Eden Project Sexy Green Car Show: Almost Beyond Comment
Keith Farnish | 07.05.2008 14:31 | Climate Chaos | Ecology | Technology | South Coast
If you want a lovely day out, pop down to the Eden Project between 23 and 31 May, and spend some time decorating the lovely "green" cars. A few bits of plantlife, some green spray paint and a chainsaw should do the trick (but leave the trees alone...)
A few years ago, possibly in 2004, I visited the Eden Project; a mixture of perfectly tended meadows, terraces and exotic planting, topped off by a pair of impressive plastic “biomes” (they were building the third at the time), all in the setting of an abandoned clay pit in Cornwall, England. My family took home some wonderful memories from that day — it was steaming hot, so much so that the Tropical Biome had to be fully vented; my younger daughter had endless fun running around the mazes and gawping at the giant bee; my older daughter discovered what it was like to be soaked in a tropical mist.
Spin forwards four years, and something has gone bad in Eden — they are allowing themselves to be used as a platform for every major car company to do a spot of greenwashing. What better place to pretend you have the interests of the planet at heart than at the Eden Project, that bastion of sustainable tourism and ecological education for all generations? What better place to show that cars are not bad things — they are just misunderstood.
The official blurb makes for deeply uncomfortable reading:
"Why a car show at the Eden Project?
"Love them or hate them, cars are not going away. But road transport accounts for a fifth of our carbon dioxide emissions in the UK, so it’s time to transform the way we buy and use them.
"The good news is that we can reduce road transport carbon dioxide emissions by a massive 80% by 2050 if we start buying the right vehicles now and take our old bangers off the roads. The technology is out there and our Sexy Green Car Show brings it to you."
You can read this in one of two ways: first, that there is a general acceptance that car transport is not going away for a long time, so we need to make the best of the situation we have; second, that car transport is a good thing, and it can be made even better if it is made greener. The difference is subtle, but is important.
The first explanation is realistic — it accepts that there will be a need for some car transport, in some places for quite a while until alternatives are found or, more importantly, people stop having the need to travel so much. The second explanation is straight out of the greenwashing guide, written by the automotive giants. Yes, maybe individual vehicle emissions can reduce by 80% in 42 years (not that that is anything like sufficient), but the car companies are exploiting huge markets in Asia and South America, plus pushing to ensure car transport is the only option for travel in the industrial West: net transport emissions are unlikely to go down at all, regardless of how “green” individual vehicles are.
The second explanation is the true meaning of the Sexy Green Car Show. Take a look at the roster of companies showing at the event:
"All the major manufacturers will be flaunting their newest, greenest models including Ford, Peugeot, Citroën, Fiat, Volkswagen, SEAT, Honda, Axon, Lotus, Saab and Morgan. Vectrix’s electric motorcycle will also be on show, and the hydrogen-powered Morgan LIFE car will make its first public appearance in this country."
This is a trade event, designed to make car manufacturers look good, while still continuing their effortless plundering of the planet’s diminishing natural assets. Eden Project, you have well and truly been taken for a ride.
Spin forwards four years, and something has gone bad in Eden — they are allowing themselves to be used as a platform for every major car company to do a spot of greenwashing. What better place to pretend you have the interests of the planet at heart than at the Eden Project, that bastion of sustainable tourism and ecological education for all generations? What better place to show that cars are not bad things — they are just misunderstood.
The official blurb makes for deeply uncomfortable reading:
"Why a car show at the Eden Project?
"Love them or hate them, cars are not going away. But road transport accounts for a fifth of our carbon dioxide emissions in the UK, so it’s time to transform the way we buy and use them.
"The good news is that we can reduce road transport carbon dioxide emissions by a massive 80% by 2050 if we start buying the right vehicles now and take our old bangers off the roads. The technology is out there and our Sexy Green Car Show brings it to you."
You can read this in one of two ways: first, that there is a general acceptance that car transport is not going away for a long time, so we need to make the best of the situation we have; second, that car transport is a good thing, and it can be made even better if it is made greener. The difference is subtle, but is important.
The first explanation is realistic — it accepts that there will be a need for some car transport, in some places for quite a while until alternatives are found or, more importantly, people stop having the need to travel so much. The second explanation is straight out of the greenwashing guide, written by the automotive giants. Yes, maybe individual vehicle emissions can reduce by 80% in 42 years (not that that is anything like sufficient), but the car companies are exploiting huge markets in Asia and South America, plus pushing to ensure car transport is the only option for travel in the industrial West: net transport emissions are unlikely to go down at all, regardless of how “green” individual vehicles are.
The second explanation is the true meaning of the Sexy Green Car Show. Take a look at the roster of companies showing at the event:
"All the major manufacturers will be flaunting their newest, greenest models including Ford, Peugeot, Citroën, Fiat, Volkswagen, SEAT, Honda, Axon, Lotus, Saab and Morgan. Vectrix’s electric motorcycle will also be on show, and the hydrogen-powered Morgan LIFE car will make its first public appearance in this country."
This is a trade event, designed to make car manufacturers look good, while still continuing their effortless plundering of the planet’s diminishing natural assets. Eden Project, you have well and truly been taken for a ride.
Keith Farnish
Homepage:
http://www.unsuitablog.org
Additions
hydrogen-powered Morgan LIFE car
07.05.2008 19:45
This always pisses me off. Hydrogen is not an energy source, it's an energy carrier!
The energy still has to be generated somewhere and if you're recharging your fuel cell from the national grid, then you're still burning hydrocarbons to get energy.
I whole-heartedly support increased pragmatism in the green movement but this stinks of "we need a new revenue/funding source."
The energy still has to be generated somewhere and if you're recharging your fuel cell from the national grid, then you're still burning hydrocarbons to get energy.
I whole-heartedly support increased pragmatism in the green movement but this stinks of "we need a new revenue/funding source."
MonkeyBot5000
Comments
Hide the following 5 comments
Eden project funders
07.05.2008 16:18
El
What more proof do you need?
07.05.2008 19:28
green capitalism sucks!
Biofuel support
08.05.2008 05:31
They also seemed to be pushing literature in the shop that supported the exploitation of poverty stricken workforces in other countries as it "gave them an opportunity for jobs and improved their standard of living". i.e. Typical capitalist rhetoric in favour of the 'globalisation' of labour.
Concerned
Eden Project
08.05.2008 16:35
Openly advertised it was built by the road building experince of McAlpine.
All the species were labelled in terms of their 'uses'.
All the punters were revolting middle-class families pretending to give a shit about the environment for the day.
A Reader
Nice rant -- but what's your solution?
23.05.2008 18:28
As you go some way to conceding, people will use private road transport -- i.e. personal cars -- for some time to come, regardless of how much I'd rather they were out on public transport, cycling and walking.
So what if car companies make some money out of 'greener' cars? Capitalism needs to see cash in green if we have any hope of tackling climate change on a serious scale.
At least we'll have a few people might switch their cars to more efficient ones as a result of this show.
Adam