Skip to content or view screen version

Fictional Crime Drama: Chris Grayling’s warped view of Moss Side

The Mule | 27.08.2009 12:57

Epsom in Surrey, an affluent commuter town on the chalk downs of Surrey that Location, Location, Location named the ‘Best place to Live in the UK’ in 2005. It’s just the kind of place you might expect to find a man like Chris Grayling, the Shadow Home Secretary. Grayling is an Oxbridge graduate, and before becoming MP for this Tory stronghold, was a high flier in the media and management consultancy.

It’s very far removed from Moss Side, a small, culturally rich but economically hard-done-by part of inner-city Manchester. Grayling this week compared Moss Side to the ultra-violent US crime drama The Wire, claiming that the conditions on the streets are ‘nothing short of urban war.’

Moss Side has had serious problems with gang violence in the past, and still does today, but ‘urban war’? Anyone living in the area will get a strong whiff of bullshit at that statement. How did he get that idea? For starters, the closest people like Grayling get to a place like Moss Side is through their TV set, so it’s not surprising he’s swallowed the ‘gunchester’ sensationalism.

See the rest of the article here:  http://themule.info/article/fictional-crime-drama-chris-graylings-warped-view-of-moss-side

The Mule
- e-mail: editor@themule.info
- Homepage: http://www.themule.info

Comments

Hide the following 3 comments

manchester

27.08.2009 18:39

I used to live in Moss side years ago. It has probably changed nowadays but i still feel qualified to comment on this. When people here of "gunchester" and moss side they assume there are firefights in the streets - it isnt like that.

But it is a case that you must use a lot of common sense. Ie. you drive with your doors locked, dont have valuables next to you in a car, dont leave your boot unlocked, dont get out if someone crashes into the back of you, dont walk down the street with a mobile next to your ear or some white ipod headphones around you neck. Those things are just asking for trouble. Another obvious one is if you find you are in an area and are the only white person around, then you are definitely in the wrong area and should leave immediately. Its not racist, just common sense. Thats how the place works.

I heard a fair few gunshots in the night but didnt see anything. I actually heard more in Whalley range when i lived there. The closest trouble I came to was a 15 year old kid was shot in the head by a gang about 200 yards away behind the swimming pool when i lived whilst in Levenshulme. From what i heard on the street, he kinda deserved it. But we did have a violent breakin in Whalley range one night. They kicked the door in, came in the bedrooms and said stay under the bed as they rifled through our stuff. My flatmate smashed them with an electric guitar when they entered his room and they legged it.

Ultimately, if you live in these areas for a number of years you will experience stuff but a lot of commonsense will protect you. I'd disagree with this article about it all being fabricated.

Jo


@jo

27.08.2009 23:06

I've lived in the area for a while as well, and I dunno where you get that idea about having to make yourself scarce if you find your the only white person around - that's nonsense!! I've never heard of anyone being attacked simply for being white. I've been attacked a few times in the past for sure, and it has always been white kids!

Or do you equate non-caucasian people with theft and violence?

Also, I think the article isn't saying that all the talk of violent crime is fabrication, but that it's an exaggeration, and an exaggeration for political gain at that.

avon


The Register: When The Wire and Midsomer Murders collide

28.08.2009 20:23

The mainstream media seem to be incapable of even a small amount of basic fact checking and seem to have been easily fooled by the fake  http://mayorofbaltimore.org/ website (with a Twitter and YouTube account for added "authenticity")

See The Register

 http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/08/28/the_wire_hoax_hoodwinks_hacks/



Hacks hoodwinked by hoax Baltimore mayor's website

When The Wire and Midsomer Murders collide

By Kelly Fiveash
Posted in Bootnotes, 28th August 2009 15:18 GMT

A fake website linking cult US television show The Wire to not-so-cult Blighty TV drama Midsomer Murders has hoodwinked several newspapers into reporting what they believed were the reactionary views of Baltimore mayor Sheila Dixon.

The Guardian and Independent were both caught out by the hoax planted by political blogger and sometime Labour Party fancier Alex Hilton AKA Recess Monkey.

It would appear that RM has been on his ollibobs in Maryland, Baltimore where he spent some time and effort pulling together a somewhat convincing spoof website that apes Mayor Dixon’s online home.

And quite a few newspapers, including local rag The Baltimore Sun, swallowed the story without first checking their facts.

[...]

Detective Chief Inspector Tom Barnaby