Skip to content or view screen version

Sold Short with AV

[Scotland] | 14.05.2010 18:22

 Saturday sees a continuation of protests as the Take Parliament Back campaign hits Scotland's capital. As part of a nationwide campaign tomorrow afternoon, protesters will march from Edinburgh City Chambers to The Mound to call for electoral reform and a fairer system.

read more


[Scotland]
- Original article on IMC Scotland: http://www.indymediascotland.org/node/19391

Comments

Hide the following 5 comments

Proportional Representation = BNP MPs!

14.05.2010 19:00

Proportional Representation = BNP MPs...

 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3pVF0ZtE240

The Hung Parliament


Wishy washy nonsense

14.05.2010 20:01

Is that what wishy washy liberals want these days fairer votes and fairer systems? BULLSHIT

You're never going to get a fair system. All systems benefit those in power because it is they who design them, they who control them, and they who can override them with emergency laws.

Don't endorse the state. Don't vote, organise.

Raise the black flag


correct

14.05.2010 20:24

"Proportional Representation = BNP MPs... "

That's how it is when democracy is working properly. The wrongheaded folks get to vote and have their views represented too. Democracy isn't about making good, wise, just, etc. etc. decisions but when working properly, just the decisions that "the people" want, for good or for ill.

There are other consequences of a more democratic proportional representation system (with low threshold). It destroys the "glue" holding parties together since as long as both resulting factions remain above the threshold no severe cost associated with party splits over ideological differences or personality clashes among the leadership. Especially those of us on the "left" need to keep that in mind as by our history we tend to fragmentation and poor cooperation between factions.

MDN


Nick Clegg

14.05.2010 21:04

Hang on, did you guys actually TRUST the Lib Dems?

PR = BNP MPs

Lib Dems = Tories (and that's official, bud)

The Hung Parliament


Non-proportional Representation = Labour, Tory and LibDem MPs

16.05.2010 09:43

Proportional Representation might let in a handful of BNP MPs, but under the current system it lets it hundreds of extra Labour, Tory, and LibDem MPs. I'm not sure which one is worse. I don't want those main party scum running things for me either!

Yes, I am anti-fascist, and no, I don't vote.

But by any standards, representation as a proportion of the number of votes is much more fair than the existing system, even if both systems will always be controlled by the rich anyway.

So, I have no illusions about PR making the world a happy place, but at least it will throw some spanners in the works, so good luck to the PR people.

anon