Skip to content or view screen version

Health Promotion

the semiotics of stupidity | 14.07.2006 01:43 | Analysis | Health | World

Never let the facts get in the way of a good health promotion campaign

"social marketing"
"social marketing"

Street Police
Street Police


"Police said the Safe magazine's gossipy, tongue-in-cheek style was designed to alert young women to the dangers they could face if they get drunk during a night out."

This is a manifestation of the trend in health promotion circles for "social marketing" approaches to health and safety education.

Rather than educate "young people" about risks, it tries to modify behaviour around the risk taking behavior by manipulating social anxieties.

So, a good local example were those anti-alcohol binge drinking ads from a few years ago where a group of really hot looking "teenage" girls, including actress/model Imogen Ainsley, sat around a table "discussing' how they'd hate it if a guy got drunk and vomited on them, etc, etc.

Also, anti-smoking ads that focus on the un-sociability of smoking and how "cool" guys/girls think smoking is "un sexy".

Yeah, right. That's going to work.

Weirdly, these idiotic programmes are often designed by women, as the health promotion field is more or less gendered and heavily staffed by people with backgrounds in community nursing, youth work and the like.

My favourite was an inner city anti-violence campaign aimed at protecting gays from street violence which actually censored crime data showing that lesbians were at risk of being bashed when out at night.

This was because the ideas that lesbians were ever at more risk of violent assault than married straight women was "inconsistent with" academic feminist "understanding" of domestic violence.

Never let the facts get in the way of a good health promotion campaign.

======================================

Police urge women drinkers to 'wear nice pants'

UK: Women going on boozy nights out have been warned by police to "wear nice pants" in case they fall down drunk in the street.

A Suffolk police safety campaign magazine shows pictures of young women slumped on the ground next to messages urging them: "If you've got it, don't flaunt it".

"If you fall over or pass out, remember your skirt or dress may ride up," the magazine says.

"You could show off more than you intended - for all our sakes, please make sure you're wearing nice pants and that you've recently had a wax."

Readers are also told to stick with friends, book a taxi home and watch the amount they drink.

Police said the Safe magazine's gossipy, tongue-in-cheek style was designed to alert young women to the dangers they could face if they get drunk during a night out.

"We need to raise their awareness of potential problems," Chief Superintendent David McDonnell said.

"They become more vulnerable whilst under the influence of alcohol."

the semiotics of stupidity

Comments

Hide the following 2 comments

Shifting the blame

19.07.2006 15:26

Quite agree with your article regarding health promotion! I am very concerned about the impact of recent governmental / police health campaigns targeting the promotion of women's safety. Some recent adverts (Suffolk Police, Consent Campaign) appear to be using sexualised images and language which I feel unhelpfully lump together and promote comtinuing stereotypes about women and rape. The image used for the recent government campaign on consent (a woman's body clothed in pants with a no entry sign) was particularly inpappropriate. Safety campaigns seem to be using rape as a stick rather than providing a carrot (practical information) and in the process shifting blame to victims of crime rather than their assailants.

Coral


Useless Health Promotion

07.08.2006 15:10

I have much sympathy with your concerns regarding pointless HP posturing. However I am not sure it is a gender issue. I teach Health Promotion practice as well as being a HP Specialist. All too often people are given jobs and simply told to "get on with it". They lack structure, guidance, and method. As a result they end up doing something that looks "catchy".

HP starts with knowing what the "problem" is you are dealing with. The symptoms may or may not be obvious. The solution rarely is. Unfortunately HP looks easy when it is in fact complex and challenging. Richard Shircore

Richard Shircore
mail e-mail: richard.shircore@berkshire.nhs.uk