Skip to content or view screen version

Third Runway - For and Against in Westminster

Peter Marshall | 20.02.2009 16:42 | Climate Chaos | Ecology

Two demonstrations took place in Westminster last night (19 Feb, 2009), In Parliament
Square around 20 people turned up for the Modern Movement event, along with a few from Plane Stupid to add a little interest, while on Whitehall around a thousand took their message "3rd Runway - NO WAY!" to Gordon Brown. Pictures Copyright (C) 2009 Peter Marshall, all rights reserved

One Solution: Aviation
One Solution: Aviation

99% can be wrong
99% can be wrong

Less Stupids
Less Stupids

One Solution: Aviation
One Solution: Aviation

NOTRAG speaker
NOTRAG speaker

Jean Lambert and other Greens: 3rd Runway - NO WAY!
Jean Lambert and other Greens: 3rd Runway - NO WAY!

Stop Airport Expansion
Stop Airport Expansion

Friends of the Earth
Friends of the Earth

NOTRAG
NOTRAG


Modern Movement calls itself a "a national, grassroots campaign group calling for 'faster, cheaper, better transport for all'" and around 20 mainly young professional people turned up for a demonstration in favour of building a third runway at Heathrow.

It's hard to understand people who appear to feel that the freedom of a few of us (and it is a very small fraction of the world's population) to take cheap holiday flights if we chose to is somehow our most basic human right. As I could hardly believe, Alex Hochuli, one of its co-founders, said on Worldbytes ( http://www.worldbytes.org/programmes/005/005_011.html) "the ability to travel, to see the world, to work abroad, to live abroad, to have other people come here is more important than dealing with climate change."

So there you have it. The planet can go hang just so long as a few of us in the rich worlds can have cheap air travel. The group seems to be linked to the (former) So there you have it. The planet can go hang just so long as a few of us in the rich worlds can have cheap air travel.

The Modern Movement - like the web magazine 'Spike' in which you can read a piece by Hochuli about it, appears to be a child of the former Revolutionary Communist party, which once published Living Marxism, but changed its name to LM as it lurched precipitously towards an ultra-right free market future.

Plane Stupid's placards, claiming to be from the 'Living Marxism Network' and the 'Revolutionary Communist Party' stating 'Down with the Ice Caps', '99% of Scientists can be wrong" and "One Solution: Aviation" could hardly have been objected to by the Modern Movement, and demonstrated it was impossible to outflank their lunatic views.

Their presence of a few people from Plane Stupid in Parliament Square caused a security scare, with a general alert going out to all security staff in the GSZ (Government Security Zone) to watch out for "a possible impromptu demonstration from the 'plane stupid' group". One of the two people who tried to join in the demonstration with her placard was looked after by a couple of officers for most of the time I was there (somehow it took them around half an hour to notice the second) and they refused to allow her to join the group, threatening her with action under SOCPA.

A couple of hundred yards down the road opposite Downing St was a much larger crowd - my estimate was around a thousand people. It was a much more disparate group in terms of age and background, with people from the Green Party, environmental groups and others, and including many local residents from Sipson, Harlington and Harmondsworth, as well as from the large area of London that will be affected by increased aircraft movements.

There were several MPs present, including Susan Kramer, MP for Richmond Park and North Kingston and Labour MP for Hayes and Harlington, John McDonnell (who apologised for not bringing a mace with him) and London Green MEP Jean Lambert.

More pictures shortly on My London Diary  http://mylondondiary.co.uk/2009/02/feb.htm#runway

Peter Marshall
- e-mail: petermarshall@cix.co.uk
- Homepage: http://mylondondiary.co.uk

Comments

Hide the following 2 comments

Flying is not just for the rich

22.02.2009 19:47

Peter Marshall talks as if only rich people flew, but that is not true. There were more than eighteen million package holidays sold in 2005. Even Peter Marshall flew to Brasilia. Most of the Plane Stupid people have flown at various times; and many of the people who try to frighten us about the dangers of Global Warming are frequent fliers.

Peter Marshall says he does not understand how some people think that their freedom to fly is more important than saving the planet. The answer is that not everyone believes that flying is going to cause the planet to burn up.

James Heartfield
mail e-mail: Heartfield@blueyonder.co.uk
- Homepage: http://www.heartfield.org


Flying etc

23.02.2009 09:53

Of course I did fly to Brasilia - and I was there to mount an exhibition and give a talk as a part of an event on the environment and sustainability. I have never flown except on business, and only then when no other suitable means of transport was available. I've never bought an airline ticket myself, never taken a holiday that needed a flight. But this is perhaps the first time I've made a public statement about a personal decision that I took over 40 years ago when I first studied the impact human activities were having on the environment.

And to comment on one of their placards, I'd really love to go around the world on a bicycle, the ideal way to do so, as a number of people have. Leisure flying seems to me to be largely a way of avoiding most of the world while moving from one pocket of privilege to another.

I'm not against flying as such, but against the kind of naivety about it and the state of the planet that the comment and the whole 'Modern Movement' represents.

I had an e-mail myself in which James says that it was the police and not the MM who objected to Plane Stupid taking part in the demo - and that the MM argued unsuccessfully with the police in support of PS's right to protest. If so, I'm sorry that I misunderstood the conversation that I overheard between a steward, an officer and a protester. I was busy taking pictures and didn't stay listening for long.

Also on the major demonstration of the evening I note that the organisers put the number attending at 400, rather lower than my estimate. It was rather difficult to count.

Peter Marshall
mail e-mail: petermarshall@cix.co.uk
- Homepage: http://mylondondiary.co.uk