New Labour in bed with Microsoft
Derek McMillan | 03.08.2003 13:10 | Education | Technology
I am a teacher. I was appalled at the Government's Framework for ICT for a number of reasons but this article is about the way it promotes Microsoft.
Microsoft's “Special Educational Pricing”
The government's framework for ICT is an uninterrupted paean of praise for Microsoft's products. The argument used is that because Microsoft is so widespread there is no need for students to know about any other system. It is fine for a substantial chunk of the educational budget to be handed over to the fat cats of this global corporation while the government lavishes free advertising on them at our expense.
This is in any case a fake argument. Microsoft may be all-poweful now. IBM once was. Schools could have ignored anything which was not IBM “because pupils would never need it in the real world” and be left looking pretty stupid now. Pupils who can only use Microsoft taught by teachers who can only use Microsoft is Bill Gates' wet dream but it is an educational nightmare.
I use Microsoft products when there is no alternative but usually there is an alternative product. I am not promoting any particular alternative but open source free software, such as Mozilla and Open Office, does not put a penny into the pockets of the corporations.
I downloaded Mozilla. It is free. It is a better program for editing web pages than the cumbersome Microsoft products recommended by the government. It does not require pupils to understand HTML - it teaches it to them. Pupils work on the text of the web page they want to produce and there is one tab which can show them how the html tags are being used in their text and another tab which shows them what the “raw” HTML looks like.
I downloaded open office. It took a long time to download but once downloaded I am using it now to produce a Word document which could be imported into Microsoft Word if necessary and this morning I used it to produce an Excel spreadsheet – and all without wasting public money – or my own for that matter – propping up Microsoft.
Open source software also has more educational value than Microsoft because pupils who want to know more about the software at any level can find out more without coming up against a brick wall of “business secrets” used by the corporations to protect themselves against rivals. More advanced students can even download the source code for the programs.
The websites of the open source projects referred to here are:
http://www.mozilla.org
http://www.openoffice.org/
Derek McMillan ( http://derekmcmillan.tripod.com )
The government's framework for ICT is an uninterrupted paean of praise for Microsoft's products. The argument used is that because Microsoft is so widespread there is no need for students to know about any other system. It is fine for a substantial chunk of the educational budget to be handed over to the fat cats of this global corporation while the government lavishes free advertising on them at our expense.
This is in any case a fake argument. Microsoft may be all-poweful now. IBM once was. Schools could have ignored anything which was not IBM “because pupils would never need it in the real world” and be left looking pretty stupid now. Pupils who can only use Microsoft taught by teachers who can only use Microsoft is Bill Gates' wet dream but it is an educational nightmare.
I use Microsoft products when there is no alternative but usually there is an alternative product. I am not promoting any particular alternative but open source free software, such as Mozilla and Open Office, does not put a penny into the pockets of the corporations.
I downloaded Mozilla. It is free. It is a better program for editing web pages than the cumbersome Microsoft products recommended by the government. It does not require pupils to understand HTML - it teaches it to them. Pupils work on the text of the web page they want to produce and there is one tab which can show them how the html tags are being used in their text and another tab which shows them what the “raw” HTML looks like.
I downloaded open office. It took a long time to download but once downloaded I am using it now to produce a Word document which could be imported into Microsoft Word if necessary and this morning I used it to produce an Excel spreadsheet – and all without wasting public money – or my own for that matter – propping up Microsoft.
Open source software also has more educational value than Microsoft because pupils who want to know more about the software at any level can find out more without coming up against a brick wall of “business secrets” used by the corporations to protect themselves against rivals. More advanced students can even download the source code for the programs.
The websites of the open source projects referred to here are:
http://www.mozilla.org
http://www.openoffice.org/
Derek McMillan ( http://derekmcmillan.tripod.com )
Derek McMillan
e-mail:
derekmcmillan@hotmail.com
Homepage:
http://derekmcmillan.tk
Comments
Hide the following 10 comments
Evil Cycle
03.08.2003 14:03
Richard Kirkcaldy
e-mail: richard@lordrich.com
Homepage: http://lordrich.com/
Technical reasons
03.08.2003 14:20
Sure some of the servers could run linux, in theory, but Microsoft requires you to run everything integrated. The exchange server is tightly integrated with the Active Directory, which runs the file server nice and easy.
I hate Microsoft as much as anybody, but they do make easy to use software which works.
Richard
e-mail: richard@lordrich.com
Homepage: http://lordrich.com
I hate Microsoft...
03.08.2003 14:38
- My printer only works with it (tho it's currently on the blink)
- I cannot find any alternative that's suitable (yes I know there's Linux), but can you use RealPlayer, Windows Media, and, dare I say it, MSN messenger (it's the only thing that my friends use)?
- With my previous attempts at Linux, I got pissed off with not being able to install drivers etc without having to have a full course in the damn thing (hence why I resorted to installing Windoze 98 again after roughly one hour)
- What is all this kernel stuff?!?!?
However, I have switched to Mozilla, but still use IE for stuff that doesn't work in Mozilla , such as Hotmail cause I reject cookies, and I use Staroffice (got it when it was still free) over Micro$oft Office too.
Oh well, I hope the penguin will fly high after the revolution...
Thomas J
In bed with the labour party
03.08.2003 16:22
the body that is the ruleing class which encompasses both the western
politicians and that of the big trans national business ,they are all
the same thing .The title gives the impresion that new labour party is somthing seperate
from the labour party and can be saved, it is not ,it is just the latest movement of the
labour party which has never represented anyone except itself and the ruling elite
from the very start of its history.It is time to dump the whole labour party new or old.
cheers
freddie the gold fish
John prescotts long lost goldfish
GNU/Linux *IS* a potential alternative
03.08.2003 18:38
A quick response to Richard and Thomas J...
There are plenty of alternatives within the 'opensource' or 'free software' world (what you call it depends upon which side of the philosophical divide you come down on, but that's not for here... more can be found by watching the excellent docu-drama Revolution OS) for programs commonly used on a micro$oft office machine. Here are some examples:
Groupware - I think you mean office sharing software such as 'groupwise' or the sharing capabilities of M$ outlook. Ximian produce Evolution which is a fine alternative.
Accountancy packages - try GnuCash for starters
there are plenty of terminals which come with any linux distribution - also editors, shells and plenty of other things which I haven't ever needed to understand in all the time I've used linux (3 years, so fat, and I'm no computer phreak either)
There are versions of RealPlayer (www.real.com), adobe acrobat reader and windows media player (Xmms - the equivelant audio player *nix operating systems) as well as Xine, a free high quality video player. Indeed, as I checked out the link to make sure it was correct, I discovered that xine has just been "borrowed" for use in a commercially available personal linux environment. I won't provide them with free advertising space!
There are numerous messenging programmes which will connect to a variety of different networks and protocols, including irc, aol, m$n, jabber, icq, and so on...
Finally, several things should be remembered about the linux distributions now available. Over the past few years, the huge number of people using them has multiplied to even more people using them. At the same time, discovery of software bugs has increased (due to more usage) and more modifications have been made. Strange pieces of hardware (tv cards, winmodems, cd-burners, printers, whatever) have been adapted to work using the linux operating system and normally someone has had a similar problem to you before. Consequently, it is really easy to type a question into google - or a few key words (try "free video player linux" and see what comes up!) - and get a piece of software that will work on your computer and do what you want.
The one catch might be that I think a good internet connection is essential - I have broadband and it does mean that I can make good use of both new software and updated versions of my current software as they are developed. And there is no cost.
Have fun (and get off the internet - the revolution will not be broadcast on broadband, even if the war in iraq is)
garcondumonde
Links
03.08.2003 18:46
http://indymedia.org.uk/en/2003/07/274430.html - Revolution OS
http://www.ximian.org - Ximian Evolution
http://www.gnucash.org - GnuCash
RealPlayer - http://www.real.com
Adobe - http://www.adobe.com - follow the link 'other operating systems' on the acrobat download page
http://www.xmms.org - Xmms - free audio player
http://xinehq.de/ - Xine - free high quality video player
garcondumonde
actually
03.08.2003 19:36
The question is how do we change it. Sure we can create Linux accounting packages suitable for big business, sure we can create servers which will do what businesses need. But you can't cross over straight away - you need to port the data, and you can't gradually change over because time spent dual booting would take up half the day.
Wine is good, but nobody is going to support it.
I do want to see free/open software used in business, it's just difficult and costly to get it in.
Richard
e-mail: richard@lordrich.com
Homepage: http://lordrich.com/
Get rid of Microsoft
04.08.2003 12:10
Capitalist Running Dog
Microsoft is not secure
04.08.2003 12:14
http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/55/32104.html
~
Groupware
04.08.2003 16:44
http://www.theregister.co.uk/content/4/32119.html
http://www.opengroupware.org/
Though I'm still resigned to using Windows as my OS, I rarely have to use any of their applications any longer. OpenOffice does everything I need an office suite to do very capably, and web browsing/emailing in a mixture of Mozilla and Opera is a pleasure compared to having to use Internet Exploiter.
alx