They won! Anti-Militarist Court Solidarity
(A) | 16.01.2015 15:08 | Anti-militarism | Palestine | Wales
On the 6th of January 2015 two local people stood trial, accused of disrupting last year’s Defence Procurement, Research, Technology & Exportability (DPRTE) Arms Fair, now an annual occurrence in Cardiff.
The defendants were accused of throwing red paint at delegates entering the fair, damaging their luxury goods worth hundreds of hundreds of pounds. They were charged with Criminal Damage and breach of s.4A of the Public Order Act (“Causing harassment, alarm or distress with intent”). They were advised that the prosecution would be seeking custodial sentences.
The defendants sought to run separate, distinct defenses. The first was to put forward a factual defense that the police had grabbed him and wrestled him to the ground for no reason. The second defendant contended that they had been acting out of necessity in an attempt to prevent war crimes based on the arms fair’s various links to Israel and the horrific attacks against Gaza that took place over the summer, in the context of the continuing oppression of the Palestinian people.
Before the trial started some 30 supporters gathered outside Cardiff Magistrates court for a solidarity demonstration with the two defendants. Several groups came out to support, including Food not Bombs Cardiff, Anarchist Action Network, Afed Bristol, Cor Cochion Caerdydd, Bristol Defendant Solidarity, Bristol Against the Arms Trade, disarmUWE as well as South Wales Anarchists.
Throughout the day defendants and their supporters were followed and surveiled by Police Liaison Officers, who largely failed in their documented intelligence gathering role since all attendees wisely declined to engage with them from the outset.
Court proceedings were delayed for hours as there was no prosecutor – the Crown Prosecution Service was called and the prosecutor who had been appointed to the case said he knew nothing about it. A replacement prosecutor was then speeded to the court.
As the arms dealers and lay prosecution witnesses had also failed to turn up, the prosecution sought to amend the charge to Criminal Damage of the arresting officer’s uniform. One of the police witnesses had claimed paint damage to his uniform – which surely, if it had occurred, would have been the result of manhandling and grabbing the defendants when they were arrested. The District Judge said that this was “moving the goalposts” considerably and that Criminal Damage by paint transfer during an arrest when the police grabbed the defendants would be “ludicrous”.
After lunch the CPS informed us that it would drop all charges. The many supporters in the public gallery broke out into applause and the judge scolded them saying “this is NOT a football stadium!”.
The DPRTE arms fair will be returning to Cardiff Motorpoint Arena on the 8th of March 2016. To flog their machines of torture and death. The people of Cardiff and beyond stand ready to oppose them and we ask that you will join us.
For more info on how to get involved with the campaign against DPRTE arms fair, email: stopnatocymru@riseup.net
The defendants were accused of throwing red paint at delegates entering the fair, damaging their luxury goods worth hundreds of hundreds of pounds. They were charged with Criminal Damage and breach of s.4A of the Public Order Act (“Causing harassment, alarm or distress with intent”). They were advised that the prosecution would be seeking custodial sentences.
The defendants sought to run separate, distinct defenses. The first was to put forward a factual defense that the police had grabbed him and wrestled him to the ground for no reason. The second defendant contended that they had been acting out of necessity in an attempt to prevent war crimes based on the arms fair’s various links to Israel and the horrific attacks against Gaza that took place over the summer, in the context of the continuing oppression of the Palestinian people.
Before the trial started some 30 supporters gathered outside Cardiff Magistrates court for a solidarity demonstration with the two defendants. Several groups came out to support, including Food not Bombs Cardiff, Anarchist Action Network, Afed Bristol, Cor Cochion Caerdydd, Bristol Defendant Solidarity, Bristol Against the Arms Trade, disarmUWE as well as South Wales Anarchists.
Throughout the day defendants and their supporters were followed and surveiled by Police Liaison Officers, who largely failed in their documented intelligence gathering role since all attendees wisely declined to engage with them from the outset.
Court proceedings were delayed for hours as there was no prosecutor – the Crown Prosecution Service was called and the prosecutor who had been appointed to the case said he knew nothing about it. A replacement prosecutor was then speeded to the court.
As the arms dealers and lay prosecution witnesses had also failed to turn up, the prosecution sought to amend the charge to Criminal Damage of the arresting officer’s uniform. One of the police witnesses had claimed paint damage to his uniform – which surely, if it had occurred, would have been the result of manhandling and grabbing the defendants when they were arrested. The District Judge said that this was “moving the goalposts” considerably and that Criminal Damage by paint transfer during an arrest when the police grabbed the defendants would be “ludicrous”.
After lunch the CPS informed us that it would drop all charges. The many supporters in the public gallery broke out into applause and the judge scolded them saying “this is NOT a football stadium!”.
The DPRTE arms fair will be returning to Cardiff Motorpoint Arena on the 8th of March 2016. To flog their machines of torture and death. The people of Cardiff and beyond stand ready to oppose them and we ask that you will join us.
For more info on how to get involved with the campaign against DPRTE arms fair, email: stopnatocymru@riseup.net
(A)
Comments
Hide 8 hidden comments or hide all comments
Further information
17.01.2015 09:29
www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2014/10/518431.html?c=all
Furthermore the protests had no effect whatsover on the event with the protest and the protesters being openly ridiculed by BAE Systems staff on their blog. Arms dealers don't give a monkeys about being shouted at by what they refer to as "the great unwashed". Unless we are changing things we are simply wasting our time with these protests because they are clearly making no difference to the organisers, the exhibitors or the attendees.
Jake
Well done
17.01.2015 12:11
@
Good for you and well done to all !
18.01.2015 14:58
Second comment, the quote from the blog of some nob at BAe systems shows part of the problem with current protests against the arms trade, they don't care about us and are not scared of what we might do. In the glory days of DSEI protest a few years ago I remember taking satisfaction from seeing fear on the face of arms dealers when we confronted them at Custom House DLR station but at the last DSEI they stood there and laughed at us. Support for actions against the arms industry is falling all across the country and for some events has stopped completely (there was nobody apart from me and one other protestor at Farnborough Air Show this year).
I have no answers, only observations and questions but I see this as part of a much bigger problem with radical politics in this country. The decline of AR activity, the lack of support last year for DSEI protests, the very few number of people prepared to stand up against the Tory austerity cuts, the lack of protest against the slow privatisation of the NHS, the rise of the far right UKIP with little comment. The Left continues to worry more about fighting itself rather than the Tories.
Silent supporter
Misinformation - Classic Indymedia style
19.01.2015 12:26
(A)
Misinformation ? I think not
19.01.2015 14:06
"Those caught in the paint attack were Mr D Solitan and Mr L Evans of Absolute Taste Catering, St Nicholas Market, 1-3 Exchange Avenue, St Nicholas Market, Bristol, BS1 1JP a company under contract to the Cardiff Motorpoint Arena (hosts of the event). Mr Solitan sustained damage to a suit jacket and shirt, Mr Evans to a casual cotton jacket."
Stop trying to cover up the fact you screwed up here and lying about it. There is nothing wrong in making a mistake but presenting it as some sort of victory against the 'man' makes you look stupid. You had a go at protersting the event, that's good - well done however you messed it up and got the wrong people. Time for reality.
Legal eagle
Misinformation
19.01.2015 14:10
(A)
@ (A)
19.01.2015 15:20
That's the problem with the online court papers system people have the opportunity to double check bullshit like yours
LOL !
Legal eagle
More detailed info
20.01.2015 18:37
www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2014/10/518431.html?c=all
Furthermore the protests had no effect whatsover on the event with the protest and the protesters being openly ridiculed by BAE Systems staff on their blog. Arms dealers don't give a monkeys about being shouted at by what they refer to as "the great unwashed". Unless we are changing things we are simply wasting our time with these protests because they are clearly making no difference to the organisers, the exhibitors or the attendees.
Reposter
Homepage: www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2014/10/518431.html?c=all
still not right
21.01.2015 13:55
next time
Hide 8 hidden comments or hide all comments