Skip to content or view screen version

Western Charity and Zimbabwe

Rene Thomas | 17.03.2007 21:17 | Globalisation | Social Struggles

How someone being killed in Zimbabwe by Mugabe's riot police means little to us, as long as our nearest and dearest are enjoying seven years of surplus



I'm sure I'm not alone in being horrified about recent events in Zimbabwe. It seems the situation in the country has reached crisis-point in several aspects, due to the legalised dictatorship of Robert Mugabe.

Recently, I was shocked to see pictures of Morgan Tsvangirai, a leader of the opposition Movement For Democratic Change, being taken to hospital from court with a gruesome head wound, incurred at the prayer meeting held by Mugabe's opponents on Sunday 11th
March.

(Although intended as a rally and show of force by the MDC, officially demonstrations are all but banned in the clampdown climate imposed by Mugabe, so it was billed instead as a prayer meeting. Even so, the police moved in with typical brutality. Zimbabwe even has laws prohibiting criticism of the president, an obvious violation of the basic human right to freedom of expression.)

However, while Western governments have targeted Mugabe with mild criticism over the beating and arrest of Mr. Tsvangirai, his treatment is not the most glaring abomination delivered at the prayer meeting, but only that which most lends itself to media attention.

According to the Amnesty International UK website, one Zimbabwean activist, Gift Tandare, was shot dead by riot police at the same prayer meeting. Had this happened in my own country, we would be up in arms. Yet I do not even know the gender of this latest victim, sacrificed at the altar of Mugabe's power madness, although I am convinced that he or she can have been no less a thinking, feeling, breathing person than myself. Hence, if his or her life had no value, then neither does my own, and I should not hold my life dear when thinking how best I can oppose this malice.

We in the west tend to have a kind of "schizophrenic" approach to the "third world"; we care for our nearest and dearest over here with a vibrant urgency, and will fight for their happiness and safety with tooth and nail.

However, although we all claim that all human life is of equal value, and even sometimes that we love all humanity, it seems that when the geographical distance and the gap in lifestyles is imposed between ourselves and someone in Zimbabwe, say, or Sudan, Brazil, Eritrea or Burma,
often the best we can do is buy a red nose and watch celebrities congratulate us on how much we've raised, although we may have sacrificed very little in terms of energy, emotion, or economic expenditure.

The amount the British government will have to spend on ensuring that Britain remains armed with nuclear Weapons of Mass Destruction will dwarf that raised by its citizens for Comic Relief. Parliament has voted to replace Trident by a majority of over 200, although
this will cost at least £20 billion (20 grand grand grand) of "the taxpayer's" money.

For now, all I can propose is raising your concerns with any of the following, then giving yourself a slap on the back for being a caring person:

ZIMBABWE MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS,
Private Bag 7703
Causeway,
Harare

Telephone:
00 - 263 - 4 - 703641
00 - 263 - 4 - 703643

Fax:
00 - 263 - 4 - 707231

E-mail:
 moha@gvt.co.zw

Officer-in-Charge of the law and Order Section of the
Criminal Investigations Department -
CID Headquarters
Box CY34
Causeway
Harare
Zimbabwe

The Permanent Secretary,
Ministry of Justice, Legal and Parliamentary Affairs,
P. Bag 7751,
Causeway,
Harare,
New Government Complex,
Corner Samora Machel / Fourth Street

Telephone 002634 774560 or 002634 774620/7

AMBASSADOR:
His Excellency Gabriel Machinga, Zimbabwe High Commission,
Zimbabwe House, 429 Strand, London. WC2R 0QE
Email:  zimlondon@yahoo.co.uk

Rene Thomas
- e-mail: weallpoo@yahoo.co.uk
- Homepage: http://www.myspace.com-weallpoo

Comments

Hide the following 4 comments

selective compassion

17.03.2007 22:42

"However, although we all claim that all human life is of equal value, and even sometimes that we love all humanity, it seems that when the geographical distance and the gap in lifestyles is imposed between ourselves and someone in Zimbabwe, say, or Sudan, Brazil, Eritrea or Burma, often the best we can do is buy a red nose and watch celebrities congratulate us on how much we've raised, although we may have sacrificed very little in terms of energy, emotion, or economic expenditure."

What about say Iraq, Afghanistan and Iran? Hows about Palestinians being starved for voting?

Its startling that you didn't refer to the deaths Britain has direct involvement in.

Its easy to paint Mugabe as a demon.

Tsvangirai of course wouldn't dream of crushing those who oppose him when he gets into power and starts 'liberalizing' the economy.

Its because of the above that the faxes, telephone calls and letters you advocate will be dismissed with a bitter laugh.

Saddam is dead and Iraq is even more hellish.

The answer does not lie in preaching to Mugabe. You have to start by tackling Blair.

not yet uhuru


hear

18.03.2007 03:11

hear

novochadat


Rene Thomas needs to do a little more research

19.03.2007 01:15


More lies are being spread via the media about events in Zimbabwe. Rene Thomas is just one more silly person who asumes the media is telling her the truth. The following letter ive written fills in some of the missing details


To whom it may concern
You may have seen news reports lately of events in
Zimbabwe, especially regards MDC leader Morgan
Tsvangirai being beaten. But what has been missing is
the context and history.
 http://www.swans.com/library/art8/elich004.html

I hope you are aware that the MDC is funded by the
western powers, like US and UK: most people are not.
So i wish to bring the following recent article to
your attention:

 http://www.africaspeaks.com/articles/2007/1503.html

in which we learn:
'In the article 'Zimbabwe: State Warns MDC Against
Lawlessness' copied from the Zimbabwe government's
website, and another article from the BBC's website
'Eyewitness: Harare's brutal clash' that purports to
be an eyewitness account of what happened, one gets
that the opposition leader, Morgan Tsvangirai, among
others, were deliberately defying the law and
provoking a violent confrontation with the police and
the government. As the so-called eyewitness said:

"All in all there were only about 30 police and there
were more than 1,000 - we were too many for them. They
could not control what was happening."

and,

"We picked up their [police] discarded sticks and used
them to beat their left-behind colleagues"

From that BBC article 'Eyewitness: Harare's brutal
clash', there is no way we can deduce that the police
and the government were to blame for the clash between
over a thousand protesters, mostly youths, and thirty
police officers. The small number of police officers
who were eventually overpowered by the protesters
clearly showed that the police did not come out in
huge numbers prepared for a violent confrontation. '

=======

Now you may be aware of recetn protests in the US,
where non-violent protestors were arrested.
 http://www.truthout.org/docs_2006/030607P.shtml
 http://peacejournalism.com/ReadArticle.asp?ArticleID=17738

So its ok for protestors to be arrested in US, but not
in Zimbabwe, especially when in Zimbabwe, they
deliberatly resorted to violence.

These facts are being ignored by the MSM, and
democractically elected Mugabe continues to be
demonised in favour of the western pastsy Tsvangirai.

regards
Brian Souter

brian


long live mugabe

19.03.2007 11:58

MDC are just western puppets. There is killing in every country in africa, and it is because of the robber civilisation of europe. That is the truth. The only reason all this amnesty bullshit is going on is because Mugabe dares to stand up to the UK, and the British, still imperialists at heart, still racists at heart, do not like it. Get the hell off your moral high horse, you hypocrites. If you really care abour Zimbabwe, then please tell the UK to pay reparations back to zimbabwe for the harm the British have caused there, and continue to cause in africa.

idi