The "Aryan Martyrs' Brigade"?! Is this really supposed to be serious journalism?
Antifa | 03.08.2009 19:16 | Anti-racism | Liverpool | Sheffield
Some sad little Nazi, most probably Leeds-based non-entity Tony Foy (who can often be found these days drooling over pictures of guns and hand-grenades in Borders bookshop), has spent years trying to get attention, tapping away at the keyboard posting silly threats on the internet from the safety of their bedroom or posting off grubby notes to ‘racial enemies’. Antifa has been receiving this kind of mouthing-off for years – we laugh at it! Suddenly though, thanks to Taylor and ‘Searchlight’ this pathetic and cowardly idiot has been given national publicity. A headline in today’s ‘Guardian’ screams: “Far right launch campaign of violence and intimidation against opponents.” We are told: “Aryan Martyr’s Brigade issues death threat against anti-fascism activist Weyman Bennett, while student attacked after BNP protest.” What follows is a shameful piece of non-news which fails to even support its own headline.
Taylor begins his piece by telling us that “Far-right activists have launched a campaign of intimidation and violence against political opponents including a series of death threats and physical attacks.” We are told that, “Hardline fascists are targeting students and leading anti-racism activists who campaigned against the British National party in June's European elections.”
The piece continues with the staggering news that the clueless idiot who heads up the UAF, Weyman Bennett, has received a "death warrant" stating that he will be killed before the end of the year "for crimes against all loyal white patriots and British nationalists". The threat, which apparently has a picture of Bennett in cross hairs (shiver!), states: "We know exactly what you look like and what venues you frequent and can strike at will. The police, special branch, MI5, Searchlight cannot save you from the bullets coming your way. No matter where you are, we will get you, all we need is a lock on your mobile phone signal and you are one dead nigger." This drivel is typical of the sort of shit numerous antifascists have received over the years from the likes of Tony Foy after a few lines of coke on a Friday night, or from his idiot side-kick Tony White. So why is it suddenly worthy of national news? We can only think that Bennett is hoping to sell the UAF (and increase his personal credibility) in much the same way as Salman Rushdie formerly sold his books.
"There has definitely been an upsurge in attacks and intimidation since the European elections," Bennett is quoted as saying. "The fringe rightwing groups appeared to be on their best behaviour when the BNP were campaigning but once the election was over they seem to be trying to take their revenge on those of us who were prominent in the anti-fascist campaign." Some ‘antifascist’, blubbing over a silly note!
Taylor’s threadbare piece does not really produce any evidence to back-up Bennett’s claims or his own hyperbole. Bennett goes on to say, "Standing up against people like the BNP you do sometimes get verbal threats and intimidation but this appears to be more serious.” Is HE serious?! More serious than what, being called names by fascist scum? If Bennett had ever really been at the sharp-end of confronting organised fascism, he might have some idea of what ‘serious’ really means, but he hasn’t.
Apart from Bennett’s pathetic “death warrant”, the only example given by Taylor to back up his claims of an increased threat of fascist violence against anti-racists, is an alleged assault by an unseen assailant against a young student who had previously attended a UAF event in Blackpool, and whose picture like those of thousands of other people has been posted on ‘Redwatch’. It is a shameful piece of journalism.
This is not the first time though that Taylor has tried to promote the ‘Aryan Martyrs’ Brigade’ in the pages of ‘The Guardian’. In fact, apart from his latest piece, the only other evidence of their existence is a piece he wrote in January, after a few threatening e-mails were sent out under that name. Taylor described ‘them’ then as a “Right-wing splinter group”. A splinter of what exactly?
‘Searchlight’, and liberal idiots like Weyman Bennett and Matthew Taylor, have spent years trying to dissuade antifascists from hands-on confrontation with the far-Right by promoting these cowardly scum as the ‘ubermenschen’ of their fascist wanking fantasies. Are they really now trying to scare us into going down their sordid state-collaborator road by promoting some silly idiot with a poison-pen fixation?!
If and when fascists return to the street, they will find us more than ready to oppose them, and in the meantime it is THEY who should be afraid, not the other way round. Giving undue publicity to these posturing idiots, rather than finding and confronting them, simply gives them credibility they do not deserve and assists their agenda.
While we regard Redwatch as a joke, we advise serious antifascists never to be complacent about their personal security. A good starting point is not trusting the likes of ‘Searchlight’ or the UAF.
Antifa
Homepage:
http://www.antifa.org.uk
Comments
Hide the following 62 comments
smash the er other antifascists!?
03.08.2009 20:40
pantihat
Here we go again....
03.08.2009 21:36
''Three whites from the extreme left in Birmingham have tried to recruit and incite Muslim teenagers to respond by taking to the streets with racially abusive language and slogans. Perhaps two political extremes are seeking confrontation in the city'' http://norfolkunity.blogspot.com/
This is nonsense, as anyone who was there on the day will tell you! It is a smear on anti-fascists that seek to confront the EDL with something other than out-dated slogans and megaphones. There is no way on earth that any anti fascist would 'recruit' muslim youths to chant 'racist' slogans. It sounds almost as if it is peeled straight from a far right account of things. Why smear anti fascists like this at all? I mean really, why?
If Searchlight want to completely nullify the anti fascist movement then this is the right way to do it. They know it, the cops know it, and we know it too.
A cold hard truth.
David
Pffft
03.08.2009 22:02
Come back to reality and focus on the issue at hand.
Yeah yeah...
Hidden agendas
03.08.2009 22:32
Ben
Shit Journalism
03.08.2009 22:54
Sod The BNP
Hardly new is it?
03.08.2009 23:24
Anti
"Come back to reality"?
03.08.2009 23:47
Are you saying that the 'Aryan Martyrs Brigade' is the stuff of reality? This sort of bollox just makes anti-fascists look stupid.
Sceptic
Searchlight
04.08.2009 02:17
Seriously - what's the beef ? I used to subscribe and always felt they were not only genuine but effective. So why do so many people slag them off ?
Anything beyond vague, wild, hearsay would be gratefully received.
veg
Homepage: http://fatsquirrel.org/bologs/veghead/
What's wrong with searchlight
04.08.2009 07:38
@ntifa
Searchlight was first exposed as State in 1983!
04.08.2009 07:56
Black n Red
Nowts changed
04.08.2009 08:09
"The SWP and others such as the Anti-Nazi League wanted to make political capital out of fascism, by selling their newspapers and chanting "Nazi Scum", often at the very people going out to bash the fash."
Nowt's changed then!
Old salt
Bennett
04.08.2009 08:32
Antifascist
Bad journalism
04.08.2009 09:07
Robin Banks
antifa
04.08.2009 16:17
Me
Not "macho" at all.
04.08.2009 16:23
Another antifascistN
Time to stick together
04.08.2009 16:26
There is far too much factionalism going on in the anti-fascist movement and in the left in general. Image how the Nazi scum will feel at Codnor if we ALL turn up, united in our determination to close down their fascist rally but also to show them that no longer will we tolerate there hateful views in our society. It doesn't matter whether you're Hope Not Hate, Antifa, UAF or Searchlight; what we ALL want is an end to this growth of fascism. UNITED we are strong, divided we're just a bunch of disperate lefties pissing in the wind.
Let's stand together at Codnor and let's close the scum BNP down.
Leeds Anti-Fascist
Sorry 'Me', you're missing the point
04.08.2009 16:33
Myself
To 'Myself'
04.08.2009 17:09
I disagree the state can never be useful, I don't have any moral issue with using them to get a result. For example, I don't think it is wrong to expose an opponents criminal record (if it will sway public opinion) or to try and have a group arrested if this is the easiest way to have them removed from an area. I also don't think it is wrong to take many forms of illegal direct action.
Is this wrong of me? Maybe? But if it works...
Me
Morality aside
04.08.2009 17:41
The point is, it doesn't.
Ben
A personal attack?
04.08.2009 17:43
Myself
United Against Fascism?
04.08.2009 18:09
For the likes of Searchlight and the UAF the ‘protest’ at Codnor has absolutely nothing to do with closing the RWB down. That is why the ‘demo’ is being held miles away from the RWB site, by prior arrangment with the police, effectively in the middle of nowhere. This is merely ‘spectacle’, a nice safe opportunity for the UAF to pretend they’re doing something while collecting money and selling papers. And more importantly diverting well-meaning antifascists from what really needs to be done to close down the RWB. Experience shows that any attempt at more radical action out of the control of the UAF will be ruthlessly denounced as “adventurism” or the work of ‘agent-provocateurs’. Experience also shows that the UAF and HnH leadership will co-operate fully with the police in assisting in the prosecution of any elements not under their control.
As long as antifascists continue to allow themselves to be manipulated, exploited, and side-tracked by opportunists like the UAF, we will get nowhere in terms of confronting the BNP. We are stronger without them. There’s a difference between united, and being suckered.
Another Leeds Antifascist
To Ben
04.08.2009 18:26
me
XWP coverage
04.08.2009 22:09
http://www.socialistworker.co.uk/art.php?id=18697
Could they really lick the cunt's arse any more or make antifascists look any more stupid if they tried?!
The piece includes this:
"Tim, an anti-fascist campaigner from Sheffield, told Socialist Worker, “I have had a number of threatening calls, including one playing Nazi marching music down the phone and another with recordings of chants of ‘Heil Hitler’."
Fucking diddums! Will you wankers please fuck off, you're a fucking embarrassment?
Sick of Trots
Anti-Fascism Divided
04.08.2009 22:23
I'm well aware of the tedious Antifa vs Searchlight "debate", and if anyone's naive enough to think either side has perfect strategies, or that either side behaves with perfect integrity, then welcome to real world. Anyone who's been watching this sorry spectacle will know that the BNP used a professional spamming company in the USA to circulate an e-mail around Anti-Fascists pretending to be from a fake "Real AFA" group, to try and make the dispute between militant Anti-Fascists and the UAF + Searchlight EVEN WORSE. The BNP are laughing while you twats are slugging it out between yourselves.
I have the greatest respect for the courage of many Antifa activists, but the reason UAF etc can get away with stealing Antifa's thunder is because Antifa is too much of a shambles to present any realistic alternative. Antifa pulled off a good one with the anti-BPP rally in Leeds and their forcing UAF to jump on the bandwagon at RWB is paradoxically also ones of their sucesses. Many of Antifa's statements however seem deliberately designed to alienate ordinary people who just happen to hate the BNP, so if Antifa really want to rule this particular roost, the way to deal with UAF is for Antifa to excel in combatting Fascism, not to waste their energy making enemies amongst people who gravitate towards the liberal Anti-Fascist groups for the simple reason that you geniuses don't yet constitute a genuinely viable alternative.
Fightback
Don't shoot the messenger
04.08.2009 22:38
Maybe that's not saying much, but it's still true...
And if you don't like hearing that - don't bitch, PROVE me wrong!
Anti_BNP
time gentlemen please
04.08.2009 23:03
pantihat
Mike posted this article
04.08.2009 23:04
no sleep
The phantom AMB?
04.08.2009 23:11
So who are the "Aryan Martyr's Brigade"? Aside from Searchlight and the puppet Guardian articles, has anyone heard of them before? Any chatter on right-wing forums? Any evidence that they actually exist beyond some online posturing? No!
Sadly a lot of people will swallow this crap and it'll put off a lot of potential anti-fascists - folks who may be scared off by the largely non-existent implication of violence. Yes, the extreme right could be a threat, but the fact is that right now they largely aren't.
So who benefits from this hyping up of the imaginary far-right extremists? The state and security services certainly have a lot to gain. Like Searchlight - after all, without the "bad guys" they'd be out of a job. And elements of the discredited left have a lot to gain - the illusory threat of the far-right sells a lot of papers...
And the laughable Redwatch... what a crock of shit. I'm on there along with quite a few of my mates. Has anything happened to me? No... Why? Because sites like that - and 'white' elephants like the AMB - are pointless bogeymen meant to scare off the feint-hearted.
I think people need to apply some critical analysis to organisations like Searchlight and UAF, because while they may spout the right platitudes, their actions in over-exagerating the power of the fascists actually play straight into the enemy's hands.
Yorkshire RASH
Trots & anarchists...
04.08.2009 23:29
"I hate Trots but the truth is they're alot better at campaigning against the BNP than militant anarchists are
Maybe that's not saying much, but it's still true...
And if you don't like hearing that - don't bitch, PROVE me wrong! "
The fact is that both strategies have proved to be wrong since neither have worked.
I hope I don't need to go into any deep analysis of the reasons why - though I suspect Indymedia readership may need a reminder.
Personally, I can't help smiling when a fascist gets a clout, but however rewarding it is lamping them, it's not going to make them go away.
We need to be on the ground (and fuck the labour party) talking to people and re-engaging with our own communities.
Not pushing any right or left orthodoxy, just starting from the ground up - something it seems no politicians can be arsed with right now.
And shite to the BNP.
Yorkshire RASH
No...
04.08.2009 23:39
No, neither of them has the slightest shred of credibility in the working class communities that matter. And the trots are hardly likely to gain much foothold with their inherent authoritarianism and middle-class bias.
I remember doing some anti-BNP leafleting in East End Park in Leeds and an SWP / UAF woman bemoaning how it was "an area that some of her clients might live in..."
If you don't understand that, don't ask me to spell it out...
Yorkshire RASH again
Antifa vs the BNP
04.08.2009 23:56
Fucking stupid the BNP may be, but Nick Griffin was at least intelligent enough to promote the "modernisation" of the BNP in the equivalent time period, not because he was (relatively speaking) any sort of moderate, but because he was a known hard-liner. Nick Griffin promoted a moderate image not because he wanted to sell-out Fascism, but because he wanted Fascism to succeed. The point I'm trying to make is that the movement that LEARNED anything from its mistakes since the 1980s was in fact the BNP.......
Fightback
Cannon fodder
05.08.2009 00:36
I understand that Searchlight "hyping" groups like C18 frightens people off physically opposing Fascists who are often just insecure fantasists, but it would be deeply irresponsible for militant Anti-Fascists not to acknowledge that physical confrontation with Nazis can, even if only sometimes, be fucking dangerous. If you don't acknowledge this, then you are potentially risking people's lives, and using ordinary people as cannon-fodder for your ideology.
Anti_BNP
Class War
05.08.2009 09:12
antifascist
A sense of reality
05.08.2009 09:34
Antifa activist
Class War and Antifa
05.08.2009 09:49
Cannon Fodder
"Popular Front for the Liberation of Judea... Splitters!"
05.08.2009 09:59
Some of the historic allegations against Searchlight are valid, but equally some of Searchlight's actions have been misinterpreted by frankly paranoid militants, and alot of Antifa's hostility to Searchlight stems from unacknowledged jealousy and from a refusal to take responsibility for the disgusting way some CW activists behaved in the 1980s.
Either way, the message is the same - ideologically I'm far closer to Anarchism than Communism, but I still think Antifa's constant bitching is pathetic. UAF and Hope not Hate are the only serious opposition to the BNP at the moment, and while I admire and respect militant Anti-Fascists, Antifa's "loose cannon" attitude sometimes arguably even HELPS the BNP.
Microscope
CW and antifa
05.08.2009 10:23
There always seem to be other anarchists having a go at antifa on here, but there words would mean more if they were involved to the same extent themselves. Anarchists should know better than working with searchlight or the trots. It seems that anyone who agrees with their principles, which most anarchists would, can join antifa or even set up there own antifascist group, so why aren't more anarchists getting involved. Viva antifa!
PS If noone has seen it there newsletter is good and there is a good statement on the front of a recent issue which everyone should read in my opinion. Its at www.antifa.org.uk
@narchist antifascist
CW-Antifa
05.08.2009 10:34
Retired (for now)
Fuck Searchlight
05.08.2009 10:41
Red & Black
Pantihose
05.08.2009 10:45
And some people regard the struggle against fascism as a bit more than that. Wanker.
Bob
Meanwhile at the computer
05.08.2009 11:01
here's what the good comrades at Meanwhile At The Bar think.
http://meanwhileatthebar.org/bar/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=20842
- Meanwhile At The Bar, i'm informed, is a small group of middle-aged men with dad's army complexes who think the iwca is the way forward in opposoing fascism/bnp. Apart the odd normal person i don't think any MATB have ever 'organised' in their communities and as such we can never know if they are right.
Lexus Carmat
Homepage: http://meanwhileatthebar.org/bar/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=37&t=20842
MATB
05.08.2009 11:08
Internet Be Damned!
at the computer
05.08.2009 11:12
LOL!
Serious debate
05.08.2009 11:17
It's also an article of faith that the "vote for anyone else because the BNP are nasty Nazis" strategy used by Hope not Hate + UAF has "failed", necessitating more confrontational strategies. There are many situations in which violence IS morally justified but is still NOT politically or strategically expedient, and in the last Euro election 35% of the electorate voted, 94% of them voting AGAINST the BNP (where in the previous Euro election something like 96% voted against the BNP), allowing the BNP under Proportional Representation to get their 1st taste of real power. There's a risk of throwing the baby out with the bath water, because to conclude that this strategy has "failed" because it's "only" working at 94% efficiency as opposed to 96% efficiency is obviously logical nonsense. Because a strategy isn't working as well as it used to is not a reason to abandon it completely, and this strategy can be used when and where it's useful alongside other strategies (no shit Sherlock)
The growth of the BNP means that Anti-Fascism needs fresh ideas sharpish, but effective strategies won't be devised unless people engage in honest debate. For instance (to respond to "@narchist antifascist" and to "Red and Black") yes of course Antifa do loads of stuff they can't talk about but SO DO I, and ducking the debate on grounds of ASSUMING that people who criticise Antifa are not "involved" or are doing "fuck all" is absolute bollocks, logically and factually ;)
Over and out
Fightback
CW
05.08.2009 11:19
LOL!CW
Antifa V Class War!
05.08.2009 11:23
Antifa - Crap name, no merchandise, good propaganda, lots of members
LOL!
Stop bitching and get on with the work!
05.08.2009 11:50
It is mostly right to say you can't debate with Fascists, but this does not mean we shouldn't debate ABOUT Fascists, as it's rational debate that generates new ideas & which keeps the majority of ordinary, decent working people from ever being suckered by Fascist beliefs (especially when new generations of youngsters come forward who are not familiar with the history of Antifascism or of the NF & BNP).
Sadly the belief that it's not worth debating with Fascists has led some militant Anti-Fascists to believe that it's not worth bothering with real debate (as opposed to trading insults) with liberal Anti-Fascists either, which is one of the reasons why the militants are so marginalised - but if militants want to re-run the process that whittled CW down to the sorry state @narchist antifascist pointed out they're in now, then I guess we have to defer to their superior authority?
Stop bitching and get on with the work!
Jewish Lad
The SWP and the RWB
05.08.2009 11:54
This year they are really pushing their anti-RWB rally, but of course its with prior arrangment with the police and well away from the BNP - a typical UAF event in other words. Now they're using the none-story about SWP-member Weyman Bennett and the fantasy Nazis of the AMB to try and increase the numbers at the event and their faux-militant credibility. No doubt Bennett will be presented as 'martyr-in-waiting' at the event itself, and those who attend will once again have to listen to one of his awful speeches.
If there is any disruption to the RWB it will be no thanks to the UAF/SWP. By the time they arrive in Codnor the RWB will most likely be well under way and the fascists who attend it will be well out of earshot. A token walk-past by Bennett and the UAF leadership, as per last year, will simply be a show of weakness, and the fascists are entitled to laugh at it.
If antifascists genuinely want to stop the RWB why turn up when it is already underway to a pre-arranged police RV? Codnor-Denby is a much lonlier (and unpoliced) area now, and at night? We should be using effective tactics against fascist mobilisation not ineffectual street-theatre.
Antifascist
RWB
05.08.2009 12:07
Fightback
Oh for more firepower! ;)
05.08.2009 12:28
Antifascist
The SWP
05.08.2009 13:39
Old timer
a contradiction
05.08.2009 13:50
unimpressed
Butchers at MATB
05.08.2009 13:56
Bloody Hell! He has got a bee in his bonnet hasn't he?! FFS have a break Butchers! Get out n have a go at the Fash for a change, it'll cheer you up!
achingsides
Unimpressed 2
05.08.2009 14:10
About a year later I went out leafleting with a Leeds antifascist group called the 635 group and things couldn't have been more different. We went into a quite hostile area in a fleet of cars, about 50 of us. Everything was very tight with people leafleting door to door in teams while others took care of security, they even had cars driving round the area looking for any opposition and radio communication between the front and rear of the group. It was all done very proffessionally and I felt many times safer than I did with the UAF, they were obviously very experienced, security conscious, and focused. There was also a proper de-brief after which was good. It also showed some of us who had not been involved much in these kind of things before that 'militant antifascism' isn't just about hitting people and it wasn't 'macho' either, there were plenty of women there for example. I'm sure if more people were interested in opposing the BNP and looked a bit further than the UAF groups like this one could do a lot more good work. I was proud to be with them that day.
G (Leeds)
seems like a good piece
05.08.2009 14:29
While most of us are struggling with the effects of the current crisis in capitalism, the British National Party are busy making hay. They see the bosses’ recession as a political windfall, and just as Hitler used Germany's economic problems to scapegoat the Jews, they are scapegoating 'immigrants' and asylum-seekers. The BNP were smashed off the streets by militant antifascists in the past, but now they are beginning to crawl back out of the sewers to spread their racist poison in our communities. It is time to stand and fight.
Antifa is committed to confronting fascism wherever it appears, but we cannot be everywhere. If the BNP are to be defeated, whole communities must unite against them, and all autonomous antifascists must organize to defend their communities and help stop the rise of the BNP. Despite what the middle-class Left tell us, this will take more than petitions or appeals to politicians, it will take direct action.
Throughout the country the BNP are holding meetings, paper-sales, and street stalls on a regular basis. Whenever they come out onto the streets we have to be there to confront them. Now is the time to stop the BNP. Now is the time to act.
By any means necessary.
ANTIFA ENGLAND
from antifa website
RWB - And just in case anyone escapes the UAF corrall...
05.08.2009 15:13
Drone used to monitor BNP event
A drone fitted with video cameras will be flown over a British National Party gathering in Derbyshire after dozens of protesters were arrested last year.
Police are using the plane to monitor the event near Ripley on 15 and 16 August and any protesters who turn out.
Last year police arrested more than 30 protesters near the site off Codner Denby Lane, but no-one was charged.
Officers said it would cost "about £500,000" to police the event. The plane will be used to record evidence.
Chief Constable Mike Creedon said: "We will apply to the Home Office for special funding which is occasionally available.
"I'm not overly hopeful about this. Last year's costs were something in the region of £300,000.
"It will be significantly more this year. I would think we're pushing around half a million pounds, and that comes from a budget which is already heavily stretched."
In a statement Derbyshire police said that a pilotless drone plane would be used to record evidence at the Red, White and Blue festival.
The force said: "The drone, fitted with CCTV cameras, will be used by a trained operator from the manufacturing company.
"It will record any incidents of disorder for evidence-gathering purposes."
It said it was not the first force in the country to use drone planes.
Black N Red
Concentrate on the BNP
05.08.2009 16:23
The reason for questioning Antifa's methods is not because Searchlight is a "sacred cow", but because the arguments put forward for wasting time attacking Searchlight are often (if not always) wrong. From Antifa's point of view the police are more of a threat to militant Anti-Fascism than Nazis are, but from the public's POV the police are more of a threat to violent Nazis than Anti-Fascists are. It was the police that stopped David Copeland, Neil Lewington, Martyn Gilleard, Robert Cottage, Nathan Worrell etc - not AFA, Red Action or Antifa, whatever they achieved elsewhere.
Fair play to Antifa supporters for defending the image of their group, but to point out that an "alliance" co-founded by Class War also includes the Anarchist Federation hardly proves Antifa's some broad church! The claim that Class War don't "control" Antifa England is pointless. Anarchists by definition don't control anyone, and you only have to look at Antifa's founding statement to see that class struggle Anarchism is (albeit in slightly coded language) central to Antifa's interpretation of Anti-Fascism. Great report about the 635 Group BTW - the 43 Group had a fleet of taxis and even their own doctors!
Jewish lad
Class
05.08.2009 16:25
Jewish lad
Responding to Jewish Lad
05.08.2009 17:11
There was of course a time when Searchlight were involved in AFA. They caused a lot of trouble, hence their eventual 'proscription'.
.
"From Antifa's point of view the police are more of a threat to militant Anti-Fascism than Nazis are, but from the public's POV the police are more of a threat to violent Nazis than Anti-Fascists are. It was the police that stopped David Copeland, Neil Lewington, Martyn Gilleard, Robert Cottage, Nathan Worrell etc - not AFA, Red Action or Antifa, whatever they achieved elsewhere."
I think that's a fair point. One of many JL.
"Fair play to Antifa supporters for defending the image of their group, but to point out that an "alliance" co-founded by Class War also includes the Anarchist Federation hardly proves Antifa's some broad church! The claim that Class War don't "control" Antifa England is pointless. Anarchists by definition don't control anyone, and you only have to look at Antifa's founding statement to see that class struggle Anarchism is (albeit in slightly coded language) central to Antifa's interpretation of Anti-Fascism. Great report about the 635 Group BTW - the 43 Group had a fleet of taxis and even their own doctors! "
Antifa is certainly not a broad church, but it's broader than some might imagine. It IS predominantly made up of Anarchists, but is not exclusively Anarchist. While Antifa was originally set up in London by individuals from CW, AF, and No Platform, that was before it was a national federation and before the adoption of its founding statement (which is closely modelled after The 635 Group founding statement. The original claim was that Antifa is a CW 'front', which it certainly is not. Nor is it a front for the AF.
Antifascist
635
05.08.2009 17:18
Ditto, good read. From what I know I'd be suprised if the 635 didn't have at least one doctor too!
James
MATB = Greek Chorus he he he
05.08.2009 19:48
Plays of the ancient Greek theatre always included a chorus that offered a variety of background and summary information to help the audience follow the performance. The Greek chorus comments on themes, and shows how an ideal audience might react to the drama.
The importance of the chorus declined after the 5th century, when the chorus began to be separated from the dramatic action. Later dramatists depended on the chorus less than their predecessors.
Gums
You can't have it both ways....
09.08.2009 15:45
Antifa also insist UAF "endangered" their own supporters by allowing a UAF e-mail list to fall into the hands of Fascists (which is true), but if Redwatch etc aren't dangerous then UAF supporters weren't put at risk - some militants are so desperate to discredit UAF that they ended up disproving their own argument here !
Nazis are mostly pathetic, but when we need to worry is when occasionally they DO walk the walk, and we don't need to resort to conspiracy theories to prove that Trots are daft.
Puncturing flabby Fascist egos and to emboldening Anti-Fascists to confront Nazis is all good, but Antifas need to remember that after Hitler's German Nazis were ELECTED, it was alleged left-wing militancy - the burning of the Reichstag - that gave Nazis the pretext to abolish democracy and establish their dictatorship!
The situation with UAF and Searclight is less black-and-white than some militants claim, and what we don't need is militants using the same class "analysis" that destroyed groups like Class War to divide the Anti-Fascist movement EVEN MORE
Jewish Lad