Thought-crime conviction
Sherman McCoy | 08.11.2007 13:16 | Terror War | Birmingham
Samina Malik has been convicted of thinking or writing unacceptable things under the Terrorism Act 2000. This invasion of the mind by the authorities and the courts is yet another example of the annihilation of civil liberties. Whilst Georgians and lawyers in Pakistan rise up to challenge their governments why is it that we are so accepting of the assault on our freedoms.
"In the end, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends."
Dr Martin Luther King
The Old Baileys valuable time has recently been taken up with the prosecution of WHSmith, Heathrow shopworker Samina Malik. She now finds herself convicted of the crime of "possessing records likely to be used for terrorism". In the same way that the mentally ill can now be locked up if they present a potential threat, thinkers who have not acted can also be charged and convicted. And at the international level a country can be dealt with pre-emptively if there is a suggestion of a threat. These rerpresent sinister applications of the precautionary principle, originally devised to take the necessary action where there is a potential threat to the environment or human health- as has been used to challenge the switch to GM food.
According to Maliks accusers she led a double-life in which she concealed a counter-identity as a threat to civilised society. The jury was left with little choice other than to convict her of collecting articles "likely to be useful to a person committing or preparing an act of terrorism". Despite this one member of the jury declared her not guilty
Yet Malik claims her poems were "meaningless" and she called herself the Lyrical Terrorist, she said, "because it sounded cool". It did not mean she was actually a terrorist or wanted to be one, she said.
Malik told the court she started writing love poetry while at Villiers High School in Southall. In early 2002, using the name Lyrical Babe, she said she began writing rap poems about guns and violence in the style of artists Tupac Shakur and 50 Cent. At the same time, she said her interest in Islam began to grow and in 2004 she started wearing a hijab. It was then that Malik changed her online name to the Lyrical Terrorist.
She told the court: "It is only a user name. You have taken it too literally and out of context. It was only because it was a cool name. It doesn't mean I'm a terrorist."
It could be you or me. I possess a record by Afro Mystik entitled 'Trivia terrorist". I also have other tracks by musicians such as Saul Williams who are critical of the war on terror. This is personal. If you are a white, British, property owner or car driver these measures are being taken in your name- in our name and yet those that resist could be next
It is interesting to juxtapose the accounts of the trial given by BBC Online and the Guardian. The BBC piece is more nuanced despite the fact that they couldn't resist placing a picture of that devil Abu Hamza at the top.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/terrorism/story/0,,2207426,00.html
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7068945.stm
I don't want to be overly critical or pessimistic and I extend this comment to myself. We in the libertarian/socialist movement are truly pathetic. Whilst people in Burma, China, India, Pakistan and Georgia are standing up to their governments on the streets all we seem capable of doing is lock ons or vacuous marches from A to B. My greatest crime is my fear, fear of what they will do to me yet everyday other people around the world overcome their fear and take risks.
How bad do things have to get before we take concerted positive action in the streets? By that time it may well be too late. Lets get out there, get bashed up and test the public mood
Dr Martin Luther King
The Old Baileys valuable time has recently been taken up with the prosecution of WHSmith, Heathrow shopworker Samina Malik. She now finds herself convicted of the crime of "possessing records likely to be used for terrorism". In the same way that the mentally ill can now be locked up if they present a potential threat, thinkers who have not acted can also be charged and convicted. And at the international level a country can be dealt with pre-emptively if there is a suggestion of a threat. These rerpresent sinister applications of the precautionary principle, originally devised to take the necessary action where there is a potential threat to the environment or human health- as has been used to challenge the switch to GM food.
According to Maliks accusers she led a double-life in which she concealed a counter-identity as a threat to civilised society. The jury was left with little choice other than to convict her of collecting articles "likely to be useful to a person committing or preparing an act of terrorism". Despite this one member of the jury declared her not guilty
Yet Malik claims her poems were "meaningless" and she called herself the Lyrical Terrorist, she said, "because it sounded cool". It did not mean she was actually a terrorist or wanted to be one, she said.
Malik told the court she started writing love poetry while at Villiers High School in Southall. In early 2002, using the name Lyrical Babe, she said she began writing rap poems about guns and violence in the style of artists Tupac Shakur and 50 Cent. At the same time, she said her interest in Islam began to grow and in 2004 she started wearing a hijab. It was then that Malik changed her online name to the Lyrical Terrorist.
She told the court: "It is only a user name. You have taken it too literally and out of context. It was only because it was a cool name. It doesn't mean I'm a terrorist."
It could be you or me. I possess a record by Afro Mystik entitled 'Trivia terrorist". I also have other tracks by musicians such as Saul Williams who are critical of the war on terror. This is personal. If you are a white, British, property owner or car driver these measures are being taken in your name- in our name and yet those that resist could be next
It is interesting to juxtapose the accounts of the trial given by BBC Online and the Guardian. The BBC piece is more nuanced despite the fact that they couldn't resist placing a picture of that devil Abu Hamza at the top.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/terrorism/story/0,,2207426,00.html
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7068945.stm
I don't want to be overly critical or pessimistic and I extend this comment to myself. We in the libertarian/socialist movement are truly pathetic. Whilst people in Burma, China, India, Pakistan and Georgia are standing up to their governments on the streets all we seem capable of doing is lock ons or vacuous marches from A to B. My greatest crime is my fear, fear of what they will do to me yet everyday other people around the world overcome their fear and take risks.
How bad do things have to get before we take concerted positive action in the streets? By that time it may well be too late. Lets get out there, get bashed up and test the public mood
Sherman McCoy
Comments
Hide the following 8 comments
Conspiring
08.11.2007 13:36
Mogger
hide THIS, as y'say
08.11.2007 15:56
T. T. T. T.
borgs-for-the-defence-of-the-borgias
waking up.
f grmpy, energy for bouncebacks. GFWF
about time we did...
09.11.2007 09:06
How long do we put up with this state racism? People being locked up for years for chanting on demos, possessing books and making random notes on the back of fag packets.
We are just not making enough noise about this. There are too many political prisoners in this country that do not get the support that they should, because they are not part of 'our' movement, and because everyone is too scared of supporting 'terrorism'.
on the streets
Crazy.
09.11.2007 14:01
poetry
having some books
having a nickname
visiting a website
the whole thing is just crazy. I'm sure if I worked at a hell hole of Heathrow's WHSmith selling Jordan's biography all day I'd write some angry poetry.. Do we not have any freedom in this country any more? And yet people are wearing poppies to show how people died for 'freedom.' Is this the freedom they died for?
jo
Where are the Human Rights activists?
09.11.2007 14:34
El Gringo Rumbero
e-mail: elgringorumbero@hotmail.com
Homepage: http://elgringorumbero.blogspot.com/
opinion-influencers, it is time-you-woke-up
10.11.2007 15:51
Or are we ? Such as . . . . what?
The possible creation of bogey-persons as "terrorists", using mesmerism with or without tech, as stooges or unwitting patsies AINT new, or that secret - mesmerist put in prison in sweden for trying to use a "patient" to do a "heist" for him, the 1890s/1913 bits from french parliamentary records, or USA gumshoe types, screwing over unions at the same time as screwing over their customers with odd "paranoia-inducing" bits of spin. Its straightforward fact, in the past, but, THESE days we get told - despite - one imagines - tech having got that sort of thing at least a BIT easier in the last century of cold-war distorted tech progress, that the idea of cash-acquisition as a cause for THIS sort of crime is absurd, when its the most frequent reason for all the other sorts!
100 years of ineptitude.
Ex- covert ops - types, fallible ? Surely, the sort of purity of soul we expect from ALL of these types rules THAT sort of thing out !
Or, thinking about it, it mightnt.
mmmm.
sometimes i wonder if that reichstag burning was a set-up
sometimes i doubt those WMD, or that niger uranium,
or that this "War of errorism" seems a bit "TAIL WAG DOG", but
then i remember, if i do, i'm supposed to blame the state, or "AmeriKa", or "TheIsraelis" BUT
. . . . SOMEHOW I KEEP COMING BACK TO . . . .
dodgy criminals do crimes too.
i keep trying to unthink it, doctor, but
oops, i thought 2+2=4,for a mo,there, too
it IS a fact that people COULD do that,
get that stupid
thinking they could get away with creating a "fashion" for terror in the age of bio/chemical/dirtynukes then sit tapping keys by the pool in hotels with hideaway bunkers in extradition-free tax havens. . . . hope it didnt disrupt the last few years of their retirement, try to spin the world back to those good-old-bad-old coldwar days, kid each other they were out of it, threaten people back home with "leading their kids astray" - but with the new tech-spin of the old techniques, a new bunch of lies for a new bunch of patsy-minions - recycled horror movies - other peoples originality but all their own blindspots.
SO. FRAMING CRITICS AS "criminals" OR "bolshies" OR "******* *******" ( insert odd accusation here) - is typical as a retort - its the old pattern, from "old jobs". Sometimes - the same jobs - insecurity industry people creating bogeypeople that actually means they get paid more to sort out?
Ouch - but it happens.
I think the reasons for people to rule it out are weak.
For all we comprehend about it, all people might suffer more "weakness" to modern, partial bits of mesmerism - if that were the case, its the sort of thing that certain old "defence of the realm" black budget types might try to keep quiet - all that interrogation/network running affecting stuff might stay hushed up WAY after it was getting as misused as "GHB" or other "daterape" drugs.
But i expect all THOSE shites thought that was always going to stay secret too. . . .
worth the thought
laters
Update of sorts
11.11.2007 01:12
It appears she has been found not guilty. So at least it is not all lost, its still bad that she should be arrested in the first place.
There is also another charge about "possessing an article "likely to be useful to a person committing or preparing an act of terrorism"
This is because she apparently owned a copy of the Al-Qaeda Handbook. I should imagine that they would find you guilty for this even if you owned something as stupid as Jolly Rogers Cookbook or printed stuff from any forum that has bomb "recipes" (even if they don't work).
JC
e-mail: wastematter@googlemail.com
Re:Update of sorts
11.11.2007 13:35
Brian B