Bias on Question Time
mediaocrity | 29.11.2002 00:04
Bias on Question time during an important time
If anyone watched Question Time tonight they may have noticed that for a crucial programme which would inevitably focus on the F/F's strike and at the height of an eight day stoppage, the panel was clearly slanted towards those who are opposed to the strike. Never, have I seen such a biased and right wing panel: the panel read like a roll call of the bad: Peter Mandelson, , the mad: ,the Mail rag writer, Melanie Philips, the Tory, Teresa May and the 'sitting on the fence', nice guy, Lib Dem, Simon Hughes. Where was Mark Thomas, Monbiot, Hilary Wainwright, Maggie Clarke, etc?..
The audience was just as bad, despite over 40% + of people still supporting the strike, the loaded audience ensured that the 'hurrahs' for Mandelson et al's comments echoed much more loudly than that of the cheers for Andy Gilchrist. The fire-fighters leader unfortunately had to struggle to challenge the panels attack and respond to a baying audience, with only limited success. The firefighters are known to use Question Time as a key indicator of public support and the onslaught from the panel and audience nd even the text mesages will not have helped morale at all. IMO, this is a dirty media war and the f/f leadership have to become much more media savvy, the Rally/Demo next Saturday should help begin this process.
you can ring the BBC up to complain, the number is 08700 100 222
If anyone watched Question Time tonight they may have noticed that for a crucial programme which would inevitably focus on the F/F's strike and at the height of an eight day stoppage, the panel was clearly slanted towards those who are opposed to the strike. Never, have I seen such a biased and right wing panel: the panel read like a roll call of the bad: Peter Mandelson, , the mad: ,the Mail rag writer, Melanie Philips, the Tory, Teresa May and the 'sitting on the fence', nice guy, Lib Dem, Simon Hughes. Where was Mark Thomas, Monbiot, Hilary Wainwright, Maggie Clarke, etc?..
The audience was just as bad, despite over 40% + of people still supporting the strike, the loaded audience ensured that the 'hurrahs' for Mandelson et al's comments echoed much more loudly than that of the cheers for Andy Gilchrist. The fire-fighters leader unfortunately had to struggle to challenge the panels attack and respond to a baying audience, with only limited success. The firefighters are known to use Question Time as a key indicator of public support and the onslaught from the panel and audience nd even the text mesages will not have helped morale at all. IMO, this is a dirty media war and the f/f leadership have to become much more media savvy, the Rally/Demo next Saturday should help begin this process.
you can ring the BBC up to complain, the number is 08700 100 222
mediaocrity
Comments
Hide the following 8 comments
Question Time Bias
29.11.2002 01:04
And it's not just the panel, the audience is predominantly right wing too, with the loudest applause for those panelists advocating War on Iraq and demonising the Firefighters. Also did you know that when you apply online for tickets to attend Question Time, you're asked if you're a member of a political party and if so which one.
That woman on the panel, can't remember her name, but she was really frightening with her extreme right wing views.
The BBC truly stands for the Blair Broadcasting Corporation.
Stu
e-mail: stuey@surfanytime.co.uk
Homepage: http://users.surfanytime.co.uk/stuey
what's bias?
29.11.2002 11:20
pir
representing the British people
29.11.2002 11:52
Joe
diverse opinions
29.11.2002 11:59
Truth is more complex. Believe it or not, 'the masses' are not all of one view, in fact at all levels and in all areas of society there are conflicting views. In every home, workplace and community, some people hold left-wing views, some hold right-wing views, and most hold a confused mixture of both.
As to Question Time, the BBC aren't entirely to blame for the bias of the panel. Traditionally they've maintained political balance by including reps from all major parties. Trouble is, now that Labour is New Labour, all three main parties are uncomfortable with unions and utterly oppose workers fighting back. The BBC will inevitably reflect this 'Westminster consensus'.
kurious oranj
BBC is the establishment
29.11.2002 13:49
Dan
''balance'' as the greater bias
29.11.2002 14:12
unbalanced
chicken or the egg...
29.11.2002 14:16
i think though, that people are beginning to see thru it...
the fact that a majority of people oppose the war despite not one newspaper opposing it and the fact that support for the firefighters is about 50-50 despite not one newspaper supporting the stike is a very good sign for politics in britain...
kev
Lets have more of Mike Moore Please BBC!
30.11.2002 03:00
How about a vote anyone?HMM?!
Phenix