Skip to content or view screen version

Charles Clarke loses democracy debate at University of East Anglia

UEA Debating | 21.11.2005 14:20

Clarkes Clarke debated the motion 'Democracy is on its back in the UK'.

Clarke Debating
Clarke Debating


The Home Secretary Charles Clarke took part in a guest debate at UEA on Friday 18th and after a rigorous exchange was beaten when the motion ‘Democracy is on its back in the UK’ was carried by an audience vote.

The debate, hosted by the UEA Debating Society, took place in a University common-room packed to its 100 person capacity and saw Mr Clarke argue against a panel of two students with both sides taking questions from the audience.

Jack Guest, President of UEA Debating Society and member of the Green Party opened the debate arguing that democracy was on its back in the UK because of globalisation and global economics, the role of the party whip in parliament and the media’s coverage of political news; the combined effect of which has driven ideology from politics and created voter disillusionment and apathy.

Mr Clarke responded by arguing that although democracy faces problems in the UK it is not as bad as ‘on its back’, that there are strong ideological differences between the main political parties and that the recent Government defeat in the House of Commons shows that the party whip is not all powerful.

Consensus between the panels was reached on a number of issues, including a personal preference expressed by Mr Clarke for an alternative to the ‘first past the post’ voting system and the need to get more people active and inspired in politics; but when the audience voted to decide the outcome of the debate, a previous majority of abstentions was turned into a majority agreeing with the motion.

Jess Durant, second year Culture Literature and Politics student and vice-president of UEA Debating Society joined Jack Guest to comprise the panel arguing for the motion against Charles Clarke’s who sat on a panel with Owen Bryant, a second year Philosophy, Politics and Economics student.

Jack Guest said: “The outcome of this debate demonstrates a real emerging consensus that democracy in the UK needs a lifeline. Our politicians must do more to inspire us and to get people involved in the democratic process, and as citizens we must become more idealistic and driven to tackle the local and global problems we face.”

Charles Clarke MP said: "It was a pleasure to take part in this event with
UEA Debating Society and I was thrilled to be invited. I think the passion
and quality of the discussion proved that democracy in the UK is indeed
alive and well."

UEA Debating
- Homepage: http://www.ueadebating.co.uk

Comments

Hide 1 hidden comment or hide all comments

The Greens?

21.11.2005 14:38

"Jack Guest, President of UEA Debating Society and member of the Green Party "

Why are they called The Greens when they are all whites?

Memory-Hole-Catchers-Mitt


Hidden Comment

This posting has been hidden because it breaches the Indymedia UK (IMC UK) Editorial Guidelines.

IMC UK is an interactive site offering inclusive participation. All postings to the open publishing newswire are the responsibility of the individual authors and not of IMC UK. Although IMC UK volunteers attempt to ensure accuracy of the newswire, they take no responsibility legal or otherwise for the contents of the open publishing site. Mention of external web sites or services is for information purposes only and constitutes neither an endorsement nor a recommendation.

I was there

21.11.2005 17:19

Thanks for the report but it doesn't fully reflect the reality of the event. Although he lost the vote it was by only three votes and regretfully many of those there voted on a simple "He's in the Labour party, he must be wrong" theory that had been pushed by NUS member Sean O'Reilly in the lead up to the event.

I voted against him but I nearly didn't. He argued his case with passion, conviction and had a grasp of facts sadly lacking in those who spoke against him, in fact I felt he probably gave them an easy time.

Julie Walters
mail e-mail: juliewalters-contact@hotmail.com


FORZA GREENS

21.11.2005 22:24

WE'RE ON THE MARCH

A JOURNEY OF A THOUSAND MILES BEGINS WITH A SINGLE STEP ON THE LADDER

G-force!

Green Giant


The Glass Ceiling

22.11.2005 16:02

30 years and still not a single MP in the UK?

The middle class is radical at the dinner table, not at the ballot box.

Memory-Hole-Catchers-Mitt


Hide 1 hidden comment or hide all comments