Skip to content or view screen version

An open letter to social justice activists, from an anti-psychiatry campaigner

Rona Stanton | 18.11.2011 11:27 | Repression | Social Struggles

Not enough is being done to challenge the prejudice and exclusion of people labelled by the state as having "mental disorders" This issue affects all of us; it's time to get informed.

A broad number of movements come under the banner of “social justice”, to challenge oppression and strive for a better, fairer world. In ink and pixels this is all well and good, but when activists get together at book fairs, gatherings, demos etc. all kinds of deep-rooted prejudices bubble up. Not enough is being done to challenge judgemental behaviour against those who don't fit into the mould of “normal”.

It's easy to get sucked into a “scene”. If you have a mental blueprint that activists dress a certain way, listen to certain bands, smoke spliffs etc., it's possible to feel wary of those you regard as “more straight” and it goes without saying that this is a barrier to new activists. However, what about those times when you meet an activist who isn't calm, educated and articulate and has unusual body language? All too often, these people are laughed at, excluded and treated with hostility.

A generation ago, society had eccentrics. Now, thanks to the efforts of psychiatrists, we have people with “mental disorders” and the number of disorders grows each year. People who worry about state surveillance are labelled “Paranoid”, those who argue passionately against injustice and have a head full of facts and figures are “Deluded” and suffering from “Thought Disorder” and those full of dreams and visions of a better world are “Psychotic”. Meanwhile, kids who prefer to explore their surroundings and chatter (as thousands of years of evolution prepared them to do) instead of sitting still listening to teachers are labelled as “suffering from ADHD” and drugged. Government consultation documents on mental health claim that “10% of children suffer from mental disorders” and that more measures need to be put in place to “identify and treat them early”. Mental health is a growing industry and drug companies reap the profits, while experimenting on animals and people.

Psychiatry no longer classifies those who fancy others of the same gender as mentally disordered, because in most parts of the world, society has moved on from that. However, an increasing number of people who talk out of turn, behave in an “embarrassing” way or are seen as a nuisance are declared ill, labelled with mental disorders, hospitalised and drugged against their will. People diagnosed with real, physical illnesses have the right to choose what treatment they have and even reject it altogether, even for potentially fatal conditions like cancer. Those diagnosed with mental “illness” have no such rights and can be detained indefinitely, purely because a psychiatrist and a second-opinion psychiatrist, psychologist or social worker label them and detain them under the Mental Health Act. Challenging such decisions is a long and complicated legal process.

There's no such thing as “mental illness”. Illness is physical; it has symptoms that can be objectively observed and tested for. Yet doctors who become psychiatrists use a manual of behavioural “symptoms” and a tick-box approach to label people and commit them to a system in which they have few rights and can be stigmatised for life. Activists who enter the mental health system can get little support from family, friends and fellow activists; a far cry from the warm solidarity experienced by those locked up in conventional prisons.

I'm calling on social justice activists to: REALISE that not everybody is a stereotype articulate educated person with a dry sense of humour and a calm disposition; some of us are confused, obsessive, angry and don't quite understand the social rules of body language. We have an equal right to have our say, (though it's fair enough to stop any one person dominating a meeting or disrupting a demo; that's only teamwork.) QUESTION your prejudices and the dominant social ideology that put them there. MAKE ALLOWANCES for those who come across as different and treat them with respect rather than acting like the state and dismissing them as embarrassing. GET AWARE about the oppressive nature of psychiatry and CHALLENGE it's false assumptions. FIGHT the enforced hospitalisation and drugging of people labelled with mental disorders.

If you'd like to engage with us in debate, find out more and/or spread the word, please take a look at www.blue-panthers-party.com We're also on Facebook, Twitter and YouTube, and members attend a variety of events such as Anarchist Bookfairs. We're a young and growing group, please support us. Thanks for reading.

Rona Stanton
- e-mail: rona.stanton@blue-panthers-party.com
- Homepage: http://www.blue-panthers-party.com

Comments

Hide the following 15 comments

Is this a Scientology front organisation?

18.11.2011 11:35

Forgive my suspicion, but is this a front organisation for the Scientologists?

anon


Of course not!

18.11.2011 12:03

It's a group of people affected by the mental health system (both staff and "service users") and their friends and family who have become increasingly distressed by the way things are going and determined to challenge it.

Rona Stanton


Confused

18.11.2011 14:24

You say "there's no such thing as mental illness". I happen to be bipolar. Sometimes it's brilliant and so very creative. Sometimes it's fucking awfull. Most of the time I'm simply 'normal'. Are you saying I'm deluded or something?

Rob


To Rob

18.11.2011 15:20

I think they're saying that you're not 'ill'. The norms of a society determine the acceptable behaviours (how happy or sad it's ok to be, how much eye contact is ok, how fidgety you can be at school, whether you're allowed to hear 'voices', what thoughts are 'deluded', etc. etc.). While 'bipolar' strays from these norms by being 'too high' and then 'too low', there is no need to invoke an 'illness' and a (no doubt pharmaceutical) 'cure'. Sorry about all the 'quote marks'.

Rich


Yes, Rich, that paraphrases it quite well

18.11.2011 16:26

People have mood swings. People can be bouncy, or angry, or sad, or ultra-confident, but these are understandable human emotions. Just because some people have very dramatic moods, does not mean they should be labelled as having a mental disorder and described as "ill"

Here's an example someone put to me the other day; why is it acceptable and normal for a person to believe that they might win millions of pounds on the lottery, even though that is so unlikely as to be ludicrous, yet it is unacceptable and abnormal for a person to believe they are on a special mission to change the world?

Rona Stanton


It's not about mood swings

18.11.2011 17:24

I've refused medication for my mental disorder and am in permanent panic and distress. I want to beleive it's society that needs to change and I'm not ill, and I'm against medicalisation of people but frankly, life's a fucking nightmare these days and when you can't function, what's the answer?

Solly


it's a question of degree

18.11.2011 17:46

Sure I'm opposed to the "pill for every ill" mentality that pumps kids who fidget full of drugs, etc.

But there are cases when people's mental state of mind can affect their lives or other people's lives in a very negative way.

You say people who worry about state surveillance are labelled “Paranoid”, I don't think that is a problem in itself, especially if you are an activist coming up against the state, your worries are quite well-founded.

If you sit around wearing a tin-foil hat 24/7 because you think they are sitting outside you house beaming "mind control rays" at your head, then you probably do have a problem as it will affect your life in a negative way. This is an "illness" in some sense, it stops you leading a happy life.

If you are a troofer obsessed with 9/11 conspiracy theories - more a borderline case, but certainly not requiring treatment as I think most of these people are fairly happy.

And I think the psychotic ones are the people running the big companies and sitting in Parliament, not the ones trying to make the world a better place! It takes a lack of empathy to get to the top and to tread down your rivals.

The brain is an organ just like anything else so I don't see why we should deny it can work in a way that causes us grief at times.

What about the small number of people who think someone is possessed by the devil or something and kill them? Surely these people have a mental illness and need help? Or would you rather they be treated as standard criminals rather than someone with an illness?

anon


To Solly from Rob

18.11.2011 19:31

look, certain stuff like bipolar is genetic. Yes of course society is ill and we need to change it- thats why I've been an activist/anarchist for most of my life. I take fluoxetine every day. It does not turn me into a zombie at all, it enables me to get on with the things I like to do. None of my friends notice any difference in me and neither do I ( ok I'm a little woozy for the first 30 minutes after | take it). When things get really too much I take diazapam. This pretty much knocks me out (but I only take it when I can't cope anymore). Please don't suffer just because some idiots tell you too. Was penicillin a conspiracy? Are anti-aids drugs a conspiracy? Please don't suffer. I know what it's like! I'm still an anarchist and busy with good stuff. Kisses.

Rob


...

19.11.2011 08:06

I am ill. I have severe depression. This is not just part of my personality: I used to be okay, now I am not. People with mental health problems often face claims that they are just faking it, or lazy, and therefore not actually ill. Activists claiming that mental health disorders don't exist at all really won't help this.

Kia


Kia and Rob, your problems are real, but are the labels being put on you?

19.11.2011 13:27

Or is it just ideology? You, personally might gain comfort from being labelled with a mental disorder, but you're not being given any choice in that matter. Surely you have the right to define your own reality and not have a "mental disorder" imposed on you? More mental disorders are thought up each year; there are now hundreds.

Anti-psychiatry activists are not trying to pretend that life's great for everybody, but are trying to end the mindset that everything needs to be thought of in psychological terms and that a stranger can assess you, label you and dictate what happens to you. This is an anarchist issue.

Another activist


Kia, depression is not an illness

19.11.2011 13:49

Sadness and emotional exhaustion are a completely understandable human response to being overwhelmed with life and events and struggling to cope and even motivate yourself to get up in the morning. The problem is when someone in your position (and I've been in that position myself, so know how it feels) is told that they are "ill with depression" and that they need to be sorted out and fixed. That implies there is something wrong with you.

There is nothing wrong with feeling terrible! The world is a confusing, terrifying and very complicated place; feeling shit is understandable. If anybody makes out you're faxing it, they're being insensitive and uncaring.

There's nothing wrong with asking for understanding and support and some listening ears and practical help to get through it, but do you really need a psychiatric label as well?

Rona Stanton


malfunction or bad data?

20.11.2011 09:13

Mental attitude, outlook, or belief can lead to harm or damage to the body. However, the processes involved might be identical to those used by healthy, normal, or common minds. So long as nobody is harmed, people should be free to follow the considerations of their choice. I'm sure "illness" is used to describe "inconvenient" in many cases.
Which flavour of herbal, mineral, or pharmaceutical tea people prefer will hopefully be guided by understanding of the consequences.

solipsist


The NHS is still rubbish medical science!

20.11.2011 11:43

sick people are sick, not neurotic.

If you are going to have a blueprint for healthcare, it should be routine MRI scan, proper blood test, and organ function test. Then the right anti-biotics, anti-viral, anti-fungalcide or surgery.

Every other country in Europe sucessfully treats its sick, why cant britian? I agree too many people are being wrongly diagnosed, and not diagnosed. 1/3 of the homeless, 1/3 of prisoners. I swear corupt GPs are presured to proscribe rubbish happy pills, and its easier to right them off than treat them.

In wikileaks list of american assets abroad every other Euro country has proper biotech products, we have happy pills and viagra.

Roger (cholestetoma)


psychiatry is for "software" problems, not "hardware"

21.11.2011 13:55

MRI scan, blood tests, and organ function tests aren't going to be very helpful for psychiatric problems, because generally (to use a computer metaphor) they are problems to do with the software (the way the brain is programmed) rather than with the actual physical brain itself.

Of course it's not a strict division and there are conditions which have elements of both, or where a physical problem can predispose you to a psychiatric problem, but it's a good general rule of thumb.

anon


social control

17.11.2013 15:55

Psychiatry was,is, and will remain a gigantic hoax and will remain so,until exposed for the fraud it is.
The critical role psychiatry played in the holocaust must also be exposed..

Dr C Jones
mail e-mail: C-cj@gmx.com
- Homepage: Psycnewsgazetteuk