Skip to content or view screen version

Is Arafat allowed to be criticized on here.

Joel | 25.09.2002 20:59

Is Arafat allowed to be criticized

The Palestinians who reject all offers of peace, then respond by deliberately blowing up innocent civilians. Worse still are the naive supporters who egg the Palestinians on in this murderous 'struggle'. Why are those protesting war against Iraq, screaming for war against Israel??? Only when the Palestinians stop obsessing over blowing up Jews will there be a chance of peace.

In early March 2002, BBC reported the execution of two Palestinians who had been accused by the PA of collaboration. When the BBC crew met with the families of the two victims, they discovered that both had a history of opposition to Arafat and that both had openly criticized Arafat, about him keeping the money the Europeans give him. The family said, that dozens of Palestinians are killed because Arafat calls them collaborators with Israel, where infact, they were people who were critical of Arafat's policies, especially using children as human shields for the media. The BBC correspondent told a human watch group that these were dissidents, not collaborators, but BBC World Service chose not to report the story.

"After two years of bloodshed, Nabil Amr is now calling for what we rejected," .

Not only do Arafat & Company appear deeply entrenched against reforms, but a violent opposition has surfaced as well:

On Tuesday in Ramallah, these threats were carried out. Masked gunmen opened fire at the home of Nabil Amr, a former PA cabinet member who has openly challenged Arafat and called for wide-scale reforms in the PA.
Palestinian sources told The Jerusalem Post they believed the attack was carried out by Fatah gunmen as a warning to PA officials who are trying to undermine Arafat's rule.

Amr, who until recently served as PA minister for parliamentary affairs, recently published an article in London's Arab newspaper blasting Arafat for having missed an historic opportunity by rejecting proposals at Camp David. Amr said, Arafat planned this war in June 2000 and never intended to make peace with Barak. "After two years of bloodshed, we are now calling for what we rejected," he wrote. He also suggested that many senior PA officials are corrupt and responsible for the theft of public funds.

London Times, Sep 23, 02.
Who's hiding behind Arafat? Joel Marr

PA Intelligence chief Tawfik Tirawi, who is hiding at Arafats headquarters, is not only responsible for a multitude of fatal attacks against Israeli civilians but also for the torture of his own people. Israel wants him to stand trial.

A Palestinian accused of collaboration who managed to flee from Hebron last week has accused Palestinian Authority General Intelligence chief Tawfik Tirawi's men of torturing him and many others suspected of working as "informers" for the Shin Bet. The man, 32, is now hiding in an apartment in Jerusalem. He is sharing the apartment together with two others who also managed to escape from Tirawi's prisons.

Tirawi is one of 20 wanted Palestinians who are reportedly hiding in PA Chairman Yasser Arafat's Mukata headquarters compound in Ramallah.

The man said Tirawi's men had brutally tortured him since his arrest about 18 months ago. He said he was released only after a relative paid a top General Intelligence official $10,000.

"I was summoned to the General Intelligence offices near Hebron for a routine interview," he said. "I had a big appliance shop in one of the towns in the Hebron area. "One day there was a big explosion that destroyed the shop. I lost all my money.

"I thought they were going to tell me that they had discovered who was behind the gutting of my shop. When I arrived, I was surprised to hear that I was being accused of being a spy for Israel."

He said that for the first month, he was tortured almost daily inside his small cell. "They beat me with telephone cables all over my body. For many days my head was covered with a stinking bag. They would also tie me to the ceiling by my arms. On other occasions, they made me stand for several hours on a small cup."

He said his interrogators threatened several times to shoot him if he did not confess. Last April, he added, his interrogators informed him that a decision had been taken "on the highest levels" to kill him.

He was blindfolded, handcuffed, and asked for his final words. He was then taken into the back yard. There, the cover was removed from his eyes, and he saw a firing squad of five masked, uniformed policemen.

"They tied me to an electricity poll and pretended that I was about to be executed," he said. "I shouted out that I'm innocent and that Islam does not permit killing innocent people, but they only looked at me with smiles. Then the policemen aimed their rifles at me and waited for the order.

Seconds later one of the officers shouted: 'Fire.' I could hear them pulling the triggers, but I didn't feel the pain.

"For a moment, I didn't know if I was alive or dead. I heard shots, but there was no pain or blood. I quickly realized that it was a mock execution. It was the worst experience in my life.
For a while, I thought I was dead. Only when I heard them laughing did I understand that they were just trying to intimidate me.

"They agreed to release me for health reasons; that's what they wrote in the papers they gave me. If it wasn't for the bribe, I would have been dead by now."

He said that while in prison he met many detainees who were also suspected of helping Israel. "Tirawi's people specialize in arresting Palestinians who are accused of being collaborators. The prisons are full of people like me. Many were released when the IDF entered the Palestinian cities. But others are still being held in secret locations. In the prison where I was, there were more than 25 people, all accused of collaboration with Israel."
He said some were very sick and required immediate medical attention. Those whose families could afford to pay the bribes were released after a short while.

"I have no sympathy for Tirawi or any of his men, and I hope Israel will put him in prison. He said he had no connection Israel, before he was got away from Tirawi. "When I see what's happening to Tirawi today, I say to myself, thank God he's finally paying the price for what his men did to me."

Joel

Comments

Hide the following 7 comments

How thoughtfull

25.09.2002 21:17

I must say that it's jolly decent of the Israelis to put
people they know to be mass murders on trial,but why bother ?
when everyday they gun down unarmed palestinian youths who
were more than likely not mass murders, and in actual fact
totally innocent of any serious crimes.
If Arafat is such a cunt why hav'nt you bumped him off years ago, perhaps he serves a(their)purpose and besides he didn 't bump off Begin their guys did that....

ele


Dan

26.09.2002 04:13

One comment that really stood out. Why are those protesting war against Iraq, screaming for war against Israel??? That is very interesting what you say. I guess you can say, its the hypocrisy of the left. Its the same reason why the left is silent on Iraq killing and gassing the Kurds.

Dan


Phoney boy in trap 6

26.09.2002 06:08

How the fuck do you expect Arafat to do anything but survive when he’s on permanent detention in his own country, pretty difficult to even fight off rival
political challenges and hard to keep hold of the reins.
Imagine if Tony popped in for a parlimentary piss or to log in at vestmunster and then stepped out and found dirty great big yankkkee panza in the corridor trapped in trap 6 after six months of being indisposed you can be sure that Mandyson and the knight of the long knifes would be long running west end hit in the city alsostarring Jeffrey Archer as the kray twins in STOP the CITY and hand over the public bugs bunny or your life britain run by a bunch of hardened criminal from the brick layers club WHAT ? it already is no time to be a hod carrier beam me up scottie ..
Just before e go I was wondering does rascism only affect jews, arabs are of course immune I saw it on the telly ...

yerinal


since he's being criticised every where else

26.09.2002 08:06

perhaps you might care to go elsewhere. no really, regardless of how you view the Israel Palestine issue, there are other preoccupations in the world besides those determined by the Zionists. Tedious people.

Bored


Arafat's got a lovely smile

26.09.2002 17:00

It seems too many minds have been warped by the Guardian, Independent and BBC. We've now got Islamo-fascists crawling out the woodwork. Just keep repeating suicide bombers are freedom fighters. Blowing up buses is resistance. Bombs in disco's is legitimate struggle.

Adam


Ready for the Braindrain

26.09.2002 19:01

SWP will help you out. They've got nice clean signs for you to carry and catchy slogans for you to chant. One month later you'll still be chanting them while you're sitting at home watching the telly wondering what happened to your anger.

xe


Dan, the idiot

26.09.2002 21:26

"I guess you can say, its the hypocrisy of the left. Its the same reason why the left is silent on Iraq killing and gassing the Kurds."
Is it not amusing? Crap people don't change, they prefer to lie than accept their responsibilities, hystory is full of crap people.
First, the crimes committed against Iraq people and Kurds by Saddam were welcome to the Tory party and Bush' (father)administration. The corporate media didn't report or reported the news in distorted way. When Sadam was a USA/UK client everything was fine (The west capitalistic economic system commited atrocities worse than the Iraqis, and they are still continuing), no crimes were reported. Only the left were able to point out what was going on, in that part of the world and the capitalist press try to quiet us.
Secondly, do not you feel strange than when a country is sentenced for crime against humanity and mass destruction weapons (too late in any case, crocodile tears are useless after the events); other countries in the same, if not worse, conditions are treated differently? Israel is worse than Iraq a trillion times but I do not see that the demented from the White House nor from England are doing anything to stop and charge Israel prime minister the terrorist Sharon, Israel is their client.
I think you support the war against Iraq and not against Israel and from that point of view you see the left hypocrite, are you sure that you are not internalize and express the fear of your hypocrisy?
Mackno

mackno