News From Brum
Victor | 14.11.2002 10:18
BIRMINGHAM BIDS SAD FAREWELL TO COMRADE GRRR
Brummie sectarians have been shocked by the news that popular SWP full-timer Ger Francis has been moved out of the West Midlands by the SWP’s central committee.
Ger, (known affectionately as Grrrrr to many comrades) made a massive impact on the Birmingham left during his sadly all too short time in the city.
It seems a remarkable decision for the SWP to recall to base a man who not only set up one Stop the War Committee in the city but had a big hand in ensuring that two such organisations were eventually created. Is there another city in the UK that can boast that?
Grrr will be remembered fondly for the way in which he ensured that Islamic fundamentalists were made to feel welcome in the Stop the War group and for making sure there was no room for compromise with those pathetic atheists and leftist dissidents from Moslem countries, especially those who objected to the physical separating of men and women in anti-war meetings.
He was particularly brilliant at denouncing anyone who criticised his new found friends as “Islamophobic” and for the superb way in which he lectured exiled Palestinians about their mistakes.
Saturday shopping in Brum won’t be the same without the sight of Grrr, Socialist Worker strapped to his chest, running up to anyone of Arabic or Asian descent and urging them to give money to their “brothers and sisters in Palestine”. We are sure that if those who donated were to check with Grrr, all the cash will have gone straight to the Gaza strip to help projects for Palestinians. No doubt about that.
As well as being a brilliant fundraiser Grrr, was also a masterful strategist in street confrontations. Who will forget the way in which he urged local Asian youth standing near to a police line to ‘attack the state’ while simultaneously ensuring that SWP comrades were moved out of harms way? And how we laughed when in one scuffle orchestrated by Grrr, a baby fell out of a pram. What jolly japes and scrapes were had with Grrrr.
Grrr was also head of the local Globalise Resistance group (Grrr of the GR?) and active in a whole range of other SWP front groups. Indeed such was Grrrr’s commitment to ‘united fronts of a special type’ that many SWP members, including some with decades of membership of the party, were inspired to commit themselves totally to broad campaigns and actually quit the SWP.
Indeed the numbers of activists who have quit the SWP during Grrr’s time in charge in the West Midlands exposes the lie that Grrr was a sectarians shitbag. After all, his commitment to his own unique way of political activity resulted in the biggest exodus of members from his party seen in years.
Who says the SWP always put themselves first?
Brummie sectarians have been shocked by the news that popular SWP full-timer Ger Francis has been moved out of the West Midlands by the SWP’s central committee.
Ger, (known affectionately as Grrrrr to many comrades) made a massive impact on the Birmingham left during his sadly all too short time in the city.
It seems a remarkable decision for the SWP to recall to base a man who not only set up one Stop the War Committee in the city but had a big hand in ensuring that two such organisations were eventually created. Is there another city in the UK that can boast that?
Grrr will be remembered fondly for the way in which he ensured that Islamic fundamentalists were made to feel welcome in the Stop the War group and for making sure there was no room for compromise with those pathetic atheists and leftist dissidents from Moslem countries, especially those who objected to the physical separating of men and women in anti-war meetings.
He was particularly brilliant at denouncing anyone who criticised his new found friends as “Islamophobic” and for the superb way in which he lectured exiled Palestinians about their mistakes.
Saturday shopping in Brum won’t be the same without the sight of Grrr, Socialist Worker strapped to his chest, running up to anyone of Arabic or Asian descent and urging them to give money to their “brothers and sisters in Palestine”. We are sure that if those who donated were to check with Grrr, all the cash will have gone straight to the Gaza strip to help projects for Palestinians. No doubt about that.
As well as being a brilliant fundraiser Grrr, was also a masterful strategist in street confrontations. Who will forget the way in which he urged local Asian youth standing near to a police line to ‘attack the state’ while simultaneously ensuring that SWP comrades were moved out of harms way? And how we laughed when in one scuffle orchestrated by Grrr, a baby fell out of a pram. What jolly japes and scrapes were had with Grrrr.
Grrr was also head of the local Globalise Resistance group (Grrr of the GR?) and active in a whole range of other SWP front groups. Indeed such was Grrrr’s commitment to ‘united fronts of a special type’ that many SWP members, including some with decades of membership of the party, were inspired to commit themselves totally to broad campaigns and actually quit the SWP.
Indeed the numbers of activists who have quit the SWP during Grrr’s time in charge in the West Midlands exposes the lie that Grrr was a sectarians shitbag. After all, his commitment to his own unique way of political activity resulted in the biggest exodus of members from his party seen in years.
Who says the SWP always put themselves first?
Victor
e-mail:
sad1917@hotmail.com
Comments
Hide the following 6 comments
I Agree
14.11.2002 10:32
On a serious note its a disgrace that the SWP split the antiwar movement in Birmingham! I was there when they swamped the Brum Stop War exec meeting in Feb..having then been in the SWP for a few years i was sickend to see that they had even bussed in SWP full timers from LONDON to, by a few votes, elect their stooges.
The way in which Ger our full timer used to rant and rave agianst 'our' percieved enemies was a real sight..being in the SWP you are expected to turn a blind eye to a lot of what the fulltimers do but hearing Ger go on and on about how other activists who just happend to disagree with the SWP line were 'islamophobic' 'racist' and, of course, 'sectarian' lead to me dropping out the SWP..
X
a big split is just what we need now
14.11.2002 12:10
Let's purge the SWP, and the Muslims while we're about it. We need to show our movement will not tolerate people who wear reactionary headscarves. There is no place for those who refuse to reject all gods.. (erm, apart from groovy Wicca-type gods of course, they're okay).
To be honest I've never liked marching alongside Arabs anyway, they talk funny.
anoon
Splitter
14.11.2002 12:38
I'm all for different groups of people working together, but as Victor points out Mr.Grrrrr and the SWP just hijacked Birmingham stop the war for their own ends and made a lot of enemies in the process. This sort of thing makes people disillusioned and drop out of politics. Now isn't that kind of behaviour splitting the movement?
splitter
Split in Birmingham
14.11.2002 14:16
If 'Anoon' had bothered to read the forwarded peice i put on the list s/he would have seen that it was the SWP who 'purged' people not the other way round! Far from the opponents of the SWP being 'anti-Arab' it was the SWP full timer who took money from Palestinians in Birmingham under the pretext it was going to help Palestinians in Gaza.
Still i wouldnt be surprised given 'Anoon's deliberate miconstruing of the original posting & 'Anoon's insinuation that opponents of the SWP are 'islamophobic' that 'Anoon' is probably not a million miles away from the SWP membership...
Victor
What an awful debate
14.11.2002 23:50
Joss
North Carolina IMC Newswire suspended
28.05.2003 23:20
To avoid this, IGNORE all time wasting "flame bait".
Instead, AGITATE, ORGANISE and MOBILISE against capitalism, war and racism.
May I suggest that when the new UK IMC site opens, that dicsussion of news items is moved to separate discussion forums so that people who want to read news
items can dos os without being assaulted by this kind of baiting?
-----------------------
From the North Carolina IMC Newsire.
http://chapelhill.indymedia.org/publish.php
Why the Open Wire has been suspended
The North Carolina Independent Media center will not tolerate posts on the Open Wire that include threats, racism, homophobia, classism, and sexism. Examples of unacceptable action on our website include but are not restricted to: hate speech, threatening comments of any type, and altering posted photographs.
Vigorous debate on the Open Wire is encouraged, so long as it stays on topic, is not reduced to personal attacks, name calling, and provides a feeling of open expression.
Due to several threatening posts on the Open Wire, we believe it has stopped being an good place for open expression. We have collectively decided to improve our website and in the interim suspend the Open Wire section of our site.
We regret having to take this step. We will reopen it as soon as we can.
Here are some suggestions for posting to e-mail lists or web forums.
DO NOT POST FLAME BAIT!
DO NOT RESPOND TO FLAME BAIT!
Flame Bait: Intentionally accusatory and harsh material that is written with the purpose of attacking people with the hopes of eliciting an angry response. (i.e. Bait)
Flames: Strongly worded, even violent writing in response to someone else's flame bait or unagreeable writing.
In the interim if you have news that follows the guidelines of our mission statement PLEASE send your stories to nc@indymedia.org.
We are actively searching for the best way to allow you to post and comment to the open wire while retaining a productive and focused atmosphere.
Thank you very much for your patience!
- The North Carolina Independent Media Center Volunteers
Jim