Skip to content or view screen version

Advice for Shell to Sea.

Anton Doyle | 13.05.2009 10:17

Fighting at the fence is no good as the State will win any battle on the street

Minister Burke off to jail
Minister Burke off to jail


In July 2004, Irish minister Ray Burke pleaded guilty to making false tax returns. The charges arose from his failure to declare for tax purposes the corrupt payments that he had received from the backers of Century Radio. On 24 January 2005 he was sentenced to 6 months in Arbour Hill Prison for these offences.
Burke was later unambiguously judged by Justice Flood to be "corrupt"

Protesters against the Shell pipeline, have claimed that the deal made by Burke which exempted the oil company Royal Dutch Shell from paying any royalties for the Irish gas had the hallmarks of a corrupt decision.

A civil action should be taken by “Shell to Sea”against Burke, Shell and the Irish State for allowing this obvious corruption to continue.

It would be easy to win a civil judgement against Burke for corruption as he is already a jailbirdfor the same crime.

If “Shell to Sea” don’t have the money they should raise it with a few gigs.


Anton Doyle

Comments

Hide the following 2 comments

copy to Ireland

13.05.2009 11:47

Please post this item on the Ireland IndyMedia site

kh


Oh FFS!

14.05.2009 20:09

At best (and making the flaky assumption the courts aren't equally corrupt), the result would be tangential. Don't knock the people struggling against the fence. They deserve to be supported, not undermined by clever-clogs. What they're doing is not tangential, it's confronting crime where it's happening.

Your idea isn't actually that clever. You assume a civil action would be easy-peasy because some washed-up ex-minister got a criminal conviction. Not necessarily so. The lower burden of proof cuts both ways. Lots more wriggle room. Do you really think an Irish civil court is going to bend over backwards to expose Shell as the corrupt scumbags they are. And even if this happened, so what? Most of the time, they're fairly blatant about it and don't really care.

Stroppyoldgit