We don't raze homes for no reason
jennie | 06.06.2003 04:22
"Suddenly we saw Jews in the house," said Amana
Za'anin. An officer and soldiers entered through
a breach they opened in the wall of the house.
They aimed their weapons at the family, and
ordered them out. According to the family, they
were not allowed to take anything with them.
Za'anin. An officer and soldiers entered through
a breach they opened in the wall of the house.
They aimed their weapons at the family, and
ordered them out. According to the family, they
were not allowed to take anything with them.
QUOTES FROM AN ARTICLE TODAY IN HAARETZ, a leading jewish newspaper in Israel. Ask yourself what sort of reason would you feel justified this sort of thing in, say, Northern Ireland even. In fact the IDF were confused, and at first could find no record of there being any reason at all for the demolition.
If this isn't a war crime, I don't know what is.
BEIT HANUN, Gaza - Ahmed Za'anin's house now looks
like some 1,200 other Palestinian homes: a pile of
rubble. On May 18, at about 7 P.M., IDF bulldozers
knocked down four houses, one partially, which
belonged to the extended Za'anin family, in Ezbat
Beit Hanun in the northern Gaza Strip.......
......"Suddenly we saw Jews in the house," said Amana
Za'anin. An officer and soldiers entered through
a breach they opened in the wall of the house.
They aimed their weapons at the family, and
ordered them out. According to the family, they
were not allowed to take anything with them. Not
even the mother's head covering. The student
daughter cried she didn't want to leave without
her books and notebooks. Her parents said that
they had to drag her away from "under the
bulldozer.".....
.....during the demolition, a
goat shed was destroyed; some of the goats were
crushed under the heavy machinery. Storehouses
were demolished as well as some farm equipment,
including a tractor. A well-preserved 1960
Mercedes was destroyed, as were beehives that
were dragged and crushed, now scattered among the
rubble. More than 50 people lived in the four
houses, and now they are crowded in with
relatives and neighbors. They cannot cross the
street - not even the oldest among them - to
reach the city. The tanks prevent that passage....
...And 14-year-old Mohammed
Za'anin was killed. He and his family didn't know
that an IDF force had taken up a position in the
next-door house. At the end of the first day of
the IDF takeover, the Za'anin family went up to a
little bridge that connects two parts of their
compound, to see what was going on around them.
Mohammed, the son, was killed - shot in the head....
...In the last two weeks, IDF forces have uprooted
the orchards and groves of Beit Hanun. On the
first day of the operation, the IDF blew up and
demolished four houses inside Beit Hanun.
If this isn't a war crime, I don't know what is.
BEIT HANUN, Gaza - Ahmed Za'anin's house now looks
like some 1,200 other Palestinian homes: a pile of
rubble. On May 18, at about 7 P.M., IDF bulldozers
knocked down four houses, one partially, which
belonged to the extended Za'anin family, in Ezbat
Beit Hanun in the northern Gaza Strip.......
......"Suddenly we saw Jews in the house," said Amana
Za'anin. An officer and soldiers entered through
a breach they opened in the wall of the house.
They aimed their weapons at the family, and
ordered them out. According to the family, they
were not allowed to take anything with them. Not
even the mother's head covering. The student
daughter cried she didn't want to leave without
her books and notebooks. Her parents said that
they had to drag her away from "under the
bulldozer.".....
.....during the demolition, a
goat shed was destroyed; some of the goats were
crushed under the heavy machinery. Storehouses
were demolished as well as some farm equipment,
including a tractor. A well-preserved 1960
Mercedes was destroyed, as were beehives that
were dragged and crushed, now scattered among the
rubble. More than 50 people lived in the four
houses, and now they are crowded in with
relatives and neighbors. They cannot cross the
street - not even the oldest among them - to
reach the city. The tanks prevent that passage....
...And 14-year-old Mohammed
Za'anin was killed. He and his family didn't know
that an IDF force had taken up a position in the
next-door house. At the end of the first day of
the IDF takeover, the Za'anin family went up to a
little bridge that connects two parts of their
compound, to see what was going on around them.
Mohammed, the son, was killed - shot in the head....
...In the last two weeks, IDF forces have uprooted
the orchards and groves of Beit Hanun. On the
first day of the operation, the IDF blew up and
demolished four houses inside Beit Hanun.
jennie
Homepage:
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/pages/ShArt.jhtml?itemNo=300656&contrassID=2&subContrassID=4&sbSubContrassID=0&listSrc=Y
Comments
Hide the following 2 comments
Realist
06.06.2003 16:22
I have never seen anybody justifying suicide bombings. Empathising with them, yes. Justifying, never.
What this sort of action does justify is any form of resistance in the occupied territories - blowing up tanks, attacking IDF checkpoints, attacking settlers are all justified.
This sort of collective punishment by the IDF is a warcrime, and needs to be treated as such.
I repeat - suicide bombings are unjustified and unjustifiable.
If you've got a better argument that repeating your 'suicide bombing' mantra, I'm sure we'd all love to hear it.
Brian
I read my posting through again......
08.06.2003 04:52
Were you replying to a different posting, Realist ?
Or did you just instinctively feel you had to say something in Israel's defence, and couldn't find anything ata all?
I think I'll count that as your subconscious agreement that this is a crime.
But let me ask YOU a question Realist, since you raised the question of the unjustifiability of criminal acts against civilians (and I agree with you). Here's the question:
Are you saying that the suicide attacks by a small number of palestinians militants justify the crimes against civilians described in the Haaretz article ?
Because if you are, then YOU are indeed that thing you thought to make ME out to be.
Or is it because you think the civilians silently approve of the crimes committed by their "side" ? But don't the bulk of Israeli citizens do the same? They even vote in a democratic system for the continuation of these crimes. Democracy. Rule of the people.
Come on, face facts. Read the posting again with an open mind. Are you really, honestly, not appalled by what the IDF are doing ?
jennie