Skip to content or view screen version

Open letter to Foreign Secretary David Miliband re Gaza

Paul O'Hanlon | 02.01.2009 13:51 | Anti-militarism | Anti-racism | Palestine | World

This is a letter I have sent to British Foreign secretary David Miliband about Gaza.

The Foreign Secretary
The Rt Hon David Miliband MP
Foreign and Commonwealth Office
London
SW1A 2AH

Friday 2nd January 2009

Dear Mr Miliband
I am appalled by the horrific events in Gaza. Israel is savagely bombing a largely unarmed and defenceless people. There is surely no equivalence between the feeble Qassam rockets fired at Sderot and the 100 tons or more of bombs delivered by American supplied F-16 jet fighters and Apache helicopters. It is disgraceful that targets have included Parliament buildings, universities, mosques and fuel trucks. Douglas Alexander, Britain's International Development Secretary is quoted as saying "Thousands are suffering. Medical items are in short supply. Fuel shortages have led to power cuts which in turn are affecting hospitals and other essential services.”

The Israeli navy’s ramming of the boat `Dignity` which was delivering 3.5 tonnes of Cypriot medical aid to the Gaza Strip shocked me. 6 Israeli naval vessels rammed the ship in international waters. The 20m Dignity was carrying 16 civilian passengers, including several doctors, journalists, a former US congresswoman (Cynthia McKinney) and a member of the Cypriot parliament.

UN special rapporteur Richard Falk was leading a mission that had intended to visit the West Bank and Gaza to prepare a report on Israel's compliance with human rights standards and international humanitarian law. Disgracefully he was denied admission to Israel and was made to wait for 15 hours in a filthy room. Professor Falk was treated not as a UN representative, but as some sort of security threat. The obvious intention was to humble Professor Falk as a UN representative and thereby send a message of defiance to the United Nations.

The Israeli blockade of Gaza, resulting in the collective punishment of the 1.5 million inhabitants, is totally illegal and should be lifted at once. The fact that the Palestinian people exercised their democratic right in the elections of January 2006 in no way justifies indiscriminate Israeli retaliation against the entire civilian population of Gaza. Human rights organisation Amnesty International said, "It is utterly unacceptable for Israel to continue to purposefully deprive 1.5 million people of food and other basic necessities. Such a policy cannot be justified on any security or other grounds and must end immediately."
Let the people of Gaza live!

Yours Sincerely,
Paul O’Hanlon



Paul O'Hanlon
- e-mail: o_hanlon@hotmail.com

Comments

Hide the following 3 comments

comment

02.01.2009 18:51

quite a bit of info there, but you havn't told him what you want.
He going to be thinking: its not my country, its all those ab-jabs over in the east causing the trouble, why is this person writing to me?

leana


what to demand from mps, pm and foreign secs.

02.01.2009 20:53

you/we should demand an immediate and total trade ban with israel and urge the whole of the eu to do likewise. likewise you/we should write demanding that until the israeli regime stop behaving like a bunch of fucking psychos, this country and the eu should break off all diplomatic relations, call the ambassador in immediately and tell him "right you bunch of murdering cunts, you have 24 hours to pack your bags and leave your embassy and this country". finally this country should resolve to never ever sell so much as a single bullet to that vile regime again.

demand away


Very good, except for one thing

02.01.2009 23:10

This is a very eloquent, persuasive, well-informed and accurate letter. You have done a very good job with this. Only problem with it is, as a previous poster mentioned, you haven't said what the Foreign Secretary is doing wrong, that being that he is only criticising Hamas and Israel evenly at best, arguably placing more blame on Hamas than Israel, which anyone who knows anything about Israel-Palestine will realise is severly unjust. Miliband and Brown should use the same language with Israel as they do with Mugabe; their regimes are just as evil, only difference is a large section of the British electorate will come out in support of Israel, but this would never happen for Mugabe.

Anyway, very very good letter, just if you ever get a chance to amend it tell Mr Miliband what he is doing wrong, use my suggestion above if you want or maybe you have other grievances with his actions (or rather the lack of them).

Good on you for putting some effort into doing something about this massacre.

Matt