What kind of non-hierarchical space is Leeds Common Place?
Yes to anti-fascism, No to dictatorship. | 12.10.2009 14:00 | Anti-racism
Yes to anti-fascism, No to dictatorship.
Yes to anti-fascism, No to dictatorship. | 12.10.2009 14:00 | Anti-racism
Yes to anti-fascism, No to dictatorship.
Comments
Hide the following 56 comments
minus one
12.10.2009 14:44
-1
not true
12.10.2009 14:53
commoner
@commoner RE:bullshit
12.10.2009 15:22
TBH I don't see what the fuss is about, the common place is a dirty, cliche, hole full of libral hippys.
no major loss.
(although I can understand why people would be annoyed by a so called political venue blocking anti-fascist events)
captain bullshit
What has happened to the Common Place
12.10.2009 15:47
Disgusted
Concensus?
12.10.2009 16:26
???
Err !
12.10.2009 16:42
Common Place Supporter
Anti-fascism in Leeds
12.10.2009 16:42
Leeds anti-fascist
self-defense is no offence
12.10.2009 17:08
can't believe what's happened to the common place that this even has to be discussed. another of our spaces has been hijacked. i hope at least that lessons can be learnt from where the weakness was so that other spaces can learn and protect themselves from this sort of tragedy.
anne
The lengths that fascists will go to
12.10.2009 17:09
Antifascist
Enough!
12.10.2009 17:46
CP supporter and antifascist
Comment
12.10.2009 18:00
Captain Jack
Whose Next?!
12.10.2009 18:01
Anyone attending this meeting shouldn't be fooled by the prejudicial language and manipulative bullshit or the stupid interpretation of concensus by self-serving scoundrels masquerading as wet-behind-the-ear liberals The CP has to put an end to whats being going on. Enough is enough. Support our antifascists.
I'm Spartacus!
dancing with the captain
12.10.2009 18:12
Sunny Jim
Is this for real
12.10.2009 18:49
like i said we're all new to the city and were countin on the CP as a radical hub.
hope this can all be sorted out.
Fighting fascism with hearts minds and steel capped boots.
leeds CW fresher
e-mail: leedsuniautonomous@gmail.com
Welcome Antifascists
12.10.2009 19:17
Ben
Comment 2
12.10.2009 19:23
The letter only describes what one person thinks, and why they made the objection. It doesn't say what the opposition to the block was, though some of it will be fairly obvious to many of us.
The whole episode is unfortunate, this should have been resolved without needing to use this meeting, because either he is right (and he isn't) or he doesn't really understand what the social centre is about.
Captain Jack
CP Minutes
12.10.2009 20:22
ACAB
More CP minutes
12.10.2009 20:32
Writing about antifascists in that way - on the CP fucking website no less - Is like dismissing Queer Mutiny (for example - no offense intended guys, gals, and others) as a "a group involved with taking drugs" - ie absolutely fucking unacceptable.
ACAB
block
12.10.2009 20:50
consenting
Any connection with Northen Indymedia?
12.10.2009 20:54
Content should not promote, incite or glorify any form of exploitation, oppression, discrimination or domination, including environmental degradation, animal abuse, violence, nationalism, racism, sexism, queerphobia or homophobia
http://www.northern-indymedia.org/pages/editorial-guidelines
'violence' is a clickable link to: http://www.who.int/topics/violence/en/
"Violence is the intentional use of physical force or power, threatened or actual, against oneself, another person, or against a group or community, which either results in or has a high likelihood of resulting in injury, death, psychological harm, maldevelopment, or deprivation"
On the basis of this guideline, they hid an announcement of a screening of the "weather underground"
http://lists.indymedia.org/pipermail/imc-northern-moderation/2009-August/0814-2e.html
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/weatherunderground/film.html
wotcha
Any Connection to Northern Indymedia
12.10.2009 21:06
Suspicious
When was the last time you went to an antifacist thing at the common place?
12.10.2009 21:10
I reckon its bollocks as well. When the CP first opened there was always loads of antifa things on. now theres never anything like that on. Someone down there doesn't like antifacists for sure.
Bash the fash
Dignified silence
12.10.2009 21:48
Leeds @ctivist
shit in the locks
12.10.2009 22:33
rather than actually standing up to this gentleman, the common place has a bucket with a home made "shit cleaning kit" under the sink.
its been going on for at least a year, probably 2 years now.
the common place has refused countless offers of people to wait for the guy - even those who just wanted sharp words...
the common place is a lost cause...
1 cops on the board to many
smash dirty bastards
Interesting but depressing
12.10.2009 22:58
V
Shit in the locks
12.10.2009 23:03
V
more liberal nonsense on 'non-violence'
13.10.2009 09:52
https://we.riseup.net/imc-uk/incitement
read how they flounce at the end when they can't get their own way...
crabgrasser
still not true
13.10.2009 11:12
commoner
And how easy...
13.10.2009 11:20
http://lists.indymedia.org/imc-uk-moderation
...
reader
Nonviolence and its violent consequences
13.10.2009 11:22
Nonviolence and its violent consequences:
http://www.sinkers.org/nonviolence/
It might be considered inflammatory: "Watch the claws and fangs pop out of the Nonviolence folk. They have a lot of pent-up anger, and they would much rather take it out on an honest activist than on the people who are actually destroying the earth and murdering its peasant stewards. Be careful, they'll probably report you to the police. They probably are the police."
Here's a book:
How Nonviolence protects the State:
http://www.akpress.org/2005/items/hownonviolenceprotectsthestate
I've found that being polite to pacifists is a more effective strategy for frustrating the oppressive consequences of their ideas than being rude to them.
Be nice!
Infiltrator?
13.10.2009 12:14
anon
It is ALL the SAME guy!!
13.10.2009 13:28
https://we.riseup.net/imc-uk/incitement
read how they flounce at the end when they can't get their own way... "
It is ALL the SAME guy, and he always behaves in exactly the same way when his lies aren't believed.
Leeds Lad
More censorship from the common place
13.10.2009 13:33
13.10.2009 11:12
I think its really sad that Indymedia is keeping this story up, when it would be very easy for a moderator to check the facts. If anyone is reading this who actually wants to know what's going on, just ask a member of the commonplace collective. Likewise if anyone wants to express an opinion, contact the collective. This story is just another example of how this site has become a chat forum rather than a news site.
commoner "
More censorious bollocks from the Common Place. One way or another what you have done will be exposed. You can see how impartial the Common PLace by the content of the e-mail in one of the early posts above and by the contents of the minutes. The only reason this scumbag has been able to infiltrate the place is because of the liberal cowards who've set themselves to run the place (into the ground.)
All touts are scum
stupid comments
13.10.2009 13:33
The ridiculousness of the comment claiming a facist has smeared shit on a door knob every week for almost two years has compelled me to comment. The fact that people respond with belief to a story like that, and others on this page, illustrates the actual passiveness and apathy of the local "radicals". The minutes to these meetings never indicate a number of participants as high as the number of comments on this page, yet the CP organizers are being accused of all sorts of atrocities and infiltrations. The fact that these same organizers are holding a large meeting to address this issue is being treated as evidence of infiltration, rather than an attempt to open themselves up even further to a difficult discussion. Where is the critical thinking here? Where is the sense of history? This debate is ages old, should never be considered settled, and belongs in a public forum- just where the CP is placing it. What kind of anarchist believes in settling positions and then leaving them untouched? The true "dirty liberals" are those that believe in permanence of positions- radical politics have life and should be always treated as in flux. I am as outraged as the next person at blocks on anti-facist groups, but to declare the CP a lost cause is going too far. They have faced all sorts of government repression this year, and the interpretation of this is to declare them dead? A social centre is only as strong as its participants, and with all the work going into the very act of keeping the CP open, certain political elements may have been neglected. This should indicate to outsiders that the CP participants are dedicated and passionate, not the opposite, and the rally cry should be to support the CP and help bring it back to the radical social centre that many people are calling for.
silly bean
There's no mistaking who this is
13.10.2009 13:47
...
‘Could you please back up your claim about the murdered scab please?’
“I’m not wasting any more time on this; you folks do what you want.”
This is a quote from the link of ‘Crabgrasser’s above. Anyone familiar with the person concerned will recognize him. He is never shy of telling lies and then throws a strop when he is in danger of not getting his own way. How on Earth has he been allowed to take over Northern Indymedia and the Common Place?
J
Silly bean
13.10.2009 14:01
Bean and gone
Northern Indymedia
13.10.2009 14:11
Gav
"antifa girl"
13.10.2009 14:52
Nazi Hunter
National 'news'
13.10.2009 15:06
It is surely of little interest to people outside Leeds.
One event was blocked (possibly / probably an abuse of consensus to do so)
The majority of the people who go to meetings disagree with what happened, they discuss it at a couple of general meetings and decide to hold a seperate meeting to sort it out once and for all and to stop it happening again.
It is happening tonight.
I'd say that the common place have a bit of a problem and are dealing with it. This thread seems to consist of a lot of unsubstantiated slander against the common place.
If you want to know what is happening at the common place then get down there yourself and find out.
Common Place Member
Support For The Common Place
13.10.2009 15:22
Also a Common Place Member
Northern IMC and antifa
13.10.2009 15:32
concerned of gipton
wrong stuff
13.10.2009 15:35
Non-hierarchical - CP ran as a completely open decision making collective for 4 years, it's now a formalised collective but not closed! - there's no joining criteria other than a commitment to share in the duties and responsibilities of running the social centre. All decision making is through the thurs collective meeting and any decisions that change the politics of the social centre are done through special members meetings ... like this one. To have a say in how CP is run - come along and join the collective and help run CP. Open and direct democracy and all that..
Shit on the locks - this happened regularly and then was stopped
freshprinceofwales
members list
13.10.2009 15:54
all common place members got an email about it.
that in itself is fucking shocking.
actually
let's by right
13.10.2009 15:54
and it complied to get it back
:(
wrong stuff
13.10.2009 16:08
freshprinceofwales
Proof of the pudding
13.10.2009 16:09
Disgrunted CP user
a really hard decision and made under stressful circumstances
13.10.2009 16:14
Yeah, the last time I was in a police cell they threatened me with all sorts of things if I didn't grass up my mates.
I didn't find it such a hard decision to keep shtum though
No comment
@COG
13.10.2009 16:14
The discussion: http://lists.indymedia.org/pipermail/imc-northern/2009-October/1007-52.html
http://lists.indymedia.org/pipermail/imc-northern/2009-October/1007-iy.html
.
Additions
13.10.2009 16:21
Antifascist
Attn Commoner (additions)
13.10.2009 16:33
still at the common place
S**it in locks comment
13.10.2009 16:41
How was it stopped? When was it stopped? Sorry, but as far as I know it's still going on.
CPer
Hmmm
13.10.2009 16:47
Wouldn't you say that blocking an antifascist event is a decision to change the politics of the social centre - they have been welcome in the past and played a big part in the Common Place? Hopefully this stupid decision will be reversed by the members.
Dr Doughnut
wrong stuff
13.10.2009 17:20
freshprinceofwales
Still at the common place talks such rubbish
13.10.2009 17:49
This is such bullshit. Lies weren't told at a common place meeting. Some people had legitimate concerns about something that the 635 group did at the common place. Rather than just complain about it to anyone who would listen or banning them or something the 635 group were informed that there was a problem and were invited to a meeting. A representative of the 635 group went to a meeting and it was sorted out to a certain extent.
The attack on the computers was claimed by 'antifascists' on indymedia, and physically on the computers themselves. No one knows who did it, the common place have never apportioned blame or accused anyone as no one knows who did it.
Some antifascists in Leeds have a bit of a no-one likes us we don't care attitude. They find something to get upset about then find it impossible to stick to the facts or reasoned debate and just go round slagging people and groups off. This thread is a case in point. Their thoughts and actions are a real blight on antifascist activity in Leeds (IMO).
This thread is incredible.
Get involved or shut up
14.10.2009 11:27
Is that how you get your kicks? Who do you think it's helping?
If you're concerned about how the Commonplace is run then get involved and make it more like you'd like it to be. Same with Indymedia or any other "service provider" whose services you want to moan about.
If you just want to tap into the facilities and leave others to run them have the decency to make useful constructive criticisms, and be prepared for the day when there's no one left running things (e.g. York IMC) and don't invent stories about their demise.
There seems to be some exaggerating going on too (shit on locks EVERY Friday?) which is a sure sign their wonky argument needs propping up. And a case of blaming the victims too.
Bradford
Responding to above
14.10.2009 11:56
'Still at the common place talks such rubbish': YOU are talking rubbish. A Common Place meeting was lied to by the person causing all the trouble. He told a load of lies about the antifascist group he has now repeatedly attacked (the one he claimed to know nothing about last night.) These claims were also made in a letter to the group. They were lies from beginning to end and they were shown to be such.
Clearly people in Leeds and Common Place members DO like antifascists, as witnessed last night. What CP members don't like is lies, bullshit, infiltration, and the constant backstabbing coming from one person against other CP users. Nor do they like hierarchy and undemocratic manouvering behind closed doors and closed e-mail lists where one person is allowed to lie with impunity.
"Get involved or shut up ": It's useless sniping (useless to everyone but the police and the BNP) that has caused all these problems. - constant attacks on others by someone with their own agenda.
Antifascists have been very strongly involved in the Common Place project, but they have been increasingly pushed out and made unwelcome through the smears and lies of one person. High time he left or was thrown out. That would be the best fresh start the Common Place could have.
Leeds antifascist