Skip to content or view screen version

MCLIBEL DUO WIN CASE

Congrats | 15.02.2005 14:15 | Repression | London | Sheffield

Two campaigners found guilty of libelling McDonald's have won a ruling that they should have been given legal aid by the British Government.

Helen Steel and David Morris were dubbed the McLibel Two during a landmark 314-day trial - the longest civil or criminal action in English legal history.



McLibel Two have had long battle with McDonald's


MCLIBEL DUO WIN CASE

Two campaigners found guilty of libelling McDonald's have won a ruling that they should have been given legal aid by the British Government.

Helen Steel and David Morris were dubbed the McLibel Two during a landmark 314-day trial - the longest civil or criminal action in English legal history.


The pair were ordered to pay £40,000 in libel damages.

But instead of paying, they went to the Strasbourg Human Rights Court, claiming the UK libel laws operated heavily in favour of companies like McDonald's.

They said the system breached their human rights because they were denied legal aid and because they were obliged to justify every word of the allegations against McDonald's.

The Human Rights judges found in their favour, saying the lack of legal aid effectively denied the pair the right to a fair trial as guaranteed by the Human Rights Convention, to which the UK is a signatory.

They said it also breached their right to freedom of expression.

The duo's lawyer Mark Stephens said: "The European Court of Human Rights found there were violations of their human rights perpetrated on them - that there was procedural unfairness in the case and that the procedures adopted were not fair."

The saga began when the US firm decided to act after the pair handed out leaflets entitled What's Wrong With McDonald's.

Neither of the defendants wrote the six-page pamphlet, which contained damaging allegations against the company, but found themselves in court.

The case began in 1990 and in 1997, after a total of 314 days of hearing, High Court judge Mr Justice Bell ruled McDonald's had been libelled and awarded the company £60,000 in damages, reduced to £40,000 on appeal.

The case is thought to have cost the fast food giant £10m and was described as "the biggest corporate PR disaster in history".

Well Bloody Done and about time!

Congrats

Comments

Hide the following 5 comments

Congrats!

15.02.2005 19:12

Congratulations, Long overdue result - When is the party???

Andy March


Well done guys

15.02.2005 20:29

I think it would be apposite to remind ourselves of the words of Bette Midler, when she sang:

"Did you ever know that you're my hero,
and ev'rything I would like to be?
I can fly higher than an eagle,
'cause you are the wind beneath my wings"

Nice one Helen and Dave. You are the wind beneath our wings.

Joeboy


Congrats

15.02.2005 21:34

Nice one Helen & Dave. i remember the leaflet. Funny, I still looks like the truth to me. ( & Ronald McDonald still looks like a se4rial killer ( in my opinion ... )).

Archway 05

Cash Crop


Justice at last for Ronald

15.02.2005 22:25

McBusted
McBusted

Heavily armed officers finally closed in on Ronald McDonald at his Nevada bunker this morning.

Mmmm. Fried salt.


McDonalds - shit and they know they are

19.02.2005 10:58

Great stuff Helen and David - freedom of expression is just a tad more free in Britain after all your efforts.

You never gave up and it has paid off.

I'm lovin' it.

Alex Higgins
mail e-mail: respond_alexblog@yahoo.co.uk
- Homepage: http://bringontherevolution.blogspot.com