Skip to content or view screen version

Protests at Band Aid Whitewashing Poverty Issues

features | 19.11.2004 10:12

On the 14th November outside the recording studios in Hampstead where "Do They Know It's Christmas" - Band AID, was being re-recorded, demonstrations took place by protesters arguing that Band Aid is a screen "whitewashing the real issues behind world poverty". Shouts of 'real aid, not band aid', 'don't whitewash Africa' and boo's were audiable over the screams of fans and onlookers. One protester was arrested while handing out leaflets explaining the reasons for the protest - [read full report].

Protesters from the Dissent! Network, organising against the G8 summit next July, argue that the song is obnoxious, patronising and out of date with the real situation in Africa.

Several initiatives are now underway to re-write the lyrics - upload your own, or send lyrics or recorded mp3s to doyouknowitscapitalism@yahoo.co.uk

International development campaigners, World Development Movement (WDM) - which was one of the founders of both the fair trade movement and Jubilee 2000, also condemned the lyrics as promoting a "negative and inaccurate picture of Africa and its problems." The organisation, drew attention to several lines in the song which it described as "patronising, false and out of date". Director of WDM, Mark Curtis said on Tuesday 14th: "African poverty is not an unfortunate accident of geography and climate. It is largely the result of damaging policies such as free trade forced on Africa by rich countries."

For more see Indymedia London Feature | Bad Reviews, Ethical Criticism | Band Aid Banned

features

Comments

Hide the following 3 comments

Memories

23.11.2004 13:46

Bob Geldof wanted to attend the Genoa demonstration. So he flew there on Tony Blairs jet. With Bono. Could there BE anything less cool than this ?

Me Myself and I


Bono runs international finance company

02.12.2004 17:10

'Bono's'company is now a major player in the media/leisure international finance markets. He's a billionaire fantasist who's been living in an adolescent dream world for most of his allegedly adult life. What more does anyone expect? What's more fun, and more bankable, than playing the rebel within the boundaries of the system, while being careful to never challenge the capitalist property relations that you benefit so abundantly from? Bob Geldof's been playing the same repulsive game for years, and it's worked wonders. For those who confuse social protest with fashion statements it's an illusion that never ceases to work. Lets all just say a big fuck off to corporate music and the even more fucked fashion industry that's it's twin sister. Burn your CD's!

Austin Fletcher
mail e-mail: Fletcherau@hotmail.com


Well little acorns....

19.12.2004 14:45

Well what to say... I remember Band Aid twenty years ago, and remember being touched by it. I remember being at a School Xmas party at someone's house, and all of us sat around an upright piano singing the song as one of us plugged away at the chords. Did we really learn anything by this, did we effect change. Well in my case it played a part in a number of ways, some illusional some real. I mean lets look at the lyrics, they are both naive and ethonocentric;
"..and there won't be snow in AFRICA this xmas (what about on top of mountains?), the greatest gift they'll get this year is life (life, while it lasts isn't a gift, its a right, clean water etc) where nothing ever grows (erm...which continent are they talking about? plenty can grow in Africa, which is part of the crime) no rain or river flow(Nile/Congo?) Do they know its xmas time at all ?(Well some of them do as a result of the missionaries, while other are muslim and unlikely to follow a roman pagan festival, while other are for want of a better term 'animist'"
This said there are levels of 'savvy' and we should not mock any attempt to effect a change, no matter how naive. The acorns sewn today can be nurtured. I mean lets face it how many of us have been looked at sideways as radical etc when we actually try and talk of neo-imperialim veiled behind the agenda of Globalisation. Lets hope that the little acorns sewn by Bob and Bono, may at least make a few pose some questions, I do not think they profess to supply any answers. If we consider ourselves politically savvy, it is our duty to see openings and speak up when people are opened and then debate/educate. To further push the point little acorns grow into great oaks, it is then our duty to watch for the acorns; if they are in good ground nurture their growth, if not do what we can to improve their chances of growth.
Let people do what people do, but let us keep our eyes and ears open for any opportunity to speak on issues concerning people marginalised with no voice, but the more ears that are opened by whatever the means the better.

Jamie Wood