Sell out of dissidents
David Rennie | 27.07.2005 08:12
A leading Cuban dissident yesterday accused a "two-faced" French government of putting trade ahead of the suffering of the Cuban people.
The comments by Marta Beatriz Roque, a 60-year-old economist who was arrested during a protest outside the French embassy in Havana on Bastille Day, came after Paris unilaterally ended a European Union diplomatic embargo against the regime of President Fidel Castro, and normalised relations with his government.
Apparently emboldened by the French overture, Cuban authorities responded by launching the largest wave of dissident arrests since 2003, when almost the entire dissident leadership of the Communist-ruled island was rounded up.
In the latest wave of arrests, about 30 democracy activists, including Mrs Roque, were taken into custody after they attempted to protest outside the French embassy on July 14 to denounce the new policy towards Cuba. As many as 19 were still believed to be in custody last night.
Fourteen dissidents were released after a day or two in detention, including Mrs Roque, who is in fragile health after two periods of imprisonment.
Speaking from her Havana home, Mrs Roque said the aborted protest was organised after France broke the EU embargo and invited the Cuban foreign minister, Felipe Perez Roque to a Bastille Day celebration at the French embassy, from which dissidents and democracy activists were excluded. The French invitation was intended to signal the normalisation of relations between Paris and Havana. Mrs Roque alleged that France had sold out its principles for the sake of business deals with Cuba.
"For a little money, they have made the Cuban people suffer," she said.
Mrs Roque, the president of the outlawed Assembly for the Promotion of Civil Society, was among a group of dissident leaders invited to the residence of Marie-France Pagnier, the French ambassador to Havana on July 13, a day ahead of the Bastille Day celebrations.
"The French are two-faced," she said. "The day before, their ambassador invited a group of us to her house through the back door, the next day they are welcoming the minister and applauding a speech in which he promised to carry on with repression."
The Bastille Day invitation went against an agreement by 24 of the 25 EU governments, who decided in February that neither dissidents nor Cuban government leaders should be invited to national day celebrations at European embassies. Spain, a vocal supporter of trade and political ties with Havana, abstained.
"France has shattered European Union unity, and wrecked the balance between the opposition and the government. France has strengthened the government," Mrs Roque said.
Embarrassed French officials have called for the release of those arrested outside their embassy. The foreign ministry said it was following the situation with ''the greatest attention''.
David Rennie
Comments
Hide the following 12 comments
Info from PEN
27.07.2005 09:11
Home
About English PEN
Membership
Events
News
Writers in Prison
Rapid Action Network
WiPC Bulletin
Campaigns
Honorary Members
Algeria
Belarus
Cameroon
China
Colombia
Cuba
Marta Beatriz Roque
Raúl Rivero Castañeda
Adolfo Fernández Saínz
Julio César Gálvez Rodríguez
Fabio Prieto Llorente
Pedro Argüelles Morán
José Luis García Paneque
Normando Hernández González
Jorge Olivera Castillo
Oscar Espinosa Chepe
Egypt
Iran
Maldives
Morocco
Myanmar (Burma)
Saudi Arabia
Sierra Leone
Syria
Tibet
Tunisia
Turkey
Uzbekistan
Vietnam
Writers Under Threat
Released Writers / Writers in Exile
About the WiPC
Contact us
Books to Prisoners
Freedom of Expression links
Readers and Writers
Writers in Translation
Prizes
International
Membership
See how you could benefit from being a member of PEN. more...
Support PEN
We rely on your support. Click here to make a donation.
Profession: author and economist
Details of arrest: Marta Beatriz Roque Cabello was arrested as part of a crackdown on alleged dissidents that began on 18 March 2003 and in which around 80 people were detained.
Details of trial: She was one of 34 journalists, writers and librarians sentenced during the one-day trials held on 3/4 April 2003 under laws governing the protection of the Cuban state. The one-day court hearings were held behind closed doors and it is reported that there was insufficient time for the accused to put together a cogent defence.
Sentence: 20 years
Health concerns: Arrested whilst on hunger strike in support of people she considered political prisoners. Suffers from rheumatism and diabetes. It was reported on 9 June 2003 that shed had lost 30 lbs (13 kilos) in weight due to health problems including vomiting and diarrhoea. Roque was transferred to a hospital on 23 July 2003 suffering from chest pains and nose bleeds brought on by high blood pressure. Reported still to be in hospital in November 2003 suffering from a variety of ailments. In February 2004 Roque wrote a letter complaining that she was not receiving adequate medical attention at the Carlos J. Finlay military hospital and that she was in pain due to an untreated bacteria.
Previous imprisonment: has previously served time for her writing. She was released in May 2000 after serving three years of a four-year sentence for her co-authorship of a document which urged the Cuban government to hold democratic elections, liberalise the economy and improve human rights.
Honorary member: Finnish, Canadian and English PEN
John
Protest
27.07.2005 09:23
Sr. Carlos Dotres Martinez
Ministro de la Salud Publica
Ministerio de la Salud Publica
Calle 23, No. 301
Vedado, La Habana, Cuba
Dr. Juan Escalona Reguera
Fiscal General de la Republica
San Rafael 3
La Habana, Cuba
Fax: 011 53 7 669 485
Sr. Jefe del Centro de Investigaciones del Departamento de
Seguridad del Estado (DSE)
Versalles
Santiago de Cuba
Prov. Oriente, Cuba
Sr. Felipe Pérez Roque
Ministro de Relaciones Exteriores
Ministerio de Relaciones Exteriores
Calzada No. 360
Vedado
La Habana, Cuba
Fax: 011 53 7 333 085 or 335 261
Monique Antione
some more background information
27.07.2005 09:39
Following a mistake by a Cuban radio technician Casto was recently overheard saying,
'I've not seen such widespread discontent in four decades'
Ruling Communist Party and armed forces officials chanted "Fidel, Fidel" throughout the speech commemorating an assault Castro led on the Moncada military barracks in 1953 to launch a revolutionary movement that ousted U.S.-backed dictator Fulgencio Batista and brought Castro to power in 1959.
But power cuts of 12 hours or more a day, coupled with record heat, led to protests, vandalism and anti-Castro graffiti this summer reported veteran human rights activist Elizardo Sanchez .
A leaked official report says 43 percent of Cuban homes need repair
Authorities have responded by mobilizing rapid deployment brigades of militant supporters to disperse pockets of protest with batons, On Friday, hostile crowds demonstrated outside government opponents' homes and police detained 33 dissidents who had planned a protest to demand the release of political prisoners. Nine of the 33 are still being held, Sanchez said.
Castro, who turns 79 next month, spoke for more than three hours, wearing his trademark olive-green uniform. He declared earlier this year that Cuba had overcome the deep crisis it was plunged into by the demise of the Soviet Union, with the loss of billions of dollars in subsidies.
Shipments of subsidised oil from Venezuela and new credits from China have helped Havana weather a cash crunch but economic commentators point out this is only a short term cure
"This nation that undoubtedly has backed the government for many years is disillusioned and frustrated now, seeing a return to the past," dissident economist Oscar Espinosa Chepe said.
He said Cuba should not have closed small private businesses it allowed a decade ago, instead of following other communist states that opened to capitalist markets.
"If the Cuban government opened up areas of the economy, like China and Vietnam, it may be able to avoid a social explosion," he said.
David Rennie
Please hide
27.07.2005 10:01
In fact to help things along why doesn't somebody post the usual crap about how all Cuba's problems are the fault of the US (without of course specifying why) followed by a lot of fabricated figures from the Cuban Information Ministry concerning literacy and healthcare figures.
Let's all remember to stick to the rule about supporting political dissidents and those seeking social justice......."Only when they are living in a Western Democracy"
IMC'er
Can you believe it.
27.07.2005 10:30
It is not surprising that when Cuba is defending itself legitimately against the degenerate terrorist new-liberal imperialist US and its pathetic toadying allies, that liberals inside Cuba, supported by the sham democratic degenerate liberals from outside Cuba, are trying to overthrow Castro’s much more equitable and fair state because its government helps its own people and opposes new liberal capitalism in a very dignified way considering the pressure and oppression applied by its US neighbour.
They are lucky only just be locked up. Castro shows dignified restraint in not executing them immediately. Why don't these degenerate liberal "democrats" just fuck off to the US or France, and support international terrorism from there.
Cant this putrid new liberal propaganda be removed from this site. These democracy advocates want authoritarian states like the US and UK. Why is their propaganda given voice on this site that is opposed to hierarchy, new liberalism and imperialist terrorism.
Please read your own editorial guidelines, and please remove this shit from this site.
Ed Campbell
mercaneries for uncle sam
27.07.2005 10:56
Al lockbeem
Cuba is not so evil...
27.07.2005 11:18
The trouble with these fluffy Liberal types is they get endlessly hung-up over Cuba's lack of 'democracy', without understanding that the 'right' to place a cross next to a box every five years in some Tweedledum vs Tweedledee election is not democracy anyway.
When's the last time the British government affected any sort of change that you actually wanted, rather than endless new laws imposed by people who "know what is good for you"? I'd say the minimum wage, and even that was too little, too late.
And to those who cannot understand how an illegal 40-year economic blockade led by the US might perhaps damage the Cuban economy and breed poverty - try gaining a basic understanding of economics, bozos!
What is amazing is that Cuba has managed to maintain its (highly imperfect) version of socialism for as long as it has. Child mortality rates are still lower than the poorest districts of Washington DC! Imagine what would be possible if Cuba was allowed to trade fairly and freely with the rest of the world...
Yes we all want democracy in Cuba. But with things the way they are at the moment, if Castro's regime is overthrown, the CIA will be in there like shit down a trouser leg and some pliant, repressive puppet regime will swiftly follow, handing everything back to the Mafia corporations that the Revolution originally booted out.
Get real !!!
Liberals are no use in a crisis because they don't UNDERSTAND
Well done Ed Campbell
27.07.2005 11:21
If we can continue to divert attention away from the reality of life for the average Cuban and instead make a number of wild allegations about how its all the fault of, The USA, Neo-Cons or indeed Israel if we think we can get away with it, so much the better.
Has anybody thought about trying to fabricate some sort of link between Cuban exiles in Miami and the large Jewish population in the rest of Florida ? Same US State, lots of Jews in the same place, is the CIA / Mossad involved etc etc. You know the sort of thing.
IMC'er
You don't understand
27.07.2005 11:29
Other countries could do well to learn from the Cuban model and adopt a process where only those who have shown the political or intellectual ability to understand the need for Socialism should be allowed to participate in elections.
Terry
or
27.07.2005 11:46
Have you consided that the failure of the Cuban economy was not a US embargo on its goods, (Cuba sold all it could produce to other countries without needing the US) but the failure of socialism to feed a people. Cuba has only survived because it the past it received billions of Dollars in Soviet Union funding and of late Chinese money.
The Cuban economy failed because the people lacked any motivation to work because they received the same pay and benefits regardless of what they did. This combined with an unrealistic percentage of the population being paid by the State without producing anything led to the current failure.
Like all those others who have gone before Socialsim in Cuba will ultimatly fail because the people don't want tit even if the rulling elite do.
RG
...
27.07.2005 18:04
I notice the US recently liberated Haiti from the clutches of a tyrannical left-wing president, and now, thanks to the CIA, the country is enjoying an unprecedented period of stability and wealth.
Wouldn't it be great if Cuba went down the same road as Haiti? Long live the march of progress. Guantanamo Bay is a shining example, inside of Cuba, of US democracy and freedom. If we all work really hard together, we can bring all the joys and creature comforts of Guantanamo Bay to the whole of the island.
Hermes
Sorry, but the criticsm is simplistic generalised nonesense.
27.07.2005 18:34
I just cant get my brain down to the level of the criticism against Cuba: that's supporting a US style democracy in Cuba, as opposed to government by the Cuban Communist Party.
Of course Cuba should be given qualified support but the conditions under which it try’s to survive severely limit the possibilities of further liberation in Cuba, towards socialism, communism or libertarian socialism or anarchism, whatever words you want to put on a freedom. The liberals do not know how to compare like with like they are too ignorant, broadminded and biased to have any opinion that is worth regarding.
The economic arguments given are simplistic generalisations and are wrong.
Any country that does trade with Cuba was threatened with economic sanctions by the US for decades. Good for France for telling the US to go fuck yourself.
Anyone who knows anything about the Cuban popular revolution knows the US drove Cuba to seek help from the USSR. They did it to many other South American States too, and Vietnam.
For fuck sakes the US has shat on Cuba since its revolution, because it has sought, as best it could, to reject capitalism imperialism, and now is helping to organise and support the battle to rid the world of new liberalism which is destroying the planet, murdering peoples, causing wars, and the destroying further the quality of peoples lives. It benefits only a small number of rich and powerful. Even the middle classes are having their pensions fucked up by new liberalism. It will bankrupt the US and Uk eventually, unless the US can politically and militarily repress and rob most of the rest of the world.
The stakes are high the choice is between barbarism and a desecrated planet on the one hand or freedom, justice and equality and a good quality and meaning of life for all on the other. Make a choice what you want, then decide who deserves qualified support.
And the bollocks from the Jewish conspiracy theorists is just complete mentalism.
Ed