Iraq's Dossier
Inspector Gadget | 08.12.2002 12:20
The US was warned against pre-judging Iraq's weapons details but the Home Secretary, Jack Straw has already denounced Saddam's dossier as lies, before it has even been read.
The Federal Opposition's foreign affairs spokesman has warned against judging Iraq's disclosure of its weapons programs before the 12,000 page document is analysed.
Iraq says details of its former nuclear, chemical and biological programs are now on their way to the United Nations headquarters in New York.
But United States President George Bush says he will pursue efforts to end Saddam Hussein's accumulation of weapons of mass destruction.
Labor's foreign affairs spokesman, Kevin Rudd, says the United States should allow the documents to be assessed first.
"It needs to be studied carefully, cautiously and systematically before a judgement is taken," he said.
"Therefore we cannot be, we can not afford to have any rush to judgement either by the United States by Australia or any other western government.
"Let's look at the evidence, let's make an assessment then," he said.
But White House spokesman Ari Fleisher says Saddam can't be trusted, so all Iraq's efforts to evade an invasion by compliance, are futile.
We'll bomb them anyway....
Iraq says details of its former nuclear, chemical and biological programs are now on their way to the United Nations headquarters in New York.
But United States President George Bush says he will pursue efforts to end Saddam Hussein's accumulation of weapons of mass destruction.
Labor's foreign affairs spokesman, Kevin Rudd, says the United States should allow the documents to be assessed first.
"It needs to be studied carefully, cautiously and systematically before a judgement is taken," he said.
"Therefore we cannot be, we can not afford to have any rush to judgement either by the United States by Australia or any other western government.
"Let's look at the evidence, let's make an assessment then," he said.
But White House spokesman Ari Fleisher says Saddam can't be trusted, so all Iraq's efforts to evade an invasion by compliance, are futile.
We'll bomb them anyway....
Inspector Gadget
Comments
Hide the following comment
us take sole copy!
10.12.2002 05:30
(AP) Two Iraqi soldiers stand guard as U.N. weapons inspectors vehicles drive by a portrait of Iraqi...
Full Image
UNITED NATIONS (AP) - The United States took possession Monday of the Security Council's copy of Saddam Hussein's massive arms declaration, as inspectors began combing the dossier for clues about whether Iraq is free of weapons of mass destruction.
Reversing an earlier decision, the U.N. Security Council agreed late Sunday to give the United States and the four other permanent council members - Britain, France, Russia and China - full copies of the 12,000-page declaration.
Deputy Russian Ambassador Gennady Gatilov said the United States had taken the council's lone copy to Washington where it would make duplicates for distribution to the four other powerful council members.
The 10 non-permanent members, including Syria, will see only a censored version of the document once weapons inspectors have gone through the report and removed sensitive material - including possible instructions on bomb-making.
Angered by the decision cut over the weekend by Secretary of State Colin Powell, diplomats said, Syria planned to protest the arrangement during Security Council consultations Monday.
Meanwhile, U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan said it would take some time to review the declaration and he called on Washington and others to be patient with the inspectors.
"The inspectors will have to review them, analyze them and report to the council, and I think that's going to take a while."
In Washington, White House press secretary Ari Fleischer withheld judgment on the massive documentation and said the United States wants to study the material "thoroughly, completely and fully and thoughtfully."
The U.N. nuclear agency said Monday that at first glance, the nuclear section of the dossier repeats Saddam's claim that his country has no atomic weapons, materials or associated programs.
(AP) Chief U.N. weapons inspector Hans Blix, right, greets a member of the United Nations weapons...
Full Image
Of the 2,400-page nuclear portion of the document, 300 pages still must be translated from Arabic. And only an exhaustive analysis, backed up by ongoing arms inspections in Iraq, can determine if the document is truthful, said Melissa Fleming, a spokeswoman for the Vienna, Austria-based International Atomic Energy Agency.
"The cross-checking is extremely important, including cross-checking on the ground," Fleming told The Associated Press. "Should there be elements we feel have to be checked out, we have the advantage of having a team on the ground that can go the next day."
On Sunday, an adviser to Saddam suggested that in the years before the 1991 Gulf War, Iraq may have been close to building an atomic bomb.
Lt. Gen. Amer al-Saadi said Iraq no longer has such ambitions, but that it was up to the U.N. nuclear agency to determine "how close we were."
Using a powerful electronic database, nuclear experts began poring through the dossier within hours after it arrived at U.N. offices Sunday, measuring Iraq's claims against the hundreds of thousands of documents the agency has compiled since it began inspections in Iraq in the early 1990s.
(AP) Hans Blix, the United Nations' chief weapons inspector, speaks to reporters minutes before the two...
Full Image
Iraq insists in the declaration that it has no programs for developing banned biological or chemical weapons - and challenged the United States to hand over any evidence it has to the contrary.
"The sooner they do it, the better," al-Saadi said Sunday.
Annan also said Monday that it sharing some intelligence with inspectors was critical to their success.
In Iraq, U.N. arms inspectors made a return visit Monday to Iraq's huge al-Tuwaitha nuclear complex, where scientists in the 1980s worked to produce the fissionable material for nuclear bombs.
Chief nuclear arms monitor Mohamed ElBaradei said that war can be avoided if continued inspections prove Iraq is disarmed.
(AP) Chief United Nations weapons inspector Hans Blix enters UN headquarters shortly before a member of...
Full Image
"If we succeed in providing a thorough analysis on the report and if we succeed in making sure Iraq is disarmed through an inspection, that I think could lead to the avoidance of a use of force," ElBaradei said at a Tokyo conference on nuclear safeguards.
The bulk of the Iraqi document, covering chemical, biological and missile components, is being reviewed in New York by the U.N. Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission, known as UNMOVIC.
The declaration arrived at U.N. offices in New York and Vienna late Sunday, the deadline for Iraq to provide a full and complete accounting of its weapons programs.
But the real test will be the document's transparency, which could determine whether Iraq will face another war with the United States and its allies over U.S. insistence that Iraq has banned weapons.
Under the terms of Security Council Resolution 1441, passed on Nov. 8, false statements or omissions in the declaration, coupled with a failure by Iraq to comply with inspections, "shall constitute a further material breach of Iraq's obligations."
(AP) Legal officer Surya Sinha of UNMOVIC enters the United Nations headquarters in New York with two...
Full Image
Such a breach could be enough for Washington to argue that military action is the only way to force Iraq to comply.
In Moscow, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Yuri Fedotov said Iraq's declaration created "not a bad basis" for resolving the Iraq crisis politically.
Under successive resolutions, passed since the Gulf War ousted Saddam's troops from neighboring Kuwait, the Security Council has demanded that Iraq disarm and comply with a weapons inspections regime. Only after inspectors declare Iraq in compliance can 12 years of crippling sanctions, imposed after the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait, be suspended.
Last week, the White House said there was a "solid basis" for assertions that Saddam possessed banned weapons and that the United States would provide that intelligence to U.N. inspectors. That evidence has not been forthcoming, and Blix has continued to ask Washington to share its data.
Asked Sunday whether he was bothered by Washington's criticism of Iraqi compliance with his inspectors thus far, Blix said: "I'm not concerned about that. They will have their reaction, and we will have our study."
Iraq's declaration, in Arabic and English with an 80-page summary, was contained in at least a dozen bound volumes accompanied by computer disks. They were brought into U.N. headquarters in two, small suitcases.
The declaration covers the 1990s U.N. weapons inspection regime in Iraq, when many arms and much production equipment were destroyed, and details "dual-use" industries that can serve both civilian and military purposes.
Inspectors said they expect much of the declaration to include repetitious material that was submitted years ago.
brian