Skip to content or view screen version

EDL leader agrees with Anders Breivik, but psychiatrists declare Breivik insane

Jai | 01.12.2011 13:22 | Anti-racism | World

The terrorist Anders Breivik has now been certified as psychotically insane. However, English Defence League leader Stephen Yaxley-Lennon (aka “Tommy Robinson”) is on record as stating that the EDL leadership share the killer’s opinions.

This article is published in conjunction with Pickled Politics ( http://www.pickledpolitics.com) and EDL News ( http://edlnews.co.uk/)

The mass-murdering Norwegian terrorist Anders Breivik has been declared insane (see:  http://news.sky.com/home/world-news/article/16120049). In a 243-page psychiatric report following 13 meetings between Breivik and a team of psychiatrists, Breivik has been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, a severe psychotic mental disorder (see:  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paranoid_schizophrenia).

It has been recommended that Breivik should be indefinitely confined to a secure unit at a psychiatric hospital, potentially for the rest of his life, with reviews every three years to determine if he is still a danger to society. The public prosecutor in the ongoing terrorism investigation told a press conference that the psychiatrists evaluating Breivik’s mental state had “described a person who lives in his own delusional universe”. The report will be formally presented at Breivik’s next court appearance, on 16 April 2012.

As discussed on Pickled Politics here:  http://www.pickledpolitics.com/archives/13888, the English Defence League recently issued a public statement on their official Facebook page finally admitting that their agenda is racially-motivated (it turns out that part of the EDL’s statement was practically identical to the statement made by Anders Breivik during his court appearance just two days previously – see:  http://exposingon.tumblr.com/post/12922224616/english-defence-league-mirror-breiviks-words-in), and the EDL have also announced a formal alliance with the Far-Right “British Freedom Party”.

It is worth noting that EDL leader Stephen Yaxley-Lennon (aka “Tommy Robinson”) is on record as explicitly stating that he does not think Breivik is insane and that he actually shares some of Breivik’s opinions (see:  http://theforeigner.no/pages/news/edl-leader-breivik-dared-to-come-forward-with-his-opinions/):

“We share some of his opinions, and his fear, but not what he did in Norway 22 July. I do not think he is insane. I think that his approach was insane. Breivik dared to come forward with his opinions, and was tough, in some regards. People need to understand that Breivik is not alone in these feelings.”

Readers can therefore draw their own conclusions about the implications of the EDL leadership claiming that they share the “opinions”, “fear” and “feelings” of an individual whom psychiatrists have now certified as psychotically insane.

Jai

Comments

Hide the following 5 comments

They should take a look at Clarkson

01.12.2011 23:56

Oi Oi

:)


not stigmatising

02.12.2011 09:22

Psychosis is defined as "loss of contact with reality", where "hallucinations and delusions and impaired insight may occur":  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychosis

This article isn't saying all people with psychosis are neo-Nazis with a propensity for mass-murder. Maybe some people believe they live in a happy world of giant fluffy bunnies. It's just saying someone shares views with someone else who has been found to have delusions and impaired insight.

Thus the implication is that Yaxley-Lennon's insight is probably impaired too, and his views aren't grounded in reality.

anon


Not really

03.12.2011 11:21

For the sake, in my view, of smearing someone with an implicit societal stigma, the author was perpetuating assuming that the psychiatric classification of paranoid schizophrenia means that the entire contents of what the diagnosed person believes is always 'delusional'. Some beliefs may have a better grounding in reality than others. Stick to exposing the facts and you won't go far wrong.

The idea of someone having 'delusions' about a world full of fluffy bunnies does not, for me, represent a thoroughgoing understanding of how a person's confusing and distressing life experiences lead them into developing paranoid interpretations of the world around them. Psychiatry blames a biological disorder that it has so far been unable to evidence in any way.

Mad Pride


Either Breivik was delusional, or his ideas make rational sense

03.12.2011 23:41

Breivik thought that Islam represents a threat to society and that massacring a group of centre-left kids would be a rational act to help stop that happening.

So either a) he is delusional and that isn't really a good idea, or b) he is completely sane and it was a good thing to do.

I go for option a). Presumably Stephen Yaxley-Lennon from the EDL goes for option b).

I get what you are saying about not stereotyping people with mental health issues, but delusions are delusions, unless you believe there is no such thing as objective reality?

anon