Skip to content or view screen version

DSEI protests, why was there so little support ?

anon@indymedia.org (Craven A) | 20.09.2013 10:55

Having returned home to Nottingham from time in London protesting the DSEI Arms Fair I wanted to give my report and observations.

DSEI 2013 was the fourth DSEI arms fair I have protested outside, the sickening site of well fed and smug arms dealers engaging in deals that will lead to maimings and the death of thousands never fails to move me to the point of vomit.

 

How could anybody not be moved to action by this I have always thought and yet every DSEI the level of protest and the numbers of those standing outside has declined. DESI 2013 had at most 150 people when the first DSEI I attended had close to 2000 with various complimentry actions at other sites. We protested the arms dealers dinner and there was about 15 of us despite the venue being well known and shared weeks in advance !

I spoke with one of the coppers in duty and he said the police numbers were also the lowest ever because, "there are hardly any protestors these days" He was a bit upset because there were no longer the overtime opportunities there once were at DSEI.

I'm not claiming to have any answers to the problem and I will always attend DESI as long as it exists even if I am the only person standing there, these bastards must not think their work is acceptable in our society but I wonder of we are having any effect on the event at all. The level of disruption we caused was minimal, the blockades we tried to set up inconvinienced nobody and the arms dealers clearly did not give a toss about us or what we had to say. Local people I spoke with were now resigned to the event every two years and several welcomed it because there was some casual work that it seemed was quite well paid. The number of exhibitors and attendees was the highest ever for a DSEI so clearly we are not influencing the event itself and we are not doing much to change minds in the local area.

 

Where are we going wrong, I simply have no idea but if I read one more post or website congratulating us on a job well done I will scream with frustration.

 


anon@indymedia.org (Craven A)
- http://nottingham.indymedia.org/articles/6025

Comments

Hide 3 hidden comments or hide all comments

sorry to say

20.09.2013 16:46

Direct action/protest of this type seems to change very little, of course there are some amazing examples every now and then, but on the whole its not working.I also have no answers and have in the past out of complete fustration have blocked nuclear bases etc.
Like you I think it is disgraceful that such a huge arms 'fair' has happended. I hope we all wake up soon.
peace,love&solidarity

also&as well


It's about effectiveness

21.09.2013 08:51

Direct action almost always wins - so long as sufficient force is used against a sufficiently weak target. For example, blockading all the stores in a chain, every weekend, for two months is almost guaranteed to stop them using workfare - because of loss of profits and bad publicity. Blockading an arms fair for one day, on the other hand is almost guaranteed to fail - even with 2000 people doing all they can to mess with it. You would need properly massive numbers of up-for-it people to make any kind of dent on the arms trade.

While I do agree that a 2000-strong demonstration against arms dealers this year would have been nice, it would also have been entirely symbolic. It's really clear, I think, why that isn't worth making happen today. For one thing, we're in a financial crisis. A lot of people are in desperate need, and I think they would rather use direct action to make their lives better - fighting for small acheivable aims - instead of getting nicked for the sake of symbolism. For another, to make a mass demonstration happen you need to organise around issues that directly affect people, and the arms trade just isn't doing that in the UK right now.

In 2000 it made sense to draw attention to the horrors of capitalism by moralising - people were doing pretty well economically, and telling everyone that capitalism was opressing them and ruining their lives wasn't easy. Now in 2013 things are different. There is a *real* possibility of a millitant mass movement which in time may spill over into attacking the millitary-industrial complex directly, but right now desperately needs anarchists to mobilise at the grassroots and build community resistance. Why should activists burn themselves out for the sake of symbolism when there is important work that desperately needs doing?

At the end of the day, there is no way to challenge the millitary-industrial complex without an international mass movement. So, I would urge you to put your energy into fighting the cuts and empowering communities - this is the only way we will ever stop the likes of desi for good!

Oh, and while we're on the topic - lets remember that we live in a "first world" nation here. The people directly affected by the arms trade are very far away. Is our protest on their behalf empowering and encouraging them, or propagating the imperialist idea that a few white british people can fix things for everyone else? Just saying...

(I understand this is all going to be hard to hear as it sounds like you have put a lot of energy into fighting the arms trade. This is good work, but you did ask why people aren't joining you and I thought I should explain why I am not. In general I would rather not criticise other activists in a time like this where the state is desperately trying to divide and rule us. But your article was basically criticising me first, so I felt it was important to respond.)

anon


location

21.09.2013 15:37

Having been involved in the 2001 and 2003 actions the most obvious problem with attempting to stop, rather than protest, DSEI is the location. An electrified railway on one side, Victoria dock on the other, leaving two tiny strips of land as the only way in ( and easy for the cops to defend.) Anyone know any suicidal pilots?

x


Excellent piece

22.09.2013 10:10

Yup, pretty much echoes my own thoughts and the thoughts of others that I've talked to about why the DSEi and other arms trades are not 'mass' actions. The arms trade is currently a distraction and a bad place to put energy for radicals and I think people know that.

The complication is that there are a few small NGOs and organisations that have the arms trade as their remit so they are always going to work on it as a issue whether or not it's a strategic place for revolutionaries to put their time.

We should recognise that these NGOs and people should not be allowed to set the direction and strategy for the rest of us.

Another @


Hidden Comment

This posting has been hidden because it breaches the Indymedia UK (IMC UK) Editorial Guidelines.

IMC UK is an interactive site offering inclusive participation. All postings to the open publishing newswire are the responsibility of the individual authors and not of IMC UK. Although IMC UK volunteers attempt to ensure accuracy of the newswire, they take no responsibility legal or otherwise for the contents of the open publishing site. Mention of external web sites or services is for information purposes only and constitutes neither an endorsement nor a recommendation.

DSEI, why we are winning

22.09.2013 10:45

Although numbers were a little down on previous years people can be happy in the knowledge that we are winning the battle to close DSEI. The protests this year were just the start of the campign to stop DSEI 2015. The local community is with us, the wider public is with us and only the Tory led support for the show from the Military Industrial complex allows it to stay open.

DSEI 2013 required thousands of police at massive expense to the public to prevent activists closing the Excel centre, the arms dealers cowered in fear behind a wall of steel to go about their business too frightened to face us on the streets. Young, old, men women, trans, Muslim, Christian and none of the above stood shoulder to shoulder proud and fearless in the face of police violence and oppression.

Everyone of them is a hero.

Toni
mail e-mail: info@dsei.org
- Homepage: www.dsei.org


At Toni

22.09.2013 17:38

Yours is a perfect example of a slightly delusional perspective of what happened on the day, and views like that are partly responsible for derailing stratgetic thinking.

Stop obsessing about important 'your' campaign is, stop saying everything that happens is a victory no matter how rubbish and ineffective it actually is.

@


Hidden Comment

This posting has been hidden because it breaches the Indymedia UK (IMC UK) Editorial Guidelines.

IMC UK is an interactive site offering inclusive participation. All postings to the open publishing newswire are the responsibility of the individual authors and not of IMC UK. Although IMC UK volunteers attempt to ensure accuracy of the newswire, they take no responsibility legal or otherwise for the contents of the open publishing site. Mention of external web sites or services is for information purposes only and constitutes neither an endorsement nor a recommendation.

Part of the problem

23.09.2013 07:31

One of the Disarm DSEI crew wrote,

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"the arms dealers cowered in fear behind a wall of steel to go about their business too frightened to face us on the streets"
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That is simply delusional. Let's look at the facts for a moment. Most of the dealers are former military, these are not the sort of people to be intimidated by some individuals waving banners and shouting slogans. The number of people protesting DSEI this year was the lowest ever, when I was there on Wednesday there was less than 100 people at the West entrance (compare that to the 30,000 arms dealers who visited this year) and at the end of the day when many of the dealers were leaving the number of us still there were down to about 15 !!

Disarm DESI does not do itself any favours with statements like the one above which is why myself and other friends chose to work independetly of them this year.

A


Hidden Comment

This posting has been hidden because it breaches the Indymedia UK (IMC UK) Editorial Guidelines.

IMC UK is an interactive site offering inclusive participation. All postings to the open publishing newswire are the responsibility of the individual authors and not of IMC UK. Although IMC UK volunteers attempt to ensure accuracy of the newswire, they take no responsibility legal or otherwise for the contents of the open publishing site. Mention of external web sites or services is for information purposes only and constitutes neither an endorsement nor a recommendation.

Returning to the original point, why the lack of support

23.09.2013 11:23

In my view the fall in support for anti arms trade work mirrors the fall in support for animal rights work and for similair reasons. Both these causes are what might be called 'boutique' in that they draw support when people have no other issues to worry about however with the current economic crises, the bedroom tax, the attacks on squaters etc people do not have time for these 'tier 2' campaigns

Tyler


useful comments

24.09.2013 09:35

It's been interesting to read the comments to this article and I think it is important that we all discuss those things. However, I think people get involved in particular parts of the struggle for a variety of reasons. Both sides have got a point, but I am unlikely to stop longterm anti-arms trade activism because something else comes along. I have seen many great campaigns fall due to the fact that people leave a persistent campaign and temporarily join a new movement which appears to have more energy for a while. All parts are important. For me, opposing the arms trade and opposing the cuts or whatever at home is the same, and proper outreach/grass roots organising will expose this.. The people affected by weapons far away are as important to me as any challenges we face here.

To 'anon' who wrote:
'Oh, and while we're on the topic - lets remember that we live in a "first world" nation here. The people directly affected by the arms trade are very far away. Is our protest on their behalf empowering and encouraging them, or propagating the imperialist idea that a few white british people can fix things for everyone else? Just saying...'

This relates to my previous point. During DSEi there were groups from Bahrain and Turkey etc involved, who have been at the receiving end of many weapons sold at DSEi. And people from Palestine have asked me numerous times to work against the arms trade where I am. For me this is called international solidarity, not imperialism. The imperialst element would be these people being bombed by weapons which have been exported from here unopposed. As far away as people may be (as if that mattered) they are often friends and people struggling for the same thing.

Having said all that, there is no reason you can't do both. Most activist I know are not just involved in one thing. Lets support each other in any small way we can and not just try to convince everone to work on whatever we have most energy to focus on at the moment.

Disarmer


Hide 3 hidden comments or hide all comments