Skip to content or view screen version

Leftwing Defeatism

Tod | 13.08.2002 12:07

I am strong, and resolute, trying to find stratagems to beat the big guys at their own game, but guess what? It appears that only Republicans are allowed this sense of exhilaration these days! The attitude of my liberal minded friends? Expect nothing less than DEFEAT! They are generally angry, and whatever hostility that comes their way from others, the more they feel PERSECUTED. Enemies of the state. And when the FBI doesn't come knocking? They're a little miffed.

Leftwing Defeatism
Leftwing Defeatism



   Not long ago, I saw the great thinker of the Left, Naom Chomski, talking on a cable channel at a diner. He spoke very convincingly, albeit with 10 syllable words, about imperialist/corporate America. I listened to him on the edge of my stool. 
  Apparently I was the only one who found Chomski intriguing. Several people 'protested' his lecture and the channel was promptly changed to Sports. In fact, an ad for Nikes was playing out. Ironic, considering that the old man had accused Nike only moments before, of supporting abysmal labor conditions throughout the developing world.
  Did the people around me see the irony? No. Not one. What they saw, I'm afraid, was an intellect with an oversized head, talking Greek. Worse, the sour looking old guy appeared to be bitching about anything and all that most people happen to enjoy.
  Is this how the Left cares to reach the masses?  
  Okay, so the masses 'enjoy' whatever few choices the market permits. When this occurs in politics, we call it propaganda; and as the 'preemptive war' effort winds up against Iraq, you can be sure that the people are going to buy it. Strong men with many medals stand at the podium at the Pentagon and sell Americans on this outlandish war, all on the basis of appealing to our best interests.
  The only real left wing candidate in recent times? Ralph Nader, who attempted to shore up his presidential bids with ZIP charisma.
  Face it. The left is at a deficit in terms of showing anything appealing that people might, well, find attractive.  
  Lately, as I read the top conservative Websites, I find that more and more of these people are becoming wary of Bush. Some of them are 'incorporating' liberal views. Conservative Cato analyst, Alan Reynolds, recently wrote, "The government's fatal assumption was that stocks fell mainly because of accounting problems," rather than cooking the books. Here we have a true affront to the Bush administration, who, for the sake of image made a few high profile arrests to appear tough.
  Conservatives are seeing through the Bush charade, but who in the Left reads the Cato reports? We know we hate the Heritage Foundation, right? But their best thinkers are every day reading The Nation, and amending OUR IDEAS to their program, which bottom line, appeals to the masses: love of family, love of country, and finally, love of (gasp!) the status quo.
  The status quo sucks. But tell that to the guy on the stool beside me. He looks like an average American, what, with an American flag airbrushed across his t-shirt. To look at him, he is just another old guy sitting at the counter, sipping coffee. But Saed is an Armenian, born in Iraq.
  He tells me he had to leave his homeland, considering the persecution of Armenians in Iraq, "And so I lived from one country to another, where no one would take me for who I am, not until I came to America."
  Saed succeeded in the US. He bought property and ran a number of successful convenient stores. He does not like Saddam Hussein, and is not unaware of the thousands of Kurds whom Saddam gassed to death in the streets.  
  "You a liberal?" he asked. "You must be if you don't want to see that butcher contained. And for me? While you fight the US government, I am grateful for the security I have living in this country, and the freedom I have to be who I am. But you liberals? You make a hate fest of all of it, and who will listen to you when you are right?"
  I smirked. "When we are right, or do you mean - on the right?"
  Saed laughed. And he handed me a feature from today's paper, of Bush on his ranch wearing a cowboy hat, wrist bleeding, carrying cedar logs. "You know how a picture is said to be worth a thousand words?" he asked.
  I nodded.  
  "You liberals should get a load of this," he said. "Here is the president who alone defies bans on greenhouse gasses, who is paid by the factories to lower pollution standards (how he won his office!). But all he need do here is say how he has 'liberated' his oaks from the strangling cedars to allow them water, and he is a great conservationist.
  "But you tell me, what about you liberals? You are defeatists, too full of hatemongering to show the little people even a little of the strength conveyed by the president in this picture."
  And I realized: He has a point. When I sought to gain big time support for InterNation in order to compete with the likes of the mainstream media, my liberal friends sent messages of PROTEST!!! What, they wondered, Did I want money? A virtual hug? "Forget it, man, we're radicals over here," one guy said.
  Another left-winger snipped, "Free information hogs!"
  I was accused of "entrepreneur activism." -Hummm do you see a financial opportunity? (My reply: If I wanted your fucking money so much I wouldn't risk assailing your Left wing stupidity!)
  I am strong, and resolute, trying to find stratagems to beat the big guys at their own game, but guess what? It appears that only Republicans are allowed this sense of exhilaration these days! The attitude of my liberal minded friends? Expect nothing less than DEFEAT! They are generally angry, and whatever hostility that comes their way from others, the more they feel PERSECUTED. Enemies of the state! And when the FBI doesn't come knocking? They're a little miffed.
  The left is in dire straits not because our positions are wrong, but because we do not engender images of strength, or success. We come across as a reactive, intellectual elite. In a nutshell? The left is like Naom Chomski, really brilliant, yes, but otherwise, totally out of touch with ordinary people.

Tod
- e-mail: admin@inter-nation.org
- Homepage: www.inter-nation.org

Comments

Hide the following 5 comments

true

13.08.2002 22:29

Your right you know.
The right, to the general public is just so more attractive!
The Right seems to call to you, saying how you are what they are thinking of most and that they will do everything they can to make life better for you.
The left on the other hand appear to just call and promise tax hikes to pay for better lives elsehwere, people whom you dont even know.

And yes, it is morally right to pay for better human rights in people who have had no direct contact with in your whole life, but people don't think that way, people respond far better to pressing domestic issues and the promise of riches then they do in acting ethically on behalf of people who in their life time will never concern them at all.
The right has a seductive way of attracting you, like most evils do.

Karic


Defeatism is a tactic, actually

14.08.2002 14:38

In the early 1990s, I argued that the condition of the Labour party was so bad that it could not be revived, and that any attempt to take power would end up in the kind of regime we have now in Blair & Co, of open collaboration with capitalism.
This was defeatism for sure, but better stay defeated than lose your principles entirely !

Space-Trotskyist


The attractiveness of the right

14.08.2002 23:16

I'm not so sure the right IS that attractive to 'ordinary' people (I'm ordinary... so are my friends and close family, who you could call 'lefties').
For example, a couple of years ago, when I was a young naive 18 year old, I started working full time as a year out. I thought this was great, I'm adding to the strength of the economy, helping stimulate growth and wealth. I know this is all BS but at the time I actually believed it, in my own naive mind. Then I found out, although the media made out the economy was 'booming', it didn't effect me, my wages stayed crap and my job was driving me insane through boredom and alienation.
Over the last two years I've taken quite an interest in politics, and learnt the basic values of Marx, found out about Chomsky etc etc. Since learning about socialism, I believe in it's majority of forms, it is on the whole a movement for all people, supported by good people, with open minds and a caring for others. This became particularly attractive to me when I learnt there is another way that doesn't involve working (for someone elses profit), consuming (bullshit) and then rotting away at the end a miserable old git who's wasted his life.... working! The thing is, I don't think the common man/woman these days doesn't know much about the great things socialism (what form I haven't decided yet) could offer, i.e liberation, co-operation and working for yourself and community. I think it's these basic things that would attract anyone from the single mother working in a supermarket to the average office worker who feels like another cog in a money making machine.
These are the people we need to reach out to to educate them that there is a better way. This is how people will become attracted to the left. Unfortunately it's going to be a struggle because radical political ideas just aren't mentioned on television, school, or the press.
I must add one thing that does put me off are miserable, cynical hard fundamentalists telling me I should do this and shouldn't do that. Thay piss me off. It's those kind of people who put people off the left.
And another thing, I got into Chomsky through a punk band called Propagandhi. He is very cool, and can be relevant to the ordinary man/woman if you find a way to make them listen. In my case it was through music.
It all depends if you see the ordinary person as an ignorant moron who is helpless or a lost soul needing direction who can be changed.
"Don't hate the media, become the media" - Jello Biafra.

Dave


oops!

14.08.2002 23:23

What I meant to say... I DO think the common man/woman these days DOESN'T know much about the great things socialism (what form I haven't decided yet) could offer

Dave


two of the same

15.08.2002 20:54

LEFT and RIGHT are just two different ways of shafting
the people, like all religions, it's a load of old bollox.

do