Skip to content or view screen version

International Human Rights Group visit Mexico-RSF

Nessuno | 07.03.2007 02:40 | Repression | Zapatista | World

Reporters Without Borders sends them chapter on media of fact-finding report by International Civilian Commission for Human Rights Observation

Ms. Rosario Ibarra de Piedra, president of the Senate Human Rights Commission
Mr. Gerardo Priego Tapia, president of the Chamber of Deputies Special Commission for Monitoring Attacks on the Press and Media
Mr. Ignacio Álvarez, special rapporteur for freedom of expression of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR)

Dear Ms. Ibarra, Mr. Priego and Mr. Álvarez,

The International Civilian Commission for Human Rights Observation (CCIODH) - consisting of 41 members of organisations from six countries (France, Spain, Italy, Denmark, United States and New Zealand) - carried out its fifth visit to Mexico from 16 December to 20 January to investigate human rights violations during the social and political crisis in the state of Oaxaca that began last May.

The chapter of the commission's fact-finding report that deals with the media is made public here by
Reporters Without Borders, which was represented on the commission. The full report was already presented to the general public in Mexico City on 3 March. The chapter that follows deals not only with attacks on the media during the conflict, but also the media's coverage of the conflict.

During its month-long visit, the CCIODH conducted more than 400 interviews with members of civil society and officials in Oaxaca and the federal capital about the uprising by the Popular Assembly of the Peoples of Oaxaca (APPO) against the Oaxaca state government led by Governor Ulíses Ruiz Ortiz and the very harsh crackdown on this movement by the state government and federal authorities.

The events in Oaxaca left a heavy toll on the press. As well as the occupations of news media by activists, around 20 local and national journalists were subjected to intimidation, physical attacks and torture. Two were killed at the height of the crisis last autumn. Freelance cameraman Bradley Will, 36, of the Indymedia agency was fatally shot on 27 October in the locality of Santa Lucia del Camino. His murder was initially attributed to five state employees, two of whom were arrested and then quickly released. The police subsequently tried to blame the APPO for Will's death.

The investigation into Will's death, which is now at a standstill, again highlights the inadequacies of the judicial system and the powerlessness of the office of the special federal prosecutor for crimes against journalists, created on 15 February 2006. Impunity also continues to prevail in the 8 December murder in Santiago Juxtlahuaca of Raúl Marcial Pérez, a columnist for the daily El Gráfico, who was also known as a community leader. It seems that all the possible leads in this case have not been explored.

The crisis in Oaxaca was the climax of an especially grim year for the Mexican press, in which a total of nine journalists were murdered and two disappeared. In the light of the report published by the CCIODH, Reporters Without Borders recommends that:

- a commission of enquiry of the federal parliament should continue the efforts begun by the CCIODH to shed full light on the human rights and press freedom violations during the events in Oaxaca,

- this commission should also shed light on the serious abuses of authority by local officials as regards the media, not only in the state of Oaxaca but also in the states of Sonora, Guanajuato and Puebla (see release of 25 January 2007),

- the commission, in order to do this, should be able to question the governors of the states concerned and the judicial and police officials under their supervision,

- the office of the special prosecutor for crimes against journalists should have the necessary resources and independence to be able to successfully carry out impartial investigations and guarantee the protection of victims,

- in the absence of significant progress in the investigations, the cases of journalists murdered in Mexico (Will being the only foreigner among the 30 killed since 2000) should be referred to the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights.

We thank you in advance for giving this matter your careful consideration.


Robert Ménard


Benoît Hervieu
Despacho Américas / Americas desk
Reporters sans frontières
5, rue Geoffroy-Marie
75009 Paris - France

tél. : +33 (0) 1 44 83 84 68
fax : +33 (0) 1 45 23 11 51
e-mail :
/ (en français)