Skip to content or view screen version

Hidden Article

This posting has been hidden because it breaches the Indymedia UK (IMC UK) Editorial Guidelines.

IMC UK is an interactive site offering inclusive participation. All postings to the open publishing newswire are the responsibility of the individual authors and not of IMC UK. Although IMC UK volunteers attempt to ensure accuracy of the newswire, they take no responsibility legal or otherwise for the contents of the open publishing site. Mention of external web sites or services is for information purposes only and constitutes neither an endorsement nor a recommendation.

UK Jews charge 'bias' in BBC peace series

Jerry Lewis | 17.10.2005 01:54 | Analysis


A new BBC documentary series that began Monday night and examines recent peace negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians shows that the BBC still has some way to go to satisfy the many critics of its Middle East coverage. .



The three-part series, “Elusive Peace: Israel and the Arabs,” has already elicited a flood of protest letters, mostly e-mails, from activists in the British Jewish community against alleged anti-Israel bias.

The series is produced by Norma Percy, who won an award for her 1998 documentary “The Fifty Years War” on the same subject. It attempts to chart the negotiators' progress from former US president Bill Clinton's first efforts up to Israel's withdrawal from Gaza in August using interviews with several of the key players.

The first episode opens with then-premier Ehud Barak's attempts to negotiate peace with Syria during a visit to Washington and Clinton's subsequent trip to Geneva for abortive talks with the late Syrian president Hafez Assad.

The scene then switches to Camp David where Barak and the late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat lock horns and fail to agree on the next stages of peace negotiations, before examining Clinton's last-ditch efforts to seal a deal on his visit to Jerusalem prior to giving up his presidency.

One viewer, activist Joy Wolfe, lodged a formal complaint to the BBC over pro-Palestinian bias even before the program was broadcast.

“How are we supposed to give any credence to the BBC's constant claim it is not biased when even in a trailer for an important series on the Israel-Palestinian conflict that bias and injection of opinion is there for all to see?” she wrote in an e-mail to senior BBC executives including Malcolm Balen, the BBC executive who serves as a kind of ombudsman for coverage of this region.

The trailer in question heralded, “The story of how Israel's Prime Minister Ehud Barak persuaded President Clinton to devote his last 18 months in office to helping make peace with Yasser Arafat. But Barak got cold feet twice. Then Ariel Sharon took a walk around Jerusalem's holiest mosques, and peacemaking was over.”

“Firstly, there is absolutely no evidence to back the view that 'Barak got cold feet twice,'” wrote Wolfe. “He and Arafat shook hands on the most generous peace settlement terms the Palestinians could have ever hoped for.

“It was not Barak who got cold feet, but Arafat, who walked away to unleash more violence as his answer.”

A senior BBC source derided the complaint, telling The Jerusalem Post that such is the situation with constant and often inaccurate complaints that many inevitably are given perfunctory replies and little or no notice is taken of them. The Jewish community does itself no favours with these interventions, the source added, and as for writing in before a program has even been shown, that takes quite some hutzpa.

Balen plainly took a different view, however, writing back to Wolfe to say that the trailer “was not written by a journalist and does not reflect the programme... It will be changed.”

And, indeed, it was, to state: “The story of how Israel's Prime Minister Ehud Barak persuaded President Clinton to devote his last 18 months in office to helping make peace with Yasser Arafat. But after tense negotiations the deal was never made.”

Jerry Lewis
- Homepage: http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?apage=2&cid=1128955350266&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull

Comments

Hide the following 5 comments

Jews, or Zionists?

17.10.2005 06:05

Let us not forget that when the UN created Israel, it also created a Palestinian State.

The Zionists make such a big deal about their State's right to exist (and what did they do to deserve such a thing?), but people forget that this entire conflict started (after the State was created, following the initial Ethnic Cleansing, etc.) when Israel refused to recognize the existence of a Palestinian State.

Huuuge Difference


At least the BBC are not as biased as Indymedia

17.10.2005 08:53

The BBC maybe biased against Israel but they are no where near as biased as Indymedia. It is also strange how Indymedia always side with Palestinians given the Palestinians fundamentalist Islamic views and connections with Al Qaeda. How can liberatarians, anarchists and humanists who make up the Indymedia collective throw in their lot with a bunch Islamic extremists?

Observer


Amazing

17.10.2005 09:18

..and there was I, also before seeing the programme, making the opposite assumption, that something called 'Israel and the Arabs', was by definition recognising Israel and excluding the notiion of a legitimate state of Palestine in favour of the concept of a miscellaneous rabble of Arabs...

rk


Why WHY WHYYYYY

17.10.2005 12:13

What is the point of blocking out an article when it is still clearly visible and possible to read in full like this one is?

What is the point? Why not just either leave it up or delete it completely?

Why block it out but in a way that still allows people to read it?

Is this some sort of Anarchist inability to make a decision so both options are tried at once?

Memory-Hole-Catchers-Mitt


re

17.10.2005 22:53

"The Zionists make such a big deal about their State's right to exist (and what did they do to deserve such a thing?)"

Well, there was a little thing called '6 million european jews in gas chambers,' and an expulsion of 1 million sephardy jews (who outnumbered original palestinian refugees 2-1) from the arab world.
But, yeah, i suppose us jews have no right to even THINK about having a homeland.But everybody else can.

lebanese jewish girl