one can bring down the corrupt, elitist, warmongering parties who have supported these wars and are war criminals.
It's merely a question of numbers!
Which law, did I hear you ask?
You didn't know? Don't you read? Pah!
It's The International Criminal Court Act 2001, as well as 6 international treaties ratified by the UK Government since 1928.
conor cruise 'missile' o'brien
Homepage:
http://www.makewarshistory.org.uk
Tired of machismo too
13.03.2008 14:36
Out trots the tired old line of 'Britain is America's poodle/bitch and that's why we went to war'. I'd expect Class War to realise that Britain might actually have one or two interests in going to war and securing a part of Iraq's resources for British business? Checked BP and Shell's profits recently? The British ruling class, like their counterparts in the US, are doing rather well thank you. The Iraq atrocity is more like a business partnership than a dominatory power relationship.
"One would hope that the expanded metaphor of the incapable lover needing a dose of Viagra to rid himself of his flaccid inability would be a joke. Sadly not. Yes what the anti-war movement needs to be is a class conscious hard cock."
I'm glad someone else picked up on this offensive shite. Sorry to spoil your war party boys, but did you think that maybe the all-penetrating phallus isn't really the most liberatory of images?
Tired of half-arsed analysis
hang on a sec
14.03.2008 23:10
can't let this go