Skip to content or view screen version

Kettled During 9th of December Protest

Rosie Bergonzi | 10.12.2010 15:50 | Public sector cuts | South Coast

My name is Rosie Bergonzi I am an A level student from Brighton. I attended to protest on Thursday the 9th of December and was kettled onto the bridge despite being an innocent protester. The mass media coverage of this event has, so far, been incredibly biased. Here is my account.

When I got on the train up to London with a small group of my friends we were in good spirits, making placards and attempting to invent new chants. We reached the station at 11, the last time any of us used a toilet, and we began to march peacefully. Following those in front of us we ended up in parliament square where we were halted. After a long pause the waiting and chanting protesters began to spread out around grounds, most of us chose to stand on walls to watch the scuffles with the police from a safe distance.
It was immediately obvious that a few of those in the square had a different agenda to us. While the vast majority were dancing or singing around the small fires lit to keep warm, groups young men in scarf’s and balaclava’s could be seen. These people were the ones graffiting or charging against the police. None of the graffiti I saw all night had anything to do with fighting fees; all I saw were anarchistic symbols and slogans which helps to prove just how separate their agenda was. They were ignored by everyone else in the square, many of whom were already looking up at Big Ben and wondering when we would be released. The media claims that we were given water and use of a toilet but that is simply not true. The policeman I asked about these things only laughed and shook his head.
When the result of the vote was announced the crowd I was in booed and vented steam with a stream of angry chants. After a few stirring speeches the crowd began to dissipate and my friends and I decided it was time to leave. We’d finally heard we were allowed to leave through the Whitehall entrance and so we began to walk in that direction. Me and two of my friends hung back for what can only have been a minute to say goodbye to some friendly protester’s we’d met before continuing pushing our way out of the Whitehall entrance. The mood around us was turning a little sour but we pushed onwards. We saw people with blood dripping down their faces, some looking very unsteady from their injuries walking towards us, shaking their heads and telling us the police had sealed the exit and that we were on our way towards a very violent front line. We retreated back into parliament square and searched for another way out.
After fruitlessly talking to multiple disinterested police men we moved to another exit where a line had formed, entirely of the protester’s own sense of fairness despite no police information. The mood inside the square had now entirely split into two opposing corners. While in the Whitehall corner, furthest from us, rioting may have been occurring a group of at least 800 calm students had formed into an ever growing, very British, queue. This fact is one which has received no media attention. Nobody wanted to be there and everyone around us had tried as we had to escape but had been denied.
Eventually we learned that they were letting protester’s out; one at a time and only if they gave their name, address, date of birth and allowed themselves to be photographed, something fellow students were quick to tell us they had no to right to do. But as the night grew colder nobody complained too much for this lack of human rights, all anyone wanted to do was get warm and sit down. The fact that the police decided to free us not from the front of the line but in a corner lead lead to the neat British queue turning instead to a pile of people and showed once again their complete disrespect for us as individuals rather than a mass of guilty parties.
Time went by and ever so slowly we moved forwards, the group behind us growing ever larger as people grew tired and wanted to leave. Finally, when I was completely hemmed in by people from behind, the police gave only piece of official information I received telling us that Westminster Bridge was now open. Because we had been attempting to leave for so long we were now at the back of the new crowd of people whilst the rioters were now at the front. Those who had been waiting longest were now last in line and as such were punished further for behaving peacefully. There was no clear information but we joined the area where everyone else was. At around 9 o’clock we were finally allowed to move, the pain of stretching my legs after holding them ridged for so long forced my and many around me to stumble and stagger instead of being allowed to walk with any dignity.
My overwhelming relief was quickly short lived. We had stopped moving on the top of the bridge for no reason whatsoever. No information was given to us. The police had now forced thd whole crowd of people into a far smaller space than we had been in. The mood was desperate with no hope of freedom. When we were moved a few steps forward the crowd didn’t cheer, instead it was more or a groan. As we walked a section of police moved into the middle of the crowd and began to hit them with shields. There seemed no reason for this violence and they did not appear to mind who they hit. The crowd responded by raising their hands into the air and calling ‘This is not a riot’ but the police violence continued near us. We were then stopped again, once more with no information given to us.
My whole body was shaking with cold and exhaustion and I couldn’t stand upright. All that I’d eaten in the past 14 hours was half a pack of Pringles, a handful of ‘Heroes’ and a sherbet lemon. As I swayed those around me moved appeared as much as possible to allow me a little air but it only resulted in others being pushed harder. At times our sprits were lifted when a chant reached us like ‘Dumbledore wouldn’t stand for this’ but mostly all anyone could talk about was how much pain they were in, how cold they were, and that all they wanted to do was leave. Never in the whole kittling experience did I hear anyone even mention idea’s of further protesting tonight. Those desperate to continue fighting were not those waiting quietly and patiently.
Finally, at midnight, at least eleven hours after I arrived at parliament square the crowd began to move. The police officer’s had caused a fence with their bodies forcing us to go the longest way possible. No reason or explanation was given for this but we’d learnt better than to attempt to talk to them. As I walked I was pushed to the edge of the line of protesters, forcing me nearest the police. I didn’t touch the police line or say anything, I didn’t have any surplus energy to speak anyway, but suddenly I felt a blow in my side. Staggering away I saw a policeman glaring at me, proving this punch had been entirely intentional. After such a long day with my body already aching it felt too much for me and I felt tears coming. Only the encouragements of my friends forced me onwards till we finally left the rows of police and were shepherded into the rest of London and were left to attempt to travel back to Brighton.
Almost everyone I saw leavening were shell shocked teenagers. There were no people with their faces covered that looked like the angry young males who caused the violence. It seems as though rather than containing the violent protesters the police had only caught all those who weren’t able to push hard enough through the crowds to escape. We were not the protesters who ‘decided to stay’. Instead we were those who never got an opportunity to leave. While there may have been violent protesters in the crowd most of those around us were under 18 and none of them were in any way dangerous. No one could believe we were being punished in this way when our only crime was attempting to protest peacefully.
The general attitude of the media has shocked me. The claims that we are ‘hardcore protesters’ who chose to say is ridiculous. We made every effort to leave in a safe and organized way despite the lack or order or information given. I asked countless policemen when I would be able to leave, and was treated like scum or something subhuman on every occasion. To be forced to stand for 8 hours in the freezing cold with no food or water was not something I asked for or deserved.
Right up until that night I had respected the police. I really believed they were there for our protection and that they wanted the good of our citizens. What I witnessed completely destroyed this picture of them. We were treated like cattle, completely stripped of any human decency or rights. The vast number of completely innocent bystanders so harshly punished for the actions of few in unforgivable. I protested for want of an education, but what I received was a traumatic lesson in police brutality.

Rosie Bergonzi
- e-mail: rosiebergonzi@hotmail.com

Comments

Hide the following 12 comments

Lesson learnt?

10.12.2010 16:37

Maybe next time Rosie you won't be so quick to condenm those who are prepared to confront police violence. The police clearly weren't there to protect your right to protest they were there to protect the interests of the British ruling class and if they had to crack a few young skulls to do it then more fun for them. What has happened to you and other student protesters will be just the start of even more state repression if there is widespread opposition to the massive cuts the ConDems are bringing in in the New Year.

Dee


'Attack' on the Wales's

10.12.2010 16:46

B4 I make up my own mind up on the group of 'who ever they were' targeting HRH Prince Charles, & Camilla; I want 2 hear it 'straight from the horses mouth' Who were those people, why did they do it, & what were they hoping 2 acheive? I seen the pics in the press, from the pro UKgov media 2 the mild leftwing media; I've not seen any Morning Star coverage yet. Me. I was sympathetic 2 the students, definitely NOT a fan of David Carrion & broken Clegg's misgovernment. Let's have some eyewitness rports of this incident please, without any political axes 2 grind. I'm old enuf 2 make up my own mind now.

Tristan
mail e-mail: mightymongoose41@yahoo.co.uk


the reasons for kettling

10.12.2010 16:48

whilst the stated aim of kettling is to detain a crowd until the will to fight has gone out of it, that equates often to "so they don't ever want to go on a demonstration again".

ps there was quite a lot of graff about education cuts btw

and the trouble started way before the masked up crew pitched in when the cops were pushing us all back and hiting us and bringing horses in to block our way.

mike


Dont fall into the trap....

10.12.2010 16:59

Excellent well written report Rosie, but dont fall into the trap layed by media and police of separating yourself and your friends from the 'angry young men' and the 'anarchists'. Even if you dont agree with their methods, they/we are all on the same side. Maybe they were once like you, but after being treated like shit, like you were, time after time, some choose to fight back. Obviously the police are not the ultimate enemy, and a few broken windows alone aren't going to change anything, but if the march had been a totally peaceful march from a to b, with a few speeches from the same power hungry wannabe politicos (NUS SWP etc), it wouldnt have even made the news, let alone the public at large.

At the risk of sounding old and patronising (sorry), i hope this experience shows you and your friends how things really work, and that you choose to become radicalised, not dispondant.

It really seems, at least to me, that momentum is really building. Bring it on.

ex student


A suggestion

10.12.2010 17:19

Thanks Rosie, for a detailed and frank account of your experience.

May I suggest you write to the Commisioner on the Metropolitan Police, at New Scotland Yard, or here

DPS Customer Service Team
Jubilee House
230-232 Putney Bridge Road
Putney
SW15 2PD

outlining the concerns you have with the policing, lack of information, the way you were treated, the being kettled for hours with no water food or toilet facilities, being punched, etc etc and heading your letter 'Complaint against the Police'. Especially include your last comment about what you thought of the police before and since this experience. Don't mention 'rioters' or anything else that they will try to use as an excuse for their bad behaviour, just stick to your own experience.

If you're up for it tell them you are sending a copy to your MP and/or other local representatives, and maybe the IPCC. Maybe send copies to the media of your choice, local or national, and let them know of any outcomes.

The more people follow these courses of action there are, the more focus goes onto the bad policing at these events. See if you can get your friends to make separate complaints too.

Post any outcomes here, to let others know how the Police Complaints procedure works, or doesn't. Oh, and don't be fobbed off with some computer generated response, insist on being in contact with someone who takes you seriously

And don't let this bad experience put you off from using your democratic right to demonstrate again and again until those in power listen to your very real concerns.
I hope that this experience has made you more determined to use your right to demonstrate.

Also next time right down the shoulder numbers of police who you see misbehaving, lying to you etc with the time and place this happened, with video or pictures to back this up.if possible.

Above all, Stay Brave and well done!

complainant


A shocking attack on Royalty

10.12.2010 18:03

Hello Tristan. Well let me tell you what happened to us, young man. Charles and myself had just been shopping in our favourite shop, Harrods. When we came out and got into our Royal Limousine, I spoke to the lead officer of our motorcade and asked him whether they had the lower orders under control yet. He told me yes, they were firmly kettled on Parliament Square so we would have no trouble in getting back to the Palace. 'Huh, that is too good for them,' I retorted. 'What we could do with in this country is a dose of the same medicine those stalwart generals in Argentina gave to their ungrateful students in the 1970s.' He agreed and apologised, then we drove off.

Imagine our consternation, when suddenly from nowhere there was a seething crowd of black clad hooligans running down the street! 'My God,' I exclaimed to Charles, 'there's a mass of proletarians outside our car!' While Charles began looking round for a perfumed handkerchief, because he really cannot abide their smell at close quarters, I opened the window and waved my diamond encrusted hand at them to go away. But these vile specimens were shouting 'off with their heads!' The police were temporarily overwhelmed and the ruffians began to kick the car. I closed the window, but the next thing I knew someone had smashed it. For one ghastly moment I even thought I would end up like Marie Antoinette!

The armed police officers present have said that they 'exercised remarkable restraint', but in my opinion they should have just gunned the thugs down like grouse on the estate at Gleneagles.

Camilla Parker-Bowles


and....

10.12.2010 18:10

take food and water with you.....good account of the day...don't let it put you off...and the police really are hired thugs who were having a great time, with toilets, food, water, rest breaks....they don't want you back protesting so they will make it a horrible experience. Bullys that beat up children...Remember the anarchists although they were not there for all the same reasons you were are your friends.....Never trust a copper....

bleeps


Thank you

10.12.2010 18:47

Thanks Rosie for a clear account of the night and for detailing the shocking behaviour of the police.

I hope it won't put you off protesting again, and I hope you do complain about your ill treatment.

I am so inspired by what you are all doing. I'd never have had the guts at your age.

Virginia


Clarion Call

10.12.2010 22:27

"Dont fall into the trap....

10.12.2010 16:59

It really seems, at least to me, that momentum is really building. Bring it on.

ex student "





+1

David Carrion


Police actions have radicalised many

11.12.2010 00:36

The trouble makers are often people who began protesting with the same attitude as you Rosie.

A so called 'feral thug' or 'masked anarchist' will look out for and try to protect their fellow protesters and citizens better than any armed riot police officer.

A person


complain

11.12.2010 04:40

It is vital you complain at the way you were treated. It is important you file a complaint with the IPCC with a copy to your MP. You may also wish to copy to the London Police Authority and London Mayor Boris.

You say you are from Brighton. May I suggest you meet with Caroline Lucas MP and discuss with her your experience.

You may like to know that senior officers at Scotland Yard were saying you were being allowed to go home. They were even saying we are tired we want to go home home, will these people please calm down and go home. But, as you found you were not allowed to go home.

 http://keithpp.wordpress.com/2010/12/10/a-sad-day-for-democracy/

Before you were herded onto Westminster Bridge, journalists were told this was about to happen. They were then told to move away.

It is good you took the trouble to write of your experience. You may also wish to tell your local paper.

Keith
- Homepage: http://keithpp.wordpress.com/2010/12/10/a-sad-day-for-democracy/


media reports

11.12.2010 04:58

I do not know what media reports you were referring to.

Sky News had very good live coverage. They were reporting all night, no food, no water, no toilets, that it was very cold and that contrary to what the police were saying, that people were not being allowed out to go home.

You may find that lazy journalist were reporting what the police were saying, not what was actually happening.

You report what happened after the vote was taken. The mood turned ugly, people were angry.

Think what would have happened if the LibDems had voted no. There would have been jubilation, partying on the street.

Therefore the violence must be put not on the police or the protesters, those to blame are Nick Clegg and Vince Cable.

 http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2010/12/470251.html
 http://london.indymedia.org/videos/6647

Keith
- Homepage: http://www.indymedia.org.uk/en/2010/12/470251.html