Skip to content or view screen version

Any questions for Paul Foot?

Tom Wall | 02.09.2002 12:00

I am planing to interview Paul Foot, twice Journalist of the Year and Journalist of the Decade for the 1990s, about campaign to become Hackney’s first directly elected Mayor. Any questions or thoughts on the matter are welcome.

I am planing to interview Paul Foot, twice Journalist of the Year and Journalist of the Decade for the 1990s, about campaign to become Hackney’s first directly elected Mayor. Any questions or thoughts on the matter are welcome.

Here's what he's said so far:

Stop the war

“Local, national and international issues will all matter in this election. For instance, the biggest political issue during the campaign is almost certain to be Bush’s war on Iraq. I shall therefore be a mayoral candidate totally opposed to the war and prepared constantly to say so. By the same token I shall also be the candidate relentlessly opposed to the disgraceful treatment by the government of asylum seekers.

“But even on these issues we will get the message across much more clearly if we set out relevant local policies to explain where we stand. For instance, we will show that the government is prepared to spend billions on bombing the already shattered people of Iraq while cutting funding to schools, nurseries, home helps for the elderly, services for the disabled, and libraries in Hackney.

Defend asylum seekers

“I will explain how I will use the Mayor’s office and influence to demonstrate our commitment to welcoming asylum seekers. As Mayor, I would campaign to stop deportations of people who have fled persecution, and oppose the detention of people not accused of any crime. I would demand that Hackney’s social services and housing departments give asylum-seekers the benefits they are entitled to and are not dispersed around the country against their will.

Education

“Last week’s Hackney Gazette led on the terrible mess the council has got itself into on the issue of education. There will soon be only one co-educational secular secondary comprehensive school in Hackney. The result is a hideous pressure on that school and a growing despair and distress everywhere else. The council vaguely promise a replacement for Hackney Downs, but this is to be one of their swish “city technology” snob schools, pioneered by Margaret Thatcher, which will fit neatly into the Estelle Morris notion of “variety” in schools – a gross departure from Labour’s time-honoured commitment to comprehensive education.

“I therefore think that my first and most urgent commitment as Mayor will be to set in motion plans for the immediate construction of two new co-educational secular and comprehensive schools in the borough. This will run side by side with a categorical commitment to supply full-time nursery places for every three-year-old.


Housing

“The next issue is housing. The whole borough has been cursed with sell-offs of council estates. In a case also reported last week, a promise by a housing association not to increase rents has been reversed into a decision to raise rents. I will be committed not just to ensuring no more sell-offs but also to initiating discussions about how to take back into council ownership the estates already sold, how to re-furbish them and involve their tenants in their management. I would call for all council homes to be renovated so they are fit for human habitation, and would ask council officers to enforce the same standards on private landlords.

Funding socialist policies

“Where will the money come from? This will be a familiar question about every socialist policy. The government’s legislation on these elected mayors is very careful to insure against the election of a socialist. The mayor therefore has no money. The mayor’s policies will have to be funded out of the council’s budget. As we all know, central government has been starving local government of the money necessary to provide vital services and has declared Hackney in effect bankrupt. So if I become mayor, and the council or government says there’s no money for policies that Hackney people have voted for, I will not back down or call for local people to pay higher council taxes.

Hackney is one of the poorest boroughs in the country. Its people’s needs should be met by central government. But the government, in its determination to stick to Tory policies on tax and public spending, has cut millions of pounds from Hackney’s grant. If elected, I would be committed to a grassroots campaign involving tenants, parents, trade unionists, voluntary groups and so on, as well as asking for support from our MPs and councillors, to back the case for more resources for Hackney from government – and I would be starting with the support of the mandate of the people of Hackney.

Privatisation

“Another issue is privatisation. Taking the lead from the government and the Local Government Network, representing the corporate greedies who can’t wait to get their fingers on public enterprise in Hackney, the council has pushed their people further and further into the mire by privatising essential public services. The IT-Net transfer was one of the great council scandals of modern times. Now the council has had, at great expense, to reverse the privatisation of the refuse service. I will be committed not just to stopping all further privatisations, but to involving all public sector workers and users in discussions as to how best to run those services democratically.

Racism

“I will not tolerate racism or any form of discrimination in any of the council’s practices. One reason for Hackney’s vitality is its diversity, which in my opinion makes it one of the best places on earth to live. I will therefore make fighting racism a priority. I will commit myself to a full-scale inquiry into allegations of racial discrimination in the council, and to having discussions with the local police committees and the GLA about the habit of police, as rampant in Hackney as anywhere else, of stopping, searching and arresting people because they are black. I will campaign for real police accountability. I will also carry on supporting families of police violence who are seeking justice, such as the Justice for Harry Stanley campaign.

Other issues

“There are plenty of other issues that I will address during the campaign. Among these will be a call for the legalisation of cannabis, opposition to congestion charges, a demand for the tube to be brought to Hackney, and a commitment to policies that protect the environment.

“We will be producing during the campaign a series of leaflets as well as a broadsheet newspaper in which my policies as mayor will be more fully set out.”



The interview will be published on the Hackney sub-section of Indy Media.

Tom Wall

Comments

Hide the following 13 comments

A few questions actually

02.09.2002 13:14

Why does Mr Foot still equate socialism with the public sector and urban derived alone ? History tends to show that Socialism will only come about when the needs are addressed of other exploited sections of society who may not be 'natural' socialists. For example, the ludicrous spiral in house prices. Property speculation is one of the most important sectors of capitalism in Britain, so why doesnt Mr Foot pledge the SWP to abolish the mortgage, seizing all freeholds and granting leaseholds to the homeowners in perpetuity. This would destroy a amajor section of capitalism in one go.

Additionally:
If Mr Foot is so appalled at the conduct of the Labour party, why does his own party (the SWP) do all it can to support Labour on the spurious pretext that it represents the working class ?
If Mr Foot's party claims to be acting in the best interests of the proletariat, why is it endorsing the ghastly Globalise Resistance, which is about as far removed from any concept of social revolution as the Fabians a century ago ?

A Real Socialist


Housing

02.09.2002 14:02

Would he encourage tenants, particularly those in privatised accommodation, to seize their homes from private landlords and housing associations? Would he do this even though it would be illegal and could see him and his council prosecuted?

Dan


"A few questions, actually"

02.09.2002 14:27

(I love the "actually" - presumably it was all our "Real Socialist" could do to avoid writing "Why oh why oh why...") Gee willikins, don't be such an arse. Hackney is a deprived urban area - hence Paul's tendency to talk about urban deprivation. Try harder next time.

Jim
mail e-mail: j.g.meadway@lse.ac.uk


the reelest

02.09.2002 15:04

can you ask mr foot what his position is on regarding the legless wheel chair guy who constantly parades along lowerclapton road, he wheels into bemused traffic while drinking tenents and special brew?

reely reel


Actually,

02.09.2002 16:12

I am trying to address the one question that socialists are ignoring in this country, which is why they don't get anywhere, whether theyre principled, or opportunists like the SWP.>>> Where, above all, does captial reside in Britain ? Not primarily in industrial output, but in PROPERTY. and thats no more than Marx himself noted... Only when socialists can see that mortgage payers (emphasis on "mort") are among the most exploited in the country, will we start to get anywhere. You dont have to be Hackney-poor to be exploited ! Capitalism entails not your own personal wealth, but how much wealth you generate for others; thats the basis of "Surplus value", so dont be sarcastic with me ! (or anyone else)

Real Socialist again


Questions

03.09.2002 13:14

How highly does Paul Foot rate the ideas and career of Jean Paul Sartre ? I consider Sartre to be the most important Marxist philosopher since Trotsky.

In what aspects of Marxism does Paul Foot agree with Perry Anderson of New Left Review ?

Can Paul Foot please explain why it is that Britain, the country which seems to be most obsessed with class, is also the one where socialist revolutionary concepts are most lacking , particularly among the working class ?

Marx spotted the tendency of the "Labour Aristocracy " first, but ask Mr Foot how he thinks this problem has developed over the century since.

Space- Trotskyist


a New Ken Livingstone ?

04.09.2002 13:22

Given the SWP policy commitment to support Labour wherever possible, isnt there a danger that if Comrade Foot wins through, he will further that policy, becoming another left-of-Labour Collaborator Poodle ? Will he end up sadly killing pigeons in Hackneys parks ?

G H Gythuk


a New Ken Livingstone ?

04.09.2002 13:22

Given the SWP policy commitment to support Labour wherever possible, isnt there a danger that if Comrade Foot wins through, he will further that policy, becoming another left-of-Labour Collaborator Poodle ? Will he end up sadly killing pigeons in Hackneys parks ?

G H Gythuk


Biggest issue?

04.09.2002 20:23

Why should I vote for you rather than Terry Edwards, Chair of our Tenants' Convention? At least Terry knows that a war in Iraq is not the biggest issue in Hackney. If you lived on one of our estates you might realise this yourself.

Peter


Who is Terry Edwards?

05.09.2002 10:15

Who is this terry character? Is he an independent or the IWCA canidate?

jail bird


The Board of Political Standards

06.09.2002 13:35

Recent allegations surrounding Livingstone's conduct have brought into prominence a rather obscure goverment agency known as The Board of Political Standards, to which it seems all elected local government politicians must sign up. This rather unpublicised entity seems to me to be a very subtle coup by Blair against any force which could oppose his movement, so the question is :
supposing Foot to be elected, would he stand alone on the electoral mandate and the manifestly just socialist platform, or would he demean himself by subscribing to the overlordship of Blair's Board of Standards ?
In a way, this is a new version of the old debate about whether socialist MPs (and other dissenters) should pledge allegiance to the Monarch and take their seats in the House .

G H Gythuk


Terry Edwards

06.09.2002 16:54

Someone asked who Terry Edwards is. He is the Chair of the Tenants' Convention. He isn't the IWCA candidate, he is independent. The next Hackney Independent (12000 copies distributed across Hoxton/Haggerston/De Beauvoir) will have an interview with Terry where he attacks the Hackney Labour Party and gentrification of the Borough. He doesn't comment on Iraq, though.

Peter


Terry Edwards

09.09.2002 13:01

Would this be the same Terry Edwards who was a Labour Party member up until a month ago and then decided to stand for mayor because he didn't get the New Labour nomination himself?

Not anything to do with the guy who paid effusive public tribute on the death of the Queen Mother (gawd bless her)?

It would be a pity if the IWCA were backing a candidate who couldn't win in order to take votes away from Paul Foot and thereby make it easier for New Labour to win. Still, better than the SA getting a vote that confounds the IWCA's analysis I suppose.

Two questions for Proletarian Peter:

1) How is Terry Edwards' housing policy better than Paul Foot's?
2) Exactly which Hackney council estate do you live on?

Curious of Hackney