Skip to content or view screen version

Our Majesty

Riku | 15.06.2006 12:24 | Analysis

The Queen and Nationalism

Today, the Queen is 80, and people around the world are running to pay her respects, commonwealth leaders, monarchs, africans, asians, europeans, are all bundling forward. But what about England? In England its even more of a rush as we suddenly remember that we have a Queen, and struggle to come up with the most tear-jerking eulogy possible. Now i'm a firm anti-monarchist, but i'm always struck by the willingness of the British to take it all so naturally, here we have a firm authoritarian, hierarchical establishment right in the heart of our "democracy". But of course it can all be explained in terms of nationalism right? We equate English identity with all things tied up with tradition, tea, biscuits, firm, stout, secure, and above all royal! It is a brilliant sheme of the monarchs to equate themselves with Britishness and thus iron out all the contradictions that they pose in relation to democracy. Paul Gilroy talked about football's ability to revive British feelings of "greatness" and "imperial might" in "Their Aint no Black in the Union Jack" and i suspect he would say the same about the Monarchy. Thus seeing images of commonwealth leaders paying their respect to the Queen builds up an image of the past, of a time when England was at the centre of the Imperial World. A question that must be asked for those against the monarchy is the way in which we can seperate the Monarchy from Britishness, and indeed Britishness from its imperial past. Recent events of Nazi-helmet wearing English supporters marching through Germany are definite representations of this.

Cheers, Riku

Riku

Comments

Hide the following 3 comments

Er ur wrong

15.06.2006 14:09

here we have a firm authoritarian, hierarchical establishment right in the heart of our "democracy". Actually the UK is a parliamentary democacy, the monarch yields no power, an example of the kind of regime u refer to, Saudi Arabia.

Arthur


What about the war???

15.06.2006 19:49

Doesn't the bag lady sign the orders for the troops to follow? Isn't she supposed to be German with nothing to do with Blighty anyway - an imposter? There is only one king - for those that believe, and 'the Queen' isn't it, despite being top dog church-wise, thanks to Henry VIII (no relation). There is no blue blood with the so-called 'windsors' so I don't know what the monarchy charade is all about, and why 'constitutional whatever democracy' is okay.

idiot


fair enough

15.06.2006 20:22

fair enough, i didnt wish to suggest that the Queen has absolute power, however i do believe that the symbolism of the monarchy poses a contradiction to democracy as we proclaim it, simply because their is a hierarchical relationship in our deference to her over others, and beyond legal institutions this has a powerful effect...simply because i believe that it brings up British people with the feeling that they are subjects and not citizens who have the right to speak their mind

riku