Skip to content or view screen version

Was Nicholas Berg An Israeli Spy?

j | 13.05.2004 04:36

Was Nicholas Berg an Israeli spy? What is known is that he studied arabic just before he illegally entered Iraq and then was arrested by the Iraqis for being an Israeli spy.

Berg told friends Iraqi police mistook him for an Israeli spy

By Robert Moran

Knight Ridder Newspapers

BAGHDAD, Iraq - Nicholas Berg, the 26-year-old American whose videotaped decapitation was posted on the Internet, told friends here that Iraqi police arrested him because he had a Jewish-sounding last name and an Israeli stamp in his passport.
"They thought he was a spy," said Hugo Infante, a Chilean who works for the United Press International news service and lives at the al Fanar Hotel in central Baghdad, where Berg stayed until he checked out April 10 to return to the United States.
Berg apparently was taken hostage and then executed sometime before Saturday, when his headless body was discovered in a western suburb of Baghdad.
Why Berg was arrested, who held him, what happened to him after his release and what role his religion might have had in his death are key questions about the final days of the former Cornell University student with a penchant for travel to Third World countries.
Infante, 31, said Berg didn't seem particularly alarmed about his arrest and detention in the northern city of Mosul, where he apparently was held from March 25 to April 6. "He wasn't mad. It was adventure for him," Infante said, a view echoed by another friend, Andrew R. Duke, who said Berg shook off his detention.
"Basically his attitude it was all sort of fun, inconvenient," recalled Duke, 43, of Boulder, Colo.
The accounts of Berg's neighbors at the hotel where he lived as he pursued work in Iraq servicing communications towers provide the most detailed version to date of how the West Chester, Pa., native came to be in Iraqi police custody.
Infante said he last saw Berg on April 8 in the hotel's Internet cafe and that Berg told him he was leaving the country because business had declined. Berg talked about taking a plane from Baghdad to Jordan, Infante said.
Duke, who drank beer with Berg the night before he left, said Berg told him he'd made a lot of money and was thinking about going sailing in Turkey. He said he thought Berg was planning to leave the country by land.
"He was looking forward to going home," Duke said.
At the time Berg left the hotel, the road to Jordan was closed by U.S. forces and the road to Baghdad's airport frequently was attacked by insurgents.
State Department spokeswoman Kelly Shannon said a U.S. consular official in Iraq spoke with Berg on April 10 and offered to "assist him in departing Iraq by plane" for Jordan. She said Berg declined and said he planned to travel overland to Kuwait.
The FBI in Washington announced that it had opened an investigation into Berg's killing and acknowledged that its agents had interviewed Berg several times while he was in the custody of Iraqi police.
According to an FBI statement released in Washington, the U.S. military notified the bureau March 25 that an American was being held by Iraqi police. After several interviews with Berg and a visit to his parents' home in West Chester, the agents determined there was no reason for the Iraqis to detain him, the statement said.
It said the Coalition Provisional Authority, the U.S. entity that governs Iraq, helped coordinate Berg's release April 6. Dan Senor, a coalition spokesman in Iraq, said Berg was never in coalition custody.
Infante said Berg had referred to his jailers as members of the coalition, but it wasn't clear who ran the facility where he held. Iraqi police report to the CPA.
Berg's father, Michael, has accused U.S. authorities of contributing to his death by allowing him to be detained after his scheduled departure date March 30, the day before the grisly killings of four American private-security contractors in Fallujah touched off violence that claimed more American lives in the next month than any other period since U.S. forces invaded.
Infante said Berg told him he was arrested in Mosul, where he'd gone looking for work, after he had been drinking beer and was "messing around" on the street. Berg didn't elaborate, Infante said.
Infante said Berg told him he was kept in a cell by himself, but that other prisoners were in the building. Infante said Berg thought most of those prisoners were Iranians and other non-Iraqis who'd been detained for crossing illegally into Iraq.
Infante and Duke said Berg told them that Iraqi police suspected he was an Israeli spy because of the stamp in his passport.
Iraqi police in Mosul couldn't be reached for comment Wednesday, and coalition authorities offered no information on the reason for Berg's detention.
Senor said the FBI visited Berg three times while he was being held to determine what he was doing in Iraq. He also was being monitored by U.S. military police to make sure he was being fed and treated well, Brig. Gen. Mark Kimmitt said.
---
(Moran reports for The Philadelphia Inquirer.)
---
(c) 2004, Knight Ridder/Tribune Information Services.

 http://www.realcities.com/mld/krwashington/8651948.htm

j

Comments

Hide the following 10 comments

no ....he wasn't

13.05.2004 12:39

the ramifications of Nick Bergs executuion if the
situation is what i think it is

the Berg family business is
a 'Free Radio for the community '
technical back up company...

Carol Berg has been involved with
Prometheus project has been in battle with the FCC
which would already put the berg family
on a FBI watchlist via the 'NAZI' patriot act...

Nick Berg originally went to Irag under his own name not
mentioning his company in order
to scout for work involving technical support and
'Free radio' for Iraqis...

apparently he left Iraq again without
any success...

Had he already raised the FBI flag...

would wanting to help Iraqis have
propaganda free information/ entertainment
constitute an offence under
coalition 'strategy'????

He then went back and under the name 'Prometheus towers',
made an arrangement to meet someone...

Who was this?

Did he get worried?

he was arrested and held for 13 days...

The FBI interrogated him...

Why ?

because his family advocated free radio
and Mike Berg was on another anti war watchlist
which raised another flag?

They then , supposedly let him go...

Did they dump him in a politically
tight spot, a danger zone?

Or did they set up a psyops operation and
have a little fun with the poor man???

The list on free republic is similar to the
redwatch website...which seeks to create
hatred towards those who do not follow the line...

lists of commies...
lists of anti war advocates...

hmmm...

will we ever know the truth?
-----------------------------


the ramifications of this whole thing
are sinister...

what watch list are you on?

what flags are you raising?

Captain Wardrobe


The stink is rising...

13.05.2004 14:11

Ho Boy!!!

Take a look at  http://www.infowars.com/print/iraq/berg.htm See the video for yourself at  http://www.thememoryhole.org Is the sound dubbed or is this guy screaming without opening his mouth? Where is all the blood when his head is cut off? Where is the cerebral fluid? How does the screaming and shouts of alau ackbar seamlessly transverse the cut from pushing this guy to the ground and the sawing (is this like any other Islamic beheading you have seen or heard of) of his throat? Compare the pictures of Berg at  http://www.drudgereport.com/iiraq3.htm with the portrait on  http://www.kyw1060.com/news_story_detail.cfm?newsitemid=37563 - is this really the same guy? shorter neck; shorter, rounder face; ...

Oh shit, now half the page at  http://www.infowars.com/print/iraq/berg.htm has disappeared and the links (including the one to kyw1060) have gone! What is the URL for the al Queda site where the video was originally released and who is the ISP, where - physically - on the planet is it hosted? At what point did the CIA stop funding al Queda? Qui Bono? Quiz custodiat ( http://www.nypost.com/postopinion/editorial/20645.htm)? Excuse my latin but WTF is happening to our world?

Prajña
- Homepage: http://www.DeclarePeace.org.uk/


Different guys?

13.05.2004 19:46

Yes Prajna. I noticed the difference in todays UK Guardian.
The home photo shows a heavy set big-boned all-American boy, while the video shows a fine-boned slight figure. The faces seem to be completely different. The video 'Nick' has a Mediterranean appearance. I know weight-loss and hair growth can change a person's appearance - but surely not that much
This reminds me of that ridiculous CIA Bin Laden video, where the fake Bin Laden looked not a thing like the real one

dh


Probably is same person

14.05.2004 10:14

DH, the authenticated picture of Berg is apparently quite old and he had lost quite a lot of weight when in Ghana (according to his parents) and there are more recent photos of him which are considerably more like those taken from the video. I am regretting having mentioned the dissimilarity now since I believe it is a red herring. The real story is weirder and weirder - in fact my 'weirdshitometer' is entirely off the scale but I am still researching so won't give too much detail yet.

Berg was becoming more and more religious (jew) his father was anti-invasion and anti-zionist. Berg studied at 4 different universities in US but received no diploma from any of them. Was arrested several times in Iraq and when arrested in Mosel had koran and a book (unspecified) 'that appeared to be anti-semitic'. Lent his laptop to Moussaoi (held in US as possible 20th 911 hijacker) to send e-mail so was questioned by FBI in 2002. Set up Prometheus Method Tower company despite having no qualifications. Seemed to have no concern for his security whilst travelling around Iraq. Turned down an offer to be flown out of Iraq since he considered it to be safer to make his way down to Kuwait than to go from Baghdad to Baghdad Airport. Father (representing Prometheus Towers) endorsed the A.N.S.W.E.R list which was poster to the FReeper (right-wing) bulletin board prior to his second (fatal) visit to Iraq. Had made loads of money on his first trip but wanted to leave at the end of March on this one having failed to find work (but had set up a company (Babylon Towers) with an Iraqi who had spent 20 years in Philli.

Too much information, nothing gels, too weird. I'm working on it. This is a *very* rough outline, quickly noted. Watch this space.

Prajña


interesting

14.05.2004 12:43

keep us updated Prajna

it is really weird


I am wondering whether the whole Mossad angle that is coming
out of the US is yet another neocon attempt to smear the Berg family...

[it has Karl Rove written all over it]

what do you think?

Captain Wardrobe


question

14.05.2004 13:09


why would Mike Berg back his son, if he had no qualifications?

I read they set up business together...

I also heard that Mike Berg has differnet veiws on the Iraq war to his son...

So why would Mike Berg sign a petition under the name
Prometheus if he knew his son was going to Iraq under that name..?

Captain Wardrobe


more

14.05.2004 13:18

If Nick berg was implicated in the Laptop password 911,
and flags were raised...

How did he get past US airport security and into iraq in the first place?

weird

Captain Wardrobe


As I said, more l8er

14.05.2004 19:18

CW, the net has gone crazy over this. I am still trawling through facts, fiction and fabrications and it will take some time before I can begin to guess at any conclusions or point fingers. Ok, so there are a number of matches between the video and Abu Ghraib but if you were a (dead, one legged) terrorist wouldn't you want to make it look like you were spooks trying to look like terrorists? As I say, too much info that links in all kinds of directions. The 'contractors' who are 'assisting' MI were also recruited from the Phili area (and nearby MI base had nice towers that Nick would have found nearly irresistable)... mountains of stuff. I don't think anything happened - it is all just CIA attempt to get those prone to conspiracy theories to have a complete melt-down; like asking a robot a paradox - a kind of dawinism designed to weed out the overexcitable. Maybe you'ld like to continue this in the BBS on my website ( http://www.DeclarePeace.org.uk/) - I could kick off a forum. I'd like to get a little further ahead first though.

(Oh, and yes, if you want to play the CIA/Mossad thing then 5/11 or seems like a nice masonic magic number like 9/11 and 3/11 but me, I'm just adding another layer to my turban.)

Cheers.

Prajña


Prometeus The Nick Berg Project MAJOR SPY SATALLITE

22.05.2004 18:09

Look at the walls same color as Abu Prison look at the base board same as Abu Prison Look at the F****ING PLASTIC WHITE CHAIR SAME EXACT TYPE LYNDSEY ENGLAND WAS SHOWN SITTING IN. DID THEY RELEASE HIM IN AN ORANGE JUMPSUIT STANDARD PRISON ISSUE. He was dead before they cut off his head no blood and the FOOTAGE IS CUT ZARQAWI IS DEAD DIED 2 MONTHS AGO.
Berg was working UA/OPS UN-ACKNOWLEDGED OPERATIONS, GET CAUGHT? THEY DISAVOW THE WHOLE STORY. Berg found out that the system he was working on is THE SPY SAT PRGM CALLED PROMETHEUS IT TARGETS ANYONE USING CERTAIN REFERENCES BOMBS, ATTACK, INFIDEL, WAR, CAPABLE OF LISTENING TO PRIVATE CONVERSATIONS THROUGH PHONE LINES TV RADIO WALKIE TALKIES.

SOCOMM


Are You All Nuts?

09.06.2004 22:30

As one with some mildly left sympathies, I often find Indymedia.org grotesque, idiotic, ignorant, offensive, and sad. The conspiratorial tone of these postings on the brutal murder of Mr. Berg serve as confirmation of my opinion. There is no evidence whatsoever that Nicholas Berg was anything other than a well-intentioned, but naive businessman. To his profound misfortune, he also happened to be a Jew in Iraq, part of an Islamic world (and not just the Arab portion) that has embraced the most vile anti-semitism and the resulting beliefs in Jewish global conspiracy and Israel demonization. Many foreigners sadly have been abducted in Iraq. They are of many nationalities including Americans, Polish, French, Russian, Japanese, Italian, Turkish, and Chinese. So far as we know, some but not most have been murdered. Berg was murdered very shortly after his kidnapping, the obvious reason being that he-unlike the other abductees, was a Jew. This video is a anti-semitic snuff film and the the sadly unconscious shame of many on the left and in the Islamic world it has not been met with the nausea that is the only possible response a non-sociopathic human being can have to this judeocidal sadism. Furthermore, even if Berg were an Israeli 'spy' (ha, ha, and now I am indulging paranoid fantasies), given the fact that Iraq is/has been a deeply anti-semitic state (witness the fate of the Iraqi Jews, subjected to violence, dispossession, occasional murder, and mass deportation)and has been firmly and unjustifiably committed to Israel's destruction since 1948, some spying would be at the very least morally justifiable. But this is a huge digression. Berg was not a spy. He was simply a good man too young to realize the murderous contempt modern Islam has for all Jews. This tragedy is compounded by the fact that many at this site share their venom.....

Wang Wei