Skip to content or view screen version

AADD-UK asks Paul Burstow to apologise for stereotyping ADHD Adults

Adult ADHD | 07.10.2010 12:33 | Health | Social Struggles

Paul Burstow MP, Minister of State for Care Services, and lead for Equality & Human Rights, seems to assume all adults with ADHD are potential criminals and as a result the Department of Health will only consider adult ADHD issues after people have entered the criminal justice system.

AADD-UK has written to Paul Burstow, Minister of State for Care Services & lead for Equality and Human Rights, asking for a public apology for his contribution to the stigmatisation of adults with ADHD.

AADD-UK petitioned the previous Government for better NHS services for adults with ADHD because not only are services completely absent in some areas of the UK, where they do exist some are oversubscribed, and one even has a waiting list of 18 months. Even worse, in some areas Trusts are refusing to treat adults who were either diagnosed as children, or who were diagnosed for the first time as adults.

Paul Burstow wrote in a letter to an MP and in an email that was sent to more than 1,000 people that the Government recognises concerns that childhood ADHD may continue into adulthood in some cases and that is why the Government is going to consider ADHD issues in the Criminal Justice programme.

As a result, AADD-UK has written to Mr Burstow, with copies to David Cameron, Nick Clegg, and Andrew Lansley, asking that he apologise, in his capacity as lead for Equality and Human Rights, to all the recipients of his letter for his contribution to the negative stereotyping of adults with ADHD, and they have also asked that he publicly support NHS services for adults with ADHD.

Here is a copy of their letter:

Paul Burstow MP
Minister of State for Care Services (Health)
Department of Health
Richmond House
79 Whitehall, London SW1A 2NS

6 October 2010

Dear Mr Burstow,

Response to petition for dedicated NHS funding for services for adults with ADHD

I am writing to you to express our very grave concerns with the discriminatory and stigmatising tone first in your letter to Mr John Penrose, MP (PO00000507382) in response to his query regarding the whereabouts of the above petition, and secondly in the response to the same petition by Her Majesty’s Government which was sent to 1,853 signatories; the latter matches your response to Mr Penrose word-for-word.

Please note that we will not be addressing the many medical inaccuracies contained in these responses, because it is our understanding that this will be addressed in a separate letter by medical professionals.

You say that “we recognise concerns that childhood ADHD may continue into adulthood in some cases. This is why we set up an ADHD research community within the Offender Health Research Network. . .” and so on. Your apparent assumption that all adults with ADHD are offenders has not only increased the considerable distress already being felt by people who are experiencing difficulties accessing NHS services (the reason for the petition), it also increases feelings of exclusion and stigmatisation thus making it less likely that people with ADHD will assert their rights to protection from direct and indirect discrimination.

We, therefore, respectfully suggest that in recompense you offer an apology on behalf of HM Government, as well as in your capacity as lead for Equality & Human Rights, to all signatories for your, hopefully inadvertent, contribution to the negative stereotyping of people with ADHD, and also publicly state that you support the provisions of services for adults with ADHD in accordance with NICE Guidelines CG72.

I look forward to hearing from you.

Yours sincerely,

Chairwoman AADD-UK

cc: The Rt Hon David Cameron, MP
The Rt Hon Nick Clegg, MP
The Rt Hon Andrew Lansley, CBE MP
Mr John Penrose, MP

More information can be found on AADD-UK's website including a 32 page Summary of Evidence that was sent to the Government supporting AADD-UK's call for better services for adults with ADHD.

Adult ADHD
- e-mail: aadd.org@googlemail.com
- Homepage: http://www.aadd.org.uk/

Comments

Hide the following 9 comments

ADHD Myth

07.10.2010 14:36

Yet another condition made up by the poisonous psychiatry industry!

I think both the author and MP should apologise to 'those with ADHD' for continuing to proclaim the ADHD myth.

It is a myth used to pump toxic chemicals into people by the pharmaceutical industry. By labelling perfectly normal childhood behaviours as defective drugs giants are further increasing their massive profits.

If you want to know the real cause of diseases in children look no further than fluoride in the drinking water supplies!

Wake up to reality people!

Anti-psychiatry
- Homepage: http://www.psychiatry.info/the-myth-of-add-adhd-hyperactivity/adult-adhd-or-attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder-does-it-exist/


ADHD Myth

07.10.2010 14:36

Yet another condition made up by the poisonous psychiatry industry!

I think both the author and MP should apologise to 'those with ADHD' for continuing to proclaim the ADHD myth.

It is a myth used to pump toxic chemicals into people by the pharmaceutical industry. By labelling perfectly normal childhood behaviours as defective drugs giants are further increasing their massive profits.

If you want to know the real cause of diseases in children look no further than fluoride in the drinking water supplies!

Wake up to reality people!

Anti-psychiatry
- Homepage: http://www.psychiatry.info/the-myth-of-add-adhd-hyperactivity/adult-adhd-or-attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder-does-it-exist/


ADHD Myth

07.10.2010 14:37

Yet another condition made up by the poisonous psychiatry industry!

I think both the author and MP should apologise to 'those with ADHD' for continuing to proclaim the ADHD myth.

It is a myth used to pump toxic chemicals into people by the pharmaceutical industry. By labelling perfectly normal childhood behaviours as defective drugs giants are further increasing their massive profits.

If you want to know the real cause of diseases in children look no further than fluoride in the drinking water supplies!

Wake up to reality people!

Anti-psychiatry
- Homepage: http://www.psychiatry.info/the-myth-of-add-adhd-hyperactivity/adult-adhd-or-attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder-does-it-exist/


ADHD Stigmatisation

07.10.2010 16:04

The three comments titled "ADHD Myth" have helped make AADD-UK's case. People with ADHD are clearly being stigmatised and stereotyped!

Hoskins


Anti-Psychiatry == Scientology

07.10.2010 17:12

Isn't Anti-Psychiatry just a front for Scientology? And, forgive me, Tom Cruise (if he is not taking drugs) is a damn good advertisement for why he SHOULD be taking drugs.

Tom Cruise


It's a shame I thought people on Indymedia were intelligent.

07.10.2010 20:41

@Hoskins - You are wrong I am not the one stigmatising those who've been 'judged' by capitalist psychiatrists to have ADHD at all. I do not judge their behaviour to be defective, indeed I recognise their behaviour for what it is... NORMAL HUMAN BEHAVIOUR. There is a very worrying trend in psychiatry geared towards making money by labelling behaviours as defective and then prescribing expensive drugs to 'treat' it. Personality Disorders, ADHD, etc are all labels applied to perfectly normal individuals in an effort marginalise them and then capitalise on them by selling them expensive patented drugs. It's a disgusting practise.

Tom Cruise - No I have nothing to do with the cult known as Scientology which is nothing more than a money making swindle much like the psychiatric industry it pretends to oppose. It like the psycho-pharmaceutical companies seeks to marginalise people and make profit from them. Scientology is just as dangerous as Psychiatry both are seeking to exploit people!

I find it very worrying that people on Indymedia are simply swallowing the lies spewed forth by pharmaceutical giants and the psychiatrists they pay vast sums of money to. The DSM IV is a booklet of lies designed to trap people on a lifetime of taking mass produced drugs.

People don't need psychiatry or dodgy cults pretending to religions. They need to be treated like normal human beings rather than throwing labels at them and deciding that hence forth they are defective in some way.

I find it very worrying that people here are in the pockets of the pharmaceutical and psychiatric mass capitalist industry.

Anti-psychiatry


psychiatry.info is a Scientology front

07.10.2010 20:42

I do have some sympathy with the view that things like ADHD are made up by the pharmaceutical industry to stigmatise people and to make huge amounts of money from drugs.

But it is apparently true that psychiatry.info is run by a Scientology front organisation called "Citizens Commission on Human Rights":  http://anonymoustoronto.wiki-site.com/index.php/Citizens_Commission_on_Human_Rights

So for that reason you should avoid this site like the plague - Scientology is a dangerous cult that was originally invented as a fake religion by science fiction author L. Ron Hubbard as a money-making scam.

anon


ADHD Stigmatisation

08.10.2010 06:46

@antipsychiatry

You are stigmatising and in fact you are helping AADD-UK by making their case for them. Even the title of your comment is telling!

While you say that the symptoms of ADHD are "normal human behaviour," you're also implicitly saying that you are more intelligent than "perfectly normal individuals" because you're implying that they've allowed themselves to be marginalised by drug companies. It's not becoming to be so superior.

Additionally, you've completely missed the point of the original news story.

In your rush to attach, you've left your flanks unguarded; that's a desperate tactic adopted by those who've run out of options.

Don't bother trying to reply because by the time you read this, I'll have left the field!

Adieu

Hoskins


Hoskins is a bigot

08.10.2010 10:50

Hoskins - How dare you deliberately misread my post to say that I am more intelligent than others! I am not saying I am more intelligent than those deemed to be ADHD at all. And it's SICK of you to imply it.

I too have been a victim of the psychiatric industry, in my late teens I was sectioned and forcibly treated in a mental health hospital against my will from 1997-1999. I was pumped full of dangerous toxic drugs which have now left me with permanent side effects which include uncontrollable tremors in my left arm, diabetes, as well as memory problems which are a known side effect of long term use of antipsychotics.

I like fellow victims of the psychiatric money making industry am simply speaking out against those that continue to support the psychiatric industry. All people need is to be treated with decency like normal human beings. If you cannot accept then it is you who is the bigot!

It sickens me that people like you think that the way to treat others deemed as defective in some way is to pump them full of toxic drugs. I like fellow victims say NO to labels, treat us as human beings instead!

Anti-psychiatry