London Indymedia

SOCPA - a send-off for ex-sergeant major edwin linton

rikki | 03.07.2006 01:21 | Indymedia | Repression | London

edwin is setting off on a 'freedom march' round britain, giving talks and meeting people along the way to publicise the massive restrictions on freedom that this government has been responsible for.

edwin, brian, and little friends
edwin, brian, and little friends

supporters gather to give him a happy send-off
supporters gather to give him a happy send-off

the first coins in his collection bucket
the first coins in his collection bucket


friends of edwin and supporters of brian haw came together today in parliament square this afternoon to give tribute to the ex-sergeant major as he sets off on his epic march round the country. his first target is to reach wales, where he will giev a series of talks.

edwin has been a staunch supporter of brian haw's for many months now, sleeping over at the square and helping protect brian from harm. he has now decided to do his 'outreach' project, as he is concerned that people outside london are even more oblivious to the government assaults on our freedoms than those in the capital.

some children helped start his collection bucket which he hopes will help fund his work. brian gave a short emotional speech thanking edwin for his care and support, and then, banner in hand and kitbag on his back, he set off in the blazing sunshine, heading west out of the square.

he will be missed.

rikki
- e-mail: rikkiindymedia@googlemail.com

Comments

Hide the following 17 comments

more socpa news including a short film

03.07.2006 13:20

rikki


He's a fake

04.07.2006 22:38

This man has never been what he claimed to be, a Scots Guard RSM. I don't know why he is pretending to be something he's not but feeding his delusion through publicity is hardly a responsible thing to do.

And am I the only one who finds the disappearing comments on this thread on the subject of this mans deception deeply ironic on a website that claims to fight censorship ?

Phil


a quick search reveals that...

04.07.2006 22:45

.... Edwin Linton has been around for some time, and that the claim that he was a RSM in the Royal Scots Guard goes back some years.

This newswire is for NEWS not half-arsed denials by people without any proof - that isn't news

scroogle


He's still a fake

04.07.2006 23:25

No matter how many times you delete comments this man is still a fake. And you are complete hypocrites for ignoring the truth in favour of your propaganda.

Get in touch with the Scots Guard Association, ask them if he's ever been a RSM. Guess what they'll tell you ?

He may have been living his fantasy for a while but that doesn't add any credence to his claims. Has he produced his "Red Book", the document soldiers get on leaving recording their service ? Have any other ex-soldiers come along to support him ? - you'd expect that, especially for a RSM.

And finally, look at the state of his dress. No RSM in the British Army would be seen dead as scruffy as that.

Phil


Never mind the RSM..

05.07.2006 07:23

What we all want to know, Phil, is why you feel it important to keep harping on about this.

benny


Phil has a point!

05.07.2006 08:57

The problem is the thought police at indymedia censor comments they don't agree with or feel embarass them, I pointed out this guy looks more like a tramp than a guards RSM and the comment was censored, why? So we will continue to harp on about something if all u do is censor us! (Wonder of this will get published?)

Paul


"looks more like a tramp than a guards RSM"

05.07.2006 09:09

No RSM has ever developed an alcohol problem before, have they? And ex-military are not over represented in the homeless population, are they?

Paul - Your comment stinks of a discriminatory viewpoint - which you'll find is one of the resons that an article or comment may get hidden.

fashion editor


Is he for real, if so he should be proud to prove it.

05.07.2006 09:57

Phil keeps harping on about it because it's important.

There seems to be rising number of 'incidents' where individuals claim an attachment or connection with the armed forces, in order to further there selfish and deluded ideals. They are dubbed 'Walts' by those who have served, and rightly want to protect the reputation of 'ex-service personnel'. If he is a proud ex-member of the armed forces, he should be more than happy to prove that he served. If not, then please don't use his misguided 'claims' to further this site's political aims.

Despite this, i do in principal agree with the protest about the decline in freedom of speech and the curb on civil liberties in Blairs Britain.

Milkybar Kid


Indymedia and the armed forces

05.07.2006 10:43

Protecting the 'integrity' of the armed services is a thankless task right now. Whilst 'our boys' rampage around Iraq and Afghanistan at the behest of evil idealogues, and are engaged in the commission of war crimes and 'losing hearts and minds' throughout swathes of the world, it comes as somewhat of a surprise that 'old soldiers' are so upset about the fact that Edwin Linton proudly proclaims his former career.

I say that the Milkybar Kid isn't the Milkybar Kid at all. By his reasoning he now needs to prove that he is. Otherwise his comment should be hidden.

Armed Forces Editor


Armed Foerces Editor

05.07.2006 11:35

Your title is a joke,as you have been so easily fooled by Linton you should not be trusted to write an article on the 'Balamory Armed Forces' yet alone the big stuff.
Research is everything so next time you publish drivel make sure it is authentic drivel.

Jim


Wear hoddin grey, an' a' that?

05.07.2006 21:49

The charity Shelter estimated that 25% of homeless people are ex-services. It is disingenuous to suggest a former soldier is bogus without further evidence simply for being forced to relax his own dress code. I leafletted an army event once and was surprised at soldiers coming up to me and complaining about the PNAC and unwinnable politically-motivated wars. If any of the soldiers - or walts - who have posted here condemning this man want to prove they are really concerned about their fellow soldiers, they should join Brian Haw themselves.

This anectdote is old and threadbare, but when I'd been leafletting the army event some RSM caught me and noticed I'd been skipping the posh cars and so bellowed at me 'YOU! HERE! NOW!' I duly trotted over, expecting a kicking, and he briefly looked at my leaflets and said 'YOU'VE MISSED HALF THE CARS - WHAT IS THE POINT OF HALF-DOING A JOB. GET BACK TO IT AND DO IT PROPERLY'

My point is peace-activists are a lazy, unfit bunch and if the military are expecting us to stop these senseless wars, then they'll be waiting a long time and a lot of soldiers will die senseless deaths. Now if you had some honour, and some respect for the weekly casualties, you be joining us and helping bring the troops home now rather than sniping at those who do.

Danny


SAS hero McNab: "talk to a Big Issue seller theres a good chance he's ex-forces"

05.07.2006 23:55

You may be interested to know that SAS Hero was interviewed by Andrew Neil on last week's 'This Week' shows on BBC1.

This is some of what he had to say:

"The Borrowers"

The fact is, our troops are inadequately equipped. They always have been. I've been in Operations where I had to steal grenades from American forces because we simply didn't have any. Maybe that's the reason why the British army is known as 'The Borrowers.'

(he also juxtaposed this appalling state of affairs and lack of priorities with the relative ease with which we can seem to find £20 billion for Trident, a weapons system that we can live without. Soldiers can't live without proper equipment.)

"No-one there to listen"

There are young men, some of them in their twenties, who have suffered both mentally and physically in operations from Northern Ireland to the Balkans and Iraq.

Friends of mine have committed suicide. There simply was no-one there to listen or assist them after the wars they'd fought in.

Very soon, we'll see others needing our help and support when they return from Afghanistan. Other countries respect and look after its soldiers. We don't.

If you talk to a Big Issue seller, there's a good chance he's ex-forces. I don't know of another country that would allow that to happen.

There are young men, some of them in their twenties, who have suffered both mentally and physically in operations from Northern Ireland to the Balkans and Iraq.

 http://news.bbc.co.uk/nolavconsole/ukfs_news/hi/bb_wm_fs.stm?news=1&bbram=1&bbwm=1&nbram=1&nbwm=1&nol_storyid=4860274

 http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/this_week/5132536.stm

Yehudi


What's all this about homeless people?

06.07.2006 20:45

Why are you gabbing away about homeless soldiers? He is not homeless and does not claim to be. Someone above stated that 'no RSM in the british army would be seen dead as scruffy as that'. Well done mate, you've established what was already in the article: Edwin is no longer in the British army. You're a freaking genius! Do you want a medal?

_Harrifer_


In reply

06.07.2006 22:09

Danny-

In reply, yes it is a widely known fact that a large percentage of the homeless population is made up of ex-members of the armed forces, and that this is a scandal. Men and women who serve and protect their country are left to deal with their problems (both mental and physical). As for serving soldiers' concern for homeless ex-colleagues, they would rather not join people like Brian Haw, as whilst making a small impact on the atmosphere around parliment, he and his associates have done nothing to help ex-soldiers. Instead they would prefer to take a course of action that is highly effective, the most popular being donating to the numerous ex-service personell charities, such as the RBL, Erskine and SSAFA who do sterling work with the small resources they can muster. This would be a far better way of suporting them, and in doing so help reduce the number of homeless people.

Yehudi-

The Uk armed forces have always had to put up with shortages in material and equipment, regardless of the colour of party in charge at no10. In our country that values social stability and security over defence, it's only to be expected. It's disingenuine to compare us to the Yanks. Their culture of millitary spending is SO different to ours. They rely on the military-industrial complex to support their economy (which is not weighed down by a welfare state). We do not, and as such cannot afford to spend along similar levels. In relation to the young men and women you mention, please refer to the paragraph above. Whilst the MOD and the govt do and are taking an almost laxidasical approach to the mental and physical well-being of our troops, there are groups working courageously to help them.

Harrifer-

You miss the point by a country mile mate! The man may leave the army, but the army never leaves the man. 17yrs of service in the Army molds someone so successfully that they do NOT give up their patterns. Continuing the structure and routine of Army life is s part of the coping mechanism that helps people deal with leaving.

Milkybar Kid


Homlessness

07.07.2006 02:00

Homelessness appears to have been mentioned because as recently as two years ago the subject of this news story WAS homeless as the article below (which originally appeared in The Guardian) demonstrates.

 http://216.239.59.104/search?q=cache:GEVz-0iLtosJ:www.leedshc.org.uk/news.html+%22edwin+linton%22+%22scots+guards%22&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=2&ie=UTF-8

(scroll down to the text highlighted in yellow and blue)

Ben


Something definitely doesn't add up here . . . .

07.07.2006 15:55

According to the article in the Muslim News at

 http://www.muslimnews.co.uk/news/news.php?article=11112

Mr. Linton is not only an ex RSM of the Scots Guards, but a Gulf War veteran to boot. Now I would never claim to be particularly good at maths, but from the dates supplied by Mr Linton in other articles, he was discharged from the forces at some point in late 1975 / early 1976 after 17 years service. It is somewhat unlikely that he took part in the Gulf War some 15 years after the Army dispensed with his services. Indeed, even had he stayed on and completed his 22 years colour service he would have left in 1982.

I have to say that 17 years service seems a very short period of time in which to reach the appointment of RSM, one imagines that he must have been some sort of wunderkind. It hardly seems likely that an alcoholic could have achieved such a feat, even one as apparently functional as Mr. Linton.

Finally, I have it on good authority that the Scots Guards Association have never heard of the gentleman, and one would certainly expect them to remember such an important personage as an RSM.

Flipper T Rox


No, the dates certainly don't add up.

08.07.2006 00:57

No, the dates certainly don't add up. It certainly seems unlikely he is a Gulf Veteran. Attributing to him Gulf War Veteran status could be an entirely innocent mistake on the part of Muslim News.

As for any government or associate body revealing or confirming that someone was, wasn't or is in the armed forces, I doubt very much whether that is a practice that does go on, should go on or be encouraged or condoned. Not in the public domain.

The security implications for the soldier or former soldier concerned are obvious. Publicly revealing that you were formally employed within the military should be a matter for the individual themselves to decide. Not for treacherous and insidious back channel sources and briefings to either confirm or deny.

Assuming for a moment that it is true that the Scots Guards Association have records of everyone who has ever served in the Scots Guards, and that they have checked those records as you seem to be inferring, why exactly did they feel permitted or authorised to do that? Has Mr Linton made such a request? Haven't the Scots Guards ever heard of a little thing called the Data Protection Act?

Soldiers who have served their country are entitled to confidentiality throughout their careers and long after they've left the service. The fact that they're engaged in anti-war activities post-military that might be seen as embarassing by the government does not justify attempting to besmirch their character, integrity and honesty.

Lawrence Livermore


Kollektives

Birmingham
Cambridge
Liverpool
London
Oxford
Sheffield
South Coast
Wales
World

Other UK IMCs
Bristol/South West
London
Northern Indymedia
Scotland

London Topics

Afghanistan
Analysis
Animal Liberation
Anti-Nuclear
Anti-militarism
Anti-racism
Bio-technology
Climate Chaos
Culture
Ecology
Education
Energy Crisis
Fracking
Free Spaces
Gender
Globalisation
Health
History
Indymedia
Iraq
Migration
Ocean Defence
Other Press
Palestine
Policing
Public sector cuts
Repression
Social Struggles
Technology
Terror War
Workers' Movements
Zapatista

London IMC

Desktop

About | Contact
Mission Statement
Editorial Guidelines
Publish | Help

Search :