EDL arrest over Manchester police killings
EDLnews | 21.09.2012 14:22 | Anti-racism | Other Press | Policing
According to reports in the Daily Telegraph, an EDL supporter has been arrested in connection with the killing of two female police officers in a gun and grenade attack in Manchester eariler this week.
Pcs Nicola Hughes and Fiona Bone were alledegly lured to their deaths by Dale Cregan and Stephen Garvey has been arrested on suspicion of making the phone call.
They reported:
Stephen Garvey, 28, was arrested on Wednesday for conspiracy to murder the female police officers and is being questioned over making the hoax phone call which lured the women to their deaths.
Garvey, a Manchester City fan, lives on the Hattersley estate in Mottram, Greater Manchester, and lists himself as a fan of the English Defence League, the right-wing organisation, on his Facebook page.
Pictures have emerged of Garvey and friends making Hitler salutes
They reported:
Stephen Garvey, 28, was arrested on Wednesday for conspiracy to murder the female police officers and is being questioned over making the hoax phone call which lured the women to their deaths.
Garvey, a Manchester City fan, lives on the Hattersley estate in Mottram, Greater Manchester, and lists himself as a fan of the English Defence League, the right-wing organisation, on his Facebook page.
Pictures have emerged of Garvey and friends making Hitler salutes
EDLnews
Homepage:
http://edlnews.co.uk/index.php/latest-news/latest-news/837-edl-member-arrested-over-manchester-police-killings
Comments
Hide 12 hidden comments or hide all comments
Why would Indymedia want to censor an article exposing a Fascist?!
21.09.2012 16:58
http://www.indymedia.co.uk/en/2012/09/500376.html
GH
The photos
21.09.2012 17:00
http://www.indymedia.co.uk/images/2012/09/500378.jpg
GH
GH
21.09.2012 17:17
If your story is censored. how is that you are able to link to it?
EDLnews did a better job than you of reporting the story.
IMCista
man city
21.09.2012 20:52
anon
old news
21.09.2012 22:24
50% oxygen
Well spotted
21.09.2012 22:43
Stephen Garvey has been released without charge - well I guess that's a moral victory for Indymedia then - but for Anti-Fascists however, the least outcome of Garvey's arrest is that it exposed another Sieg Heiling Nazi
Cityscape
Nowhere does it say EDL
21.09.2012 22:44
Follow the links provided, numb-nuts
City
@IMCista - If your story is censored, how is that you are able to link to it?
21.09.2012 23:14
You say that "EDLnews did a better job than you of reporting the story"? In fact the info that IMC spiked WAS the EDLnews story, however the version the Indy mods havn't spiked was the one (above) that did not include the evidence proving the link between this Sieg Heiling Nazi and the EDL, while the version the Indy mods did spike was the version that did include that evidence, which is why that evidence had to be re-linked here in the comments above.
Have a nice day
Poltergeist
You're the "IMCista"
21.09.2012 23:16
Paul T Guest
Do me the courtesy of reading this carefully before censoring it
22.09.2012 00:32
The first problem is that whenever it's pointed-out how much easier and cheaper it is for people who want to discredit radicalism to post black propaganda on Indymedia than it is for them to employ undercover agents, rather than responding to the comments, Indymedia spike (most of) the posts, effectively giving the trolls an open field of play. The second problem is that Indy mods spike articles which suggest radicals engage with moderate groups on grounds those groups are hierarchical (which is fair to a point), but then allow violent hooligan, criminal and (ultra-hierarchical) terrorist shit that completely ruins any chance of radical politics crossing-over out of the activist ghetto.
When disaffected people tentatively explore radical politics, they come across bollocks like that, assume radicals are dangerous wankers, and lose interest. Hence the pitiful size of eg - all the Anarchist groups in the UK that havn't already collapsed, and the near total failure of the UK radical movement to capitalise on the biggest crisis in world capitalism for decades. The nature of the vicious circle is that if activist groups don't want to waste any of the public interest that they attract then they have to become more organised, in becoming more organised they become more hierarchical, meaning IMC's operating philosophy ultimately prevents the mods (who are themselves a hierarchy relative to ordinary IMC users) having to run the risk of stepping outside the radical ghetto / comfort zone by actually risking success.
Don't get me wrong, Indymedia is a very useful resource, but the problems are first that it's useful to all sorts of people, not just to radicals, and second that there is sometimes an unconscious logic of self-defeating psychology at play, meaning a style of operating which helps support the radical SCENE at the expense of progressing actual radical POLITICS.
Back to the specifics in question, in this case the deal is that not only is Indymedia being used to link radical politics with extreme acts of anti-social violence, in this case Indymedia's also being used to celebrate violence against women
Paula
Violence against women
22.09.2012 00:50
https://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2012/09/500333.html
Paz
released
22.09.2012 06:33
tim
no chage
22.09.2012 06:40
mir
Indymedia logic
22.09.2012 11:10
Anti-Fascist
IMC operating policy
22.09.2012 11:30
The first problem is that whenever it's pointed-out how much easier and cheaper it is for people who want to discredit radicalism to post black propaganda on Indymedia than it is for them to employ undercover agents, rather than responding to the comments, Indymedia spike most of the posts, effectively giving the trolls an open field of play. The second problem is that Indy mods spike articles which suggest radicals engage with moderate groups on grounds those groups are hierarchical (which is fair to a point), but then allow violent hooligan, criminal and (ultra-hierarchical) terrorist shit that completely ruins any chance of radical politics crossing-over out of the activist ghetto.
When disaffected people tentatively explore radical politics, they come across bollocks like that, assume radicals are dangerous, stupid, irresponsible wankers, and lose interest. Hence the pitiful size of eg - all the Anarchist groups in the UK that havn't already collapsed, and the near total failure of the UK radical movement to capitalise on the biggest crisis in world capitalism for decades. The nature of the vicious circle is that if activist groups don't want to waste any of the public interest they attract then they have to become better organised, in becoming more organised they become more hierarchical, meaning IMC's operating philosophy ultimately prevents the mods (who are themselves a hierarchy relative to ordinary IMC users) having to run the risk of stepping outside the radical ghetto / comfort zone by actually risking contact with people who don't share their views. When confronted with such arguments, the IMC mods' approach is, yet again, to keep on deleting these problems instead of debating them.
Don't get me wrong, Indymedia is a very useful resource, but the problems are first that it's useful to all sorts of people, not just to radicals, and second that there is sometimes an unconscious logic of self-defeating psychology at play, meaning a style of operating which helps support the radical SCENE at the expense of progressing actual radical POLITICS. Back to the specifics in question, the 3rd problem is that in this case not only is Indymedia being used to link radical politics with extreme acts of anti-social violence, in this case Indymedia's also being used to celebrate violence against women –
https://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2012/09/500333.html
Shoals
Moderation on this site
22.09.2012 11:56
Editorial Guidelines
IMCista
re: violence against women
23.09.2012 13:19
That is an interesting question - is it always unacceptable for men to perpetrate violence against women? What about a male anti-fascist attacking a female neo-nazi for example? Or a male assassin targeting a female politician or wealthy businesswoman for ideological reasons?
Does the female neo-nazi's gender trump her fascism?
Maybe female fascists etc. should always be attacked only by female anti-fascists?
anon
Christ I wish Indymedia was moderated by grown-ups
02.10.2012 05:38
You - IMC moderators - know what the real issue is with this and other threads, readers won't be able to tell what that issue is because you deleted the comments, I won't mention the issue again because, yes sir-ee your constant censorship forces me to defer to your superior judgement, for fear of this comment disappearing as well! Forelock duly tugged, you "won", as regards the issue you successfully covered-up, but the underlying damage you continue to cause is, unfortunately, permanent
Another Sieg Heiling Nazi exposed
Hide 12 hidden comments or hide all comments