Multicultural Diversity
Fly on the wall | 04.11.2003 14:43 | Sheffield
If anyone saw the documentary 'Disunited Kingdom' on Channel Four last week - for those who didn't see it - below is the main content from the programme, witten by Kenan Malik.
This guy used to write for Living Marxism(!) a magazine that nearly always published views looking at issues through a perspective from which the rest of the "politically correct" Left were afraid to look.
This guy used to write for Living Marxism(!) a magazine that nearly always published views looking at issues through a perspective from which the rest of the "politically correct" Left were afraid to look.
Diversity training is really a PR exercise, a way of projecting a positive public image.
'Diversity' has become a brand, a kind of Benetton shorthand for cool, liberal modernity. And any organisation that wants to brush up its image signs up. When the BBC wanted to shake off its fuddy-duddy image, it replaced its logo of a spinning globe with shots of wheelchair-bound dreadlocked basketball players and Indian classical dancers. When the Arts Council wanted to become more relevant it launched its Year of Diversity. When Ford motor company was revealed 'whiting out' black faces on its ads, it responded by instituting a glossy, multi-million pound diversity programme.
Even the BNP are at it. Over the past few years, under the leadership of Nick Griffin, the BNP has attempted to rebrand itself from a party of street thugs into a democratic organisation defending 'English culture' and 'white identity'. According to its website, the BNP's 'moderate, commonsense position' is that 'races are neither equal nor unequal, but simply different'. 'Fortunately', it suggests, 'increasing awareness of the scientifically established reality of such differences is undermining the old egalitarian dogmas and making it ever easier for those of us who champion human genetic and cultural diversity to win the argument.'
I met Griffin in a pub in Mixenden near Halifax on the day when the BNP won its fifth council seat in a local bye-election. It was a surreal encounter - a decade ago I might have come to a pub like this to beat up people like Griffin. Now I was interviewing him for a Channel 4 documentary. But more surreal was Griffin's patter. 'There are two kinds of diversity', he told me. 'The diversity of nations in Britain - the English, Welsh, Scots and Irish - and on global scale, all great traditions and cultures of the world.' It was a racist bigot talking as if he'd just been on the same diversity course as me.
Griffin remains the man who, in 1995, wrote in the BNP magazine The Rune that the party should be 'a strong, well disciplined organisation with the ability to back up its slogan "Defend Rights for Whites" with well directed boots and fists.' He has learnt, however, to translate this racist project into diversity-speak. The BNP takes the sense of abandonment and resentment felt in areas such as Mixenden and wraps it in the language of identity and victimhood. Other ethnic groups are allowed the promote their identity, so why not the English? Why has English heritage been abandoned? Why should white identity not be included in the multicultural map? And so on. It is perhaps the biggest indictment of the contemporary celebration of diversity that it allows someone like Griffin to turn racism into a cultural identity.
The unthinking pursuit of diversity not only gives legitimacy to the likes of Nick Griffin. It also helps divide communities far more effectively than racism. Take Bradford. From the beginnings of mass immigration in the 1950s racism has helped create deep divisions in the city. But it also helped generate political struggles against discrimination, the impact of which was to create bridges across ethnic, racial and cultural fissures. In response to the militancy of these struggles, the local council in the early eighties rolled out its multicultural programme, including a 12-point race relations plan which declared that every section of the 'multiracial, multicultural city' had 'an equal right to maintain its own identity, culture, language, religion and customs'. Council funding became linked to cultural identity, so different groups began asserting their differences ever more fiercely. The consequence has been not simply to entrench the divisions created by racism, but to make cross-cultural interaction more difficult.
Today, cultural segregation in Bradford has become so profound that the local education authority has started bussing children from all-Asian schools to all-white schools, and vice versa. The so-called 'Linking project' aims to break down barriers between children, many of whom have never interacted with a child from the other community.
I travelled with a group of Asian 10-year olds from the all-Asian Farnham Primary School in Great Horton as they visited their white counterparts at the largely white St Anthony's Catholic school. For most of them it was their third trip. 'What was it like the first time you visited St Anthony's?', I asked one of the children.
'Nervous', he said.
'Why were you nervous?'
'Because I didn't know what they'd be like. I'd never met them before.'
'You'd never met white children before?'
'No.'
'Do you know any white children apart from those at St Anthony's?'
'No.'
Could this really be Britain, 2003?
'I've got a present for you.' That's how my teacher introduced me, as a six-year old, on my first day at school in England. It was the era of Paki-bashing and Powellism, when black people were still viewed as exotic creatures and treated with fear, hatred and condescension in equal measure. Thirty years on it's almost impossible to imagine how inward, looking, parochial and racist Britain used to be. Mass immigration has opened up British society, transformed its culture and created a nation far more vibrant and cosmopolitan than would have seemed possible three decades ago.
But diversity has become more than simply a way of describing the expansion of our experiences. It has also become a dogma about how we should live that has become as stultifying as old-fashioned racism - and often as divisive. The dogmatic pursuit of diversity means that there remain schools in which seeing someone of a different skin colour is as exotic an event as it was to my white classmates three decades ago. Half a century ago the American authorities were forced to bus black children to break the stranglehold of racism in the schools of the Deep South. Did anyone ever imagine that local authorities in Britain would be forced to follow suit in 2003 to break the stranglehold of cultural segregation?
Kenan Malik
There's more stuff about race etc in and amongst his website. I don't like a lot of what he has to say in some of his work (like on the subject of human genetics) but difficult subjects that have no easy black & white answers and unless we talk this stuff through, ideas will end up getting left behind.
'Diversity' has become a brand, a kind of Benetton shorthand for cool, liberal modernity. And any organisation that wants to brush up its image signs up. When the BBC wanted to shake off its fuddy-duddy image, it replaced its logo of a spinning globe with shots of wheelchair-bound dreadlocked basketball players and Indian classical dancers. When the Arts Council wanted to become more relevant it launched its Year of Diversity. When Ford motor company was revealed 'whiting out' black faces on its ads, it responded by instituting a glossy, multi-million pound diversity programme.
Even the BNP are at it. Over the past few years, under the leadership of Nick Griffin, the BNP has attempted to rebrand itself from a party of street thugs into a democratic organisation defending 'English culture' and 'white identity'. According to its website, the BNP's 'moderate, commonsense position' is that 'races are neither equal nor unequal, but simply different'. 'Fortunately', it suggests, 'increasing awareness of the scientifically established reality of such differences is undermining the old egalitarian dogmas and making it ever easier for those of us who champion human genetic and cultural diversity to win the argument.'
I met Griffin in a pub in Mixenden near Halifax on the day when the BNP won its fifth council seat in a local bye-election. It was a surreal encounter - a decade ago I might have come to a pub like this to beat up people like Griffin. Now I was interviewing him for a Channel 4 documentary. But more surreal was Griffin's patter. 'There are two kinds of diversity', he told me. 'The diversity of nations in Britain - the English, Welsh, Scots and Irish - and on global scale, all great traditions and cultures of the world.' It was a racist bigot talking as if he'd just been on the same diversity course as me.
Griffin remains the man who, in 1995, wrote in the BNP magazine The Rune that the party should be 'a strong, well disciplined organisation with the ability to back up its slogan "Defend Rights for Whites" with well directed boots and fists.' He has learnt, however, to translate this racist project into diversity-speak. The BNP takes the sense of abandonment and resentment felt in areas such as Mixenden and wraps it in the language of identity and victimhood. Other ethnic groups are allowed the promote their identity, so why not the English? Why has English heritage been abandoned? Why should white identity not be included in the multicultural map? And so on. It is perhaps the biggest indictment of the contemporary celebration of diversity that it allows someone like Griffin to turn racism into a cultural identity.
The unthinking pursuit of diversity not only gives legitimacy to the likes of Nick Griffin. It also helps divide communities far more effectively than racism. Take Bradford. From the beginnings of mass immigration in the 1950s racism has helped create deep divisions in the city. But it also helped generate political struggles against discrimination, the impact of which was to create bridges across ethnic, racial and cultural fissures. In response to the militancy of these struggles, the local council in the early eighties rolled out its multicultural programme, including a 12-point race relations plan which declared that every section of the 'multiracial, multicultural city' had 'an equal right to maintain its own identity, culture, language, religion and customs'. Council funding became linked to cultural identity, so different groups began asserting their differences ever more fiercely. The consequence has been not simply to entrench the divisions created by racism, but to make cross-cultural interaction more difficult.
Today, cultural segregation in Bradford has become so profound that the local education authority has started bussing children from all-Asian schools to all-white schools, and vice versa. The so-called 'Linking project' aims to break down barriers between children, many of whom have never interacted with a child from the other community.
I travelled with a group of Asian 10-year olds from the all-Asian Farnham Primary School in Great Horton as they visited their white counterparts at the largely white St Anthony's Catholic school. For most of them it was their third trip. 'What was it like the first time you visited St Anthony's?', I asked one of the children.
'Nervous', he said.
'Why were you nervous?'
'Because I didn't know what they'd be like. I'd never met them before.'
'You'd never met white children before?'
'No.'
'Do you know any white children apart from those at St Anthony's?'
'No.'
Could this really be Britain, 2003?
'I've got a present for you.' That's how my teacher introduced me, as a six-year old, on my first day at school in England. It was the era of Paki-bashing and Powellism, when black people were still viewed as exotic creatures and treated with fear, hatred and condescension in equal measure. Thirty years on it's almost impossible to imagine how inward, looking, parochial and racist Britain used to be. Mass immigration has opened up British society, transformed its culture and created a nation far more vibrant and cosmopolitan than would have seemed possible three decades ago.
But diversity has become more than simply a way of describing the expansion of our experiences. It has also become a dogma about how we should live that has become as stultifying as old-fashioned racism - and often as divisive. The dogmatic pursuit of diversity means that there remain schools in which seeing someone of a different skin colour is as exotic an event as it was to my white classmates three decades ago. Half a century ago the American authorities were forced to bus black children to break the stranglehold of racism in the schools of the Deep South. Did anyone ever imagine that local authorities in Britain would be forced to follow suit in 2003 to break the stranglehold of cultural segregation?
Kenan Malik
There's more stuff about race etc in and amongst his website. I don't like a lot of what he has to say in some of his work (like on the subject of human genetics) but difficult subjects that have no easy black & white answers and unless we talk this stuff through, ideas will end up getting left behind.
Fly on the wall
Comments
Hide the following 20 comments
Lee Jasper
04.11.2003 16:22
In the interview, Malik played Jasper a video of what Griffin had said, which was basically that the BNP loved Jasper's segregationalist agenda and was wholly in favour of Jasper's policy line.
Jasper's response? After looking stunned to the core, he fled from the interview into a lift, shook his fist and screamed "BLACK POWER!!" as the doors closed.
Draw your own conclusions.
http://www.blackinbritain.co.uk/AZfiles/LeeJasper.htm
Guwahati
Ummm.
04.11.2003 17:57
"The Jewish Onslaught" my arse. I hate Sharon and his pissant murderous regime as much as the next man, but we really have to watch ourselves here, or we'll be as bad as them...
tsk tsk tsk
Mad Monk
Seperatist Arts Centre
04.11.2003 18:22
Haringey council are building a separatist arts centre costing £50million - just one of a string of dodgy arts centres that various unaccountable power crazed councils across the UK. This particular one will be the Bernie Grant Arts Centre!
( And what a dodgy council that was - I'd love to go over their books and a certain H*** bank account in H******).
Arts centres are just one of the ways that bent politicos and property developers rip off the poor and create overpaid pointless jobs for the middle classes,yuppies and the extremely talentless and unimaginative. We allpay for it with our taxes. Skincolour has fuck all to do with it - the mode of capitalist power relations everything. This planet is full of ripped off artists who have onething in common -they have all been exploited by the arts and media industry. Fuck the Turner prize. Fuck the mainstream media. Fuck the ICA.Fuck MTV. Fuck Sky. Fuck the shoreditch twat. DIY. No sellout.
Dodgy Politicos
Sources please?
04.11.2003 20:29
hazel
Source
04.11.2003 21:42
Guwahati
the only way?
04.11.2003 22:39
no more schools in the north of ireland for protestant or catholic only!
no more state funded posh COE schools for rich christians only!
no more state helped islamic only schools!
it is all the same,
on a side note when are anarchists going to rid themselves of the white-middle-class-anglo-saxon-patriachal attitudes?
maybe it is time to take a femminist-working-class-black aproach to things?
translator
Screaming?
05.11.2003 05:03
http://www.spiked-online.com/Printable/00000006DFA7.htm
THere doesn't seem to be a transcript on the channel 4 site either.
hazel
Hazel... you're starting to bore me now
05.11.2003 12:46
Guwahati
If that's pedantry, long live pedantry
05.11.2003 14:04
How sad to be so rude, previous poster. There's nothing wrong in trying to establish facts, surely. Your report sounds like it was exaggerating for effect. The reports Hazel found seemed to be more straightforward, if less dramatic. I know which I'd prefer to read, and it's the one closest to reality. We live in bloody strange times, we need to be careful with words. Thanks for this discussion anyway.
Intrigued
Facts are more boring than innuendo
05.11.2003 15:01
And by the way, a pendant is a necklace ornament.
hazel
Ummm II
05.11.2003 16:16
A fine thing to shout after the head of the BNP has cited your opinions with approval, I'm sure.
I saw it with mine own eyes, so there. No-one's trying to be rude, Haze, but sticking up for the self-serving likes of Jasper isn't clever. The man's a dick.
Mad Monk
Evidence
05.11.2003 19:53
All I'd like to see is more than someone's word for it that he shouted anything. The only written review I can find says otherwise. Happy to be proven wrong though...
hazel
Pendantry
05.11.2003 23:02
Guwahati
okay
05.11.2003 23:08
hazel
watch more telly !
06.11.2003 12:40
When u think that probably a million people wtched the Divided Britain programme, shown twice last week, it's a lot more than who use IMC.
...I've still got a copy of this if anyone wants to view, it's at the end of a tape with Jap horror films Ring/II - not for the faint-hearted, so I'll wind it on to right bit if interested!
Fly on the wall
e-mail: socialinadequate2000@yahoo.co.uk
stop the Nazis
06.11.2003 12:48
http://www.anl.org.uk
kurious
previous posting was a touch abstract...
06.11.2003 18:09
throughout the last few decades, people saw that eastern european immigrants came to britain and had to fend for themselves until their communities established, same with Irish and then with Black immigrants who had to do much the same. what a lot people see is an exception when it came to the asian communities who get the benefit of the PC 80s and 90s multicultural policy adopted by local authorities while the working class in general (the majority being white and so directly not benefitting from this) got poorer as monetarist politics took a hold on things.
I think we all benefit from being around different cultures but i can see why the poorest in this country end up scapegoating recent immigrant cultures as they see no golden age that our grandparents were promised.
blatant plug for ANL?
how and where to fight racism?
06.11.2003 22:00
the reasons for working class blacks getting poor results are the same as working class whites getting poor results, (anti-school sub-culture, colectivist attitude and imediate gratification).
why do *some* working class communities not want assylum seekers in their area?
in their area there are not enough jobs for the working class community already there, the services are already stretched to maximum already and even a tiny amount extra is deemed acceptable. *If* more resources were put into the area at the same time as locating assylum seekers into these areas then people would be fine about it and that would be that.
Why doesnt the government locate assylum seekers into middle class areas?
because the middle class backlash against assylum seekers would be much larger than the working class backlash. (look at other things that attacked middle class people and see the back lash eg the people who had their course work badly marked all 2000 of them).
The answer?
i don't know (yet!), possible put more resources into areas that are getting more newbies? possibly house assylum seekers in middle class areas?
but definatly improve the quality and quantity of council housing!!
we need to improve the enviroment, education and health of the working class areas, and we need the local groups to become more effective and less of a reflection of modern society.
translator
Translator is spot on IMO
07.11.2003 00:09
Aslam
cultural diversity is fine
07.11.2003 18:54
know better take the wrong attitude to cultural diversity. They think
that peoplev will behave badly unless there are lots of laws and
bullshit courses for people like police and judges.
Cultural diversity is an opportunity, but it does require considerable
mental effort to try and do something like learning another language.
It is well worth itm because learning how other people think about
us is important and a means of getting enlightenment.
The quest for insight should be a guide to the correct behaviour
to people from other backgrounds.
The state, rather than trying to enforce some political view on how
people should treat their neighbours should invest more in language
teaching in schools and universities, and also in giving people the
opportunities to follow these courses.
The regulation of broadcasting in the UK should include the option of
foreign language stations being rebroadcast here at affordable prices.
Al Jazeera should certainly be made more widely available in this country.
tony goddard
e-mail: tony@lowtech.org
Homepage: http://d4maths.lowtech.org