Skip to content or view screen version

Labour peer admits to Nestle link

Baby Milk Action | 19.03.2002 16:09

Labour peer, Lord Ahmed, defended Nestlé when a former Nestlé Pakistan employee provided internal documents demonstrating he was required to promote breastmilk substitutes by bribing doctors and other unethical means. Lord Ahmed has disclosed in The Guardian (19th March 2002) that Nestle funded his fact-finding trip to Pakistan and that he is now negotiating o be a paid advisor.

Dear all,

Labour peer Lord Ahmed has admitted he took a trip paid by Nestle to Pakistan prior to defending the company's baby food marketing reputation. Now says he may take paid employment with the firm, whose unethical and irresponsible marketing of breastmilk substitutes contributes to the unnecessary death and suffering of infants around the world.

See the following article, reproduced from The Guardian, Tuesday 19 March 2002  http://www.guardian.co.uk/

You may have followed the news about former Nestle Pakistan employee Syed Aamar Raza who quit the company after becoming concerned about the way he was required to promote breastmilk substitutes after an infant died while he was visiting a doctor. Aamar's duties included offering inducements to doctors to increase sales - one of the claims he has backed up with internal company documents. For further details see the summary of the report Milking Profits at  http://www.babymilkaction.org/update/update27feature.html and follow-up press releases in the 'resources' section of the Baby Milk Action site at  http://www.babymilkaction.org/

The Network for Consumer Protection in Pakistan presented evidence of systematic and institutionalised malpractice to a European Parliament public hearing into Nestlé in November 2000, which Nestlé boycotted. Lord Ahmed went instead.

Please distribute this email widely. If you have received this email from  mikebrady@babymilkaction.org and would rather not receive future alerts, please reply with 'delete' as the subject.

----The Guardian, Tuesday March 19, 2002. Page 7

Labour peer under fire for Nestlé link

Lord Ahmed negotiating paid post with food giant

Kevin Maguire

A prominent Labour Muslim peer was criticised by baby milk campaigners last night over plans to take a paid post advising Nestlé, the controversial food giant.

Lord Ahmed of Rotherham disclosed he is in negotiations with the Swiss corporation and has made company-sponsored trips to inspect Nestlé's operations in Pakistan, which he subsequently praised.

The conglomerate is the target of a long running boycott over allegations, vehemently denied by executives, that it puts sales ahead of infant health in the developing world and bribed doctors in Pakistan to promote its products.

Lord Ahmed, made a life peer by Tony Blair in 1998, insisted criticism of the multinational was unfounded and was mainly from "white people" unaware of the facts. "I may become an adviser on international affairs," he said, to ensure the highest corporate standards were maintained.

The endorsement of such a high profile Muslim would be a boost for Nestlé which has devoted significant resources to countering claims that it routinely breaches a World Health Organisation international marketing code.

"They have suggested [the advisory role] because of my interest in other countries," said Lord Ahmed.

Labour MEP Richard Howitt, European parliament spokesman on corporate responsibility, urged the peer to reconsider and warned him his independence would be compromised if he accepted an official position with Nestlé.

Nestlé has been accused of promoting unsafe bottle feeding instead of breast feeding in countries such as Pakistan where water supplies are often polluted, resulting in thousands of bottle fed children dying of diarrhoea.

Anti-corporate campaigners argue it fails to abide by an international code banning unethical marketing practices, including inducements to doctors to recommend bottles and free trial supplies of milk substitutes to mothers.

Critics claim groups in 20 countries support a boycott of Nestlé brands from Nescafé and Quality Street to Gale's honey and Felix cat food.

The peer's support for Nestlé has outraged Baby Milk Action, the Cambridge based network that has harried the conglomerate for more than two decades. Its policy director, Patti Rundall, said Lord Ahmed had voiced support for the group's aims in February 2000 during a Westminster meeting with Aamar Raza, a former Nestlé employee turned whistleblower in Pakistan.

Yet in November of that year the peer attempted to put Nestlé's case to a European parliament hearing into corporate accountability.

When the MEP Mr Howitt refused Lord Ahmed permission to speak at the hearing, the peer invited socialist group MEPs to a meeting with the company.

"Lord Ahmed was very sympathetic, offered to do whatever he could and even proposed to organise a forum in London," said Ms Rundall.

"Then we found that he had visited a Nestlé factory in Pakistan and was speaking up for Nestlé. We were very surprised to find he had effectively switched sides."

Nestlé said it rejected Baby Milk Action's allegations of malpractice and it had decided to "facilitate" a trip to Pakistan by Lord Ahmed after the peer decided to investigate the claims himself.

"We have found his input and advice to be very valuable and since then we have entered into discussions with him about him becoming an adviser to Nestlé UK Ltd on developing world issues affecting Islamic matters and Muslim communities in the UK," said a company statement.

Lord Ahmed accepted the visit to Nestlé's Pakistan operations and had changed his mind and he believed it had been unfairly singled out for criticism.

He registered the fact the company paid for the trip two years ago, said the peer, who denied receiving payment from Nestlé or Weber Shandwick, Nestlé's lobbyists.
---ends

Best wishes,

Mike Brady
--
---
Mike Brady
Campaigns and Networking Coordinator
Baby Milk Action

Visit our website  http://www.babymilkaction.org/

Baby Milk Action is the UK member of the International Baby Food Action Network - IBFAN -  http://www.ibfan.org/

****YOU CAN NOW ORDER PUBLICATIONS AND MERCHANDISE ON-LINE****

Baby Milk Action, 23 St. Andrew's Street, Cambridge, CB2 3AX, UK.
UK contact numbers. Tel: 01223 464420 Fax: 01223 464417
International contact numbers. Tel: +44 1223 464420 Fax: +44 1223 464417
----

Baby Milk Action
- e-mail: mikebrady@babymilkaction.org
- Homepage: http://www.babymilkaction.org/