Skip to content or view screen version

Amy Goodman in London

mini mouse | 30.01.2005 18:31 | London

Amy Goodman talks at LSE about US media ownership, bias and censorship.

But has she seen what we have to put up with?

Amy Goodman leaving the stage
Amy Goodman leaving the stage


We all know the military industrial complex thrives in America. Not only do the major weapons makers own the major media, that same media hires the retired military as pundits to comment and explain the war to the people.And just in case they were to get out of line, the FCC - the media regulator - hires Michael Powell, son of Secretary of State Colin Powell as its chairman (1).

The all leaves the American public, according to Amy Goodman, “not a silent majority, but a silenced majority”.

Speaking at the LSE Goodman said there was never a time when it was more important to stick together. As thousands “disappear” in the US under the provisions of the Patriot Act, and “rendition” enables the State’s detractors to be flown to countries such as Syria and Egypt for third party torture, it’s essential that we fight back and learn to manage the media.

All very true, and it’s probable that on balance, the Patriot Act is more far reaching (certainly more frequently invoked) than our equivalent legislations, brought in around the same time (and currently under attach by the Law Lords).

But I’m not so sure about her perception - common amongst the thinking US public - that their news is more censored than the rest of the world.

For example, according to Goodman the Democracy Now programme is carried by some 300 radio and TV station across the US. Here we have no equivalent. For news we have principally the "impartial" BBC, where one early morning broadcast by Andrew Gilligan results in a hissy fit by Number Ten, the Hutton enquiry and resignation of the Director General.

And the US, recognising that cable stations enjoy monopolies as a result of their infrastructure, force them to throw open channels for community access. Anyone trying to get a radio license to broadcast anything other than 80s crap music in the UK would find that unbelieveable.

Finally, with honourable (if inconsistent) exceptions including the Guardian, Independent and New Statesmen, we have a press devoted to the inanities of celebrity gossip, racism and bigotry. But read the California based Information Clearing House (2) and you’ll find links to the most unlikely sources of criticism - The Kansas Bugle, The Lincoln County News and The Oregonian to name but three.

Goodman’s talk was entertaining and uplifting, and it’s clear from her terrifying experiences in Indonesia she’s a brave and determined journalist.

Her message holds good over here. I just wonder if she realises how much.



1.  http://www.fcc.gov/commissioners/powell/mkp_biography.html

2  http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/

mini mouse
- e-mail: mini_mouse@riseup.net

Comments

Hide the following 7 comments

Re Amy Goodman talk at LSE

30.01.2005 20:13

I appreciate the report on Amy Goodman's talk as I had wanted to go myself but as I live in Edinburgh it was a litle too far, (800 mile roundtrip). The US media is largely muzzled due to its ownership by the arms manafacturers but there are honourable exceptions like Amy and `Democracy Now!` Another good dissident journalist is Danny Schechter who has a new film out called `WMD weapons of mass deception` and the website for the film is: www.wmdthefilm.com
Thanks a lot mini-mouse!

Paul O'Hanlon
mail e-mail: o_hanlon@hotmail.com


Review of The Exception to the Rulers

30.01.2005 21:43

I was impressed with Amy Goodman. She caught the interest of her audience and held it for the best part of an hour.
There is nothing as good as Democracy Now in the UK. We can get  http://democracynow.org and see the show on the internet if we have broadband. I find myself agreeing with Tariq Ali (and that is not commonplace!) when he says that we need something like Democracy Now! in the UK. We have newspapers (try The Socialist!) and we have indymedia but obviously the more the merrier.
She also made the most basic point - we don't all agree with each other (it wouldn't be exactly democratic if we did!) but we do have to stick together; when human beings are suffering it is our instinct to help.
We have all seen how the basic human solidarity of people in the face of the tsunami disaster has shamed the world governments into making "pledges" of aid. Bush and Blair may well rat on those pledges as they have in the past and only independent media will hold them to account.

Derek McMillan
mail e-mail: derekmcmillan1951@yahoo.co.uk
- Homepage: http://derekmcmillan.tripod.com


Review of The Exception to the Rulers

30.01.2005 21:44

I was impressed with Amy Goodman. She caught the interest of her audience and held it for the best part of an hour.
There is nothing as good as Democracy Now in the UK. We can get  http://democracynow.org and see the show on the internet if we have broadband. I find myself agreeing with Tariq Ali (and that is not commonplace!) when he says that we need something like Democracy Now! in the UK. We have newspapers (try The Socialist!) and we have indymedia but obviously the more the merrier.
She also made the most basic point - we don't all agree with each other (it wouldn't be exactly democratic if we did!) but we do have to stick together; when human beings are suffering it is our instinct to help.
We have all seen how the basic human solidarity of people in the face of the tsunami disaster has shamed the world governments into making "pledges" of aid. Bush and Blair may well rat on those pledges as they have in the past and only independent media will hold them to account.

Derek McMillan
mail e-mail: derekmcmillan1951@yahoo.co.uk
- Homepage: http://derekmcmillan.tripod.com


Apologies and book review

30.01.2005 21:51

Apologies
The book review in question is at  http://user1951.tripod.com/exception.htm

Derek McMillan
mail e-mail: derekmcmillan1951@yahoo.co.uk
- Homepage: http://derekmcmillan.tripod.comhttp:


dont be fooled by her

30.01.2005 22:20

ALTERNATIVE MEDIA CENSORSHIP:
SPONSORED BY CIA's FORD FOUNDATION?

by bob feldman

The multi-billion dollar Ford Foundation's historic relationship to the Central Intelligence Agency [CIA] is rarely mentioned on Pacifica's DEMOCRACY NOW / Deep Dish TV show, on FAIR's COUNTERSPIN show, on the WORKING ASSETS RADIO show, on The Nation Institute's RADIO NATION show, on David Barsamian's ALTERNATIVE RADIO show or in the pages of PROGRESSIVE, MOTHER JONES and Z magazine. One reason may be because the Ford Foundation and other Establishment foundations subsidize the Establishment Left's alternative media gatekeepers / censors.

PACIFICA / DEMOCRACY NOW / DEEP DISH TV

Take Pacifica / DEMOCRACY NOW, an alternative radio network with annual revenues of $10 million in 2000, whose National Program Director was paid $63,000 in that year. In the early 1950s--when the CIA was using the Ford Foundation to help fund a non-communist "parallel left" as a liberal Establishment alternative to an independent, anti-Establishment revolutionary left--the Pacifica Foundation was given a $150,000 grant in 1951 by the Ford Foundation's Fund for Education. According to James Ledbetter's book Made Possible By..., "the Fund's first chief was Alexander Fraser, the president of the Shell Oil Company."
Besides subsidizing the Pacifica Foundation in the early 1950s, the Ford Foundation also spent a lot of money subsidizing many other noncommercial radio or television stations in the United States. According to Ledbetter's Made Possible By..., between 1951 and 1976, the Ford Foundation "spent nearly $300 million on noncommercial radio and television."

In the late 1950s and early 1960s, Pacifica relied primarily on listener-sponsor contributions to fund the operations of its radio stations. And in the early 1970s, Pacifica also began to accept funds from the U.S. Establishment's Corporation for Public Broadcasting [CPB], according to Rogue State author William Blum--who worked as a KPFA staffperson in the early 1970s. But in the early 1990s, some Pacifica administrators decided to again seek grants from the Ford Foundation and other Establishment foundations. As former Pacifica Development Director Dick Bunce wrote in the appendix to the "A Strategy for National Programming" document which was prepared for the Pacifica National Board in September 1992, entitled "Appendix Foundation Grantseeking National Programming Assumptions for Foundation Fundraising":

The national foundation grantseeking arena has changed enough in recent years to make activity in this arena potentially worthwhile--for organizations prepared to be players and partners in the same field as NPR, APR, maybe some others...The foundation funding of interest is in gifts of $100,000 or more a year, for several years...Three of America's six largest foundations (Ford, MacArthur, Pew) have begun to fund public broadcasting, public radio in particular, and evidently intend to continue doing so. Pacifica requested meetings with each of these foundations earlier this year and was treated seriously enough in subsequent meetings to give us some hope of securing funding possibly from all three. A `Report Sheet' on this work is included in Appendix 3.

Beyond these three foundations there are no others among the country's 100 largest which have made substantial grants to public broadcasting. So the second tier of foundation prospects look substantially different from the first tier requiring more work on our part to open doors, establish `standing' and find a workable `fit.'

There are nonetheless a number of interesting prospects--in some cases only because of particular people who are currently involved, or because of formal criteria which we could try to fit. The second tier list includes several from the top 100--Rockefeller, Irvine, Surdna, George Gund--Nathan Cummings--and a number of smaller foundations, but still capable of 6 figure grants: Aaron Diamond, Revson, Rockefeller Family & Associates, New World, Winston Foundation for World Peace.

Once we drop to the $35,000 to $75,000 grant range, the list enlarges, but these take as long to cultivate as the bigger ones, so it makes sense to start from the top.

Foundation fundraising at this level has extraordinary payoffs--but it takes senior staff time, not `grantwriting' but in communicating. It is therefore expensive, and not successfully done as an afterthought to everything else in the day. It also requires `venture capital visits' to the foundations to open doors and conversations that lead to partnerships.

In initiating three top level contacts in April, May and June, and attempting to capitalize on the opportunities apparent to us, we have already been stretched beyond our capacity to really interface effectively with these funders--although admittedly much of the problem to date has been due to the fact that we don't yet have a clear business plan for national programming.

Foundation grantmaking will most likely proceed as short-term funding. Funders will want to `fund projects, not operations.' We should presume that we can succeed in raising serious money to launch or establish new programs, etc. but not to sustain them beyond start-up. The standard of self-sufficiency will be required for many proposals we submit, and our own planning will be most successful if we relate to this funding source accordingly.

Short-Run Strategies for Developing a Foundation Grantseeking Program

Seek Development Committee leadership in planning for Foundation grantseeking.

Pursue 3 `anchor' grants to acquire funding beginning in FY'93 from the Big 3 foundations we've already begun to work with.

Long-Range Strategies for Developing a Foundation Grantseeking Program

Initiate an informal `feasibility inquiry' of foundation support for Pacifica's objectives by requesting visits with the dozen top prospects to shape proposals and establish relationships...

Foundation Grants Summary: Late this spring we began our first efforts in national foundation grantseeking on behalf of national programming. We have a good chance of securing six figure grants in the coming fiscal year from any or all of the 3 foundations we're working with, but our approach is still dependent upon our own organizational progress toward a business plan that we are committed to following through on.


The second tier of foundation prospects is more challenging, and will require increased staff resoucres, a modest feasability inquiry and active planning with the Board Development Committee.

By 1995, billionaire speculator George Soros' Open Society Institute had given the Pacifica Foundation a $40,000 grant. And in 1996, the Carnegie Corporation of New York gave Pacifica a $25,000 grant to launch its DEMOCRACY NOW show. In 1997 came a $13,000 grant from the J.M. Kaplan Fund to Pacifica to provide support for DEMOCRACY NOW. And in 1998 came a $25,000 grant to Pacifica from the Public Welfare Foundation "to report on hate crimes and related issues as part of its `DEMOCRACY NOW!" public-affairs radio program and an additional $10,000 grant to support DEMOCRACY NOW from the J.M. Kaplan Fund. That same year the Ford Foundation gave a $75,000 grant to Pacifica "toward marketing consultancy, promotional campaign and program development activities for radio program, DEMOCRACY NOW." In 1998 and 1999, two grants, totalling $22,500, were also given to Pacifica by the Boehm Foundation, to support its DEMOCRACY NOW show.

In early 2002, an additional Ford Foundation grant of $75,000 was given to Deep Dish TV "for the television news series, DEMOCRACY NOW, to continue incorporating the aftermath of the September 11th attack into future broadcasts." Besides being presently subsidized by the Ford Foundation to air Pacifica's DEMOCRACY NOW show, Deep Dish TV, with an annual income of $158,000 in 2000, was also subsidized by the MacArthur Foundation in the 1990s. Between 1993 and 1998, $190,000 in grants were given to Deep Dish TV by the MacArthur Foundation. And one of the members of Deep Dish TV's board of directors in recent years has apparently been a WBAI staffperson named Mario Murillo.

Another Ford Foundation grant of $200,000 was given in April 2002 to the Astraea Foundation, whose former board finance committee chairperson, Leslie Cagan, is presently the chairperson of Pacifica's national board. Three other grants have been given to the Astraea Foundation by the Ford Foundation since 2000: two grants, totalling $75,000, in 2000; and a $200,000 grant in 2001 "for general support and subgrants to community-based organizations addressing social, political and economic justice, especially those focused on lesbians and other sexual minorities." The former finance committee chairperson of the Ford Foundation-sponsored Astraea Foundation recently signed a $2 million "golden handshake / sweetheart contract" with the Ford Foundation-sponsored, soon-to-be-privatized DEMOCRACY NOW producer (who has apparently been receiving a $90,000/year salary from Pacifica in recent years for her alternative journalism work).

truth out


Amy Goodman Speaks in Dublin Jan 29th

31.01.2005 03:19

We had her just before you all did :-)

Check out the Indymedia Ireland Feature:

Amy Goodman Speaks in Dublin Jan 29th
&
Question: How Do You Make 'Independent Media' Sustainable?

MP3s available at
 http://www.indymedia.ie/newswire.php?story_id=68425

redjade


Truth Out - Don't Be Silly

31.01.2005 16:54

Is anyone seriously suggesting that Amy Goodman receives handouts from the CIA?

This is a woman who went to East Timor in 1991 to highlight the country's suffering under the Western-backed Indonesian occupation, where she was an accidental witness to the Santa Cruz massacre of Timorese mourners at a funeral in Dili. She and cameraman Alan Nairn were extremely lucky not to be murdered by the Indonesian Army themselves and had to beg for their lives, while others were killed all around them.

Amy Goodman is an inspirational activist on a whole range of issues. People like her represent what is good is about the left and deserve our support.

Alex Higgins
mail e-mail: bring_on_the_revolution@yahoo.co.uk
- Homepage: http://bringontherevolution.blogspot.com