Skip to content or view screen version

White working class? Is that investigative journalism?

Paula Sharratt | 06.03.2008 21:41 | Analysis | Anti-racism | Globalisation | Sheffield

Most local and national journalism defaults to notions of an underclass of 'losers' without any analysis of how these 'losers' have been structurally excluded. The recent discovery of 'working class' and 'white' as a disadvantaged group is for purely cynical and sensationalist reasons.

White working class? There’s a constructed debate going around the local and national media, smoothed by the professional caresses of a professional media class who don’t have accurate information, (don’t want accurate information).

Who really don’t give a fig.

And would much rather base their stories and practice on the fictional glamour of the grubby people they continue to exclude on a day to day basis (because there’s a real living to be made in taking the mickey, humiliating one group or another).

They’re not really talking about the ‘working class’ then, but the empty of anything ‘underclass’ that they’ve been instrumental in constructing, concentrating on the negatives rather than any positives, crushing the life out of anything not like themselves...

-and now the category has been around for twenty years or so it’s so easy to abuse and manipulate, to wrong foot and catch out, to surveil and make guilty anyone who has that tag.

But now the ‘discovery’ of the (white) working class that, in their usual day to day lives, in their own race to have ‘that career’ they usually call the underclass or the losers. Their knowledge of other working class experiences from other cultures is nil.

In my opinion, Underclass is really a group of people who have been permanently excluded from the economy in order to remove all traces of the benefits of the welfare state and cooperation between people and provide benefit fodder in the buy to let economy and very cheap and unsustaining labour.

Underclass is a group of people who are structurally always in the wrong and therefore, cannot move without making a mistake in the way they live, work, bring up their children, socialise. People who believe they are part of society but have been brutalised by their experience of exclusion.

But there are working class stories now, except the working class of now, from all cultures, often doesn’t work for long periods of time

-and you can bet your bottom dollar that the stories these working class, people, be they white or Irish or Chinese, Bengali, Jewish, Jamaican, or whichever ever gloriously invisible cultural lineage has been hammered out of them are interesting and the inextricable roots of everything our culture takes for granted as ‘our civilisation’.


But these stories don’t get written or even rehearsed by our media.

The stories of the working class are a little bit too real and normal and just like their own feelings and aspirations to fit the ‘glamour in nihilism’ market and so

-they should really know better before setting one group against another. But it’s all good, ignorant and prejudiced fun, like it always used to be before political correctness, say the tabloid harpies.


The constructed debate about the white working class and the suddenly found group of grubby white people who are being done down by housing allocation, education and work opportunity givers is really a story about intra-organisational competition over funding.

The reality of how all of the working class (in an underclass environment) are really struggling to survive the ignorance of the sensationalist media and how their stories aren’t being told is another very important matter.

Paula Sharratt
- e-mail: poly.sharratt@btinternet.com

Comments

Hide the following 3 comments

Sort of agree

07.03.2008 01:09

I agree with the gist of what you're saying, the idea of the masters making programmes defending 'these poor people' reeks of a noblesse oblige attitude.

But is it true to say that there are no working class stories on TV? Pop Idol and Britain's Got Talent are working class stories, and very good ones, however much we find that embarrassing and frustrating. If you type 'britain' into google the first separate entry you get is for 'Britain's got Talent', and that my friend, speaks volumes about the state we find ourselves a part of.

On the up side, there are documentary series like 'One Life' that depict (admittedly non-standard) working class stories about as honestly as a TV show can.

You can't beat a bus journey for a bit of 'oh my GOSH' style drama and gossip tho! :-)

Boyd


Sorry for being cynical but.....

07.03.2008 15:57

Stories from the under class like this Paula?

 http://www.transitiontradition.com/magazine_article_pic.php?article_id=124

My proles bigger than your prole


at least she is interested

08.03.2008 12:38

@My prole

At least Paula is showing some interest in the working class, W/C issues, the poor in this country. Most of the left, radicals, etc, seem to have abandoned the poor and those on benefits, in favour of campaigning on abstractions or the usual button issues, migration, the environment, peace, etc. One has to ask where are the campaigns against the benefit cuts, privatisation of welfare, housing benefit changes, etc?, can't see them...

weneedanotherOrwell