Skip to content or view screen version

Author of "The Rise of the Meritocracy" is dead

Sposa Balincom | 16.01.2002 16:27

Michael Young (b 1915), one of the few British important post- war theoreticians, was announced dead last night.

"The Rise of the Meritocracy 1870- 2033" was written by Young in 1958 and is in a long line of political satire masquerading as fiction. Like H G Wells, he was shunned by the Fabians and other fake socialists for laying open some of the fundamental dangers of Labourism. Like Jack Londons "Iron Heel, he formulated his fears in the form of a future manuscript where instead of the socialist utopia, there arose a new form of oligarchy which he termed "Meritocracy". It is bizarre indeed that Blair should have rushed to pour accolades on Youngs grave (coming to bury not to praise, one might think) for perhaps neither he nor Brown quite understand the implications of their advocacy of Meritocracy. As recently as 29 June 2001, Young said in the Guardian;
" Four decades ago, I wrote a book warning of the risks of what i called a Meritocracy. Now my worst fears are being realised"
Young was also the author of a sociological study "Family and Kinship in East London", and an introduction to James Burnham's "The Managerial Revolution" of 1939. The latter is perhaps the only piece of political theory ever to unsettle Trotsky, with its then startling suggestion that Soviet Russia and NSDAP Germany were becoming almost indistinguishable. Young concluded that for all the mistakes Burnham made, a managerial dictatorship could still arise if democracy failed.

Michael Young 1915- 2002

Sposa Balincom

Comments

Hide the following 5 comments

ive been endeavouring to find an online text

16.01.2002 17:11

version of young's work, but alas, and its out of print as far as i know, although you sometimes find an old pelican edition in bookshop basements (ah, pelicans ! whatever happened to them ?).
so heres a review by prof r m young (no relation, i imagine)

D S B again
- Homepage: http://www.human-nature.com/rmyoung/papers/pap133.htm


Here anyway, is the list of chapter headings

16.01.2002 17:34

Contents list of "Rise of the Meritocracy, 1870-2033"

Decline of the lower Classes:

Status of the worker:
Golden age of Equality
Gulf Between the classes
Pioneers of Dirty work
The new unemployment
Domestic servants again

Fall of the labour movement:
Historic mission
Decline of parliament
The technicians
Adjustment in the unions

Rich and poor:
Merit money
The modern synthesis

Crisis:
The first womens campaign
Modern feminist movement
Coming of the crisis
New conservatism
A rank and file at last
From here, where ?

As the full title makes clear, Young envisaged that the seeds of modern society had been laid about 1870 and would not be overthrown until 2033.

DSB yet again


we do not value our own people

16.01.2002 19:48

in other countries a brilliant thinker and political strategist such as Michael Young ( he wrote the 1945 lABOUR MANIFESTO WITH ITS COMMITMENT TO CREATE THE N.H.S.ETC)would be revered on the left. Yet, while it is good that there is an obituary on indymedia uk, most activists will never have heard of him. His prediction of the rise of a meritocracy has proved correct with the rise of the Blairites who kick the 'ladder of opportunity' away once they have risen.

info-shifter


NO ONE INTERESTED ?

17.01.2002 16:04

O well, I suppose its just a generational thing. but i really do wish people would pay more attention to thought- out written stuff, and not always rely on instinct and home -grown knowledge.
I was actually expecting lots of objections here, on the lines that Michael Young wasnt a radical, that he took a lordship, even joined the dreaded 'SDP', and set up the OU and Which? magazine, etc etc.
I was preparing to reply that particularly in England, political analysis and personal career may not always co-incide. Still, no need to bother. But remember that both Leo Tolstoy and Pyeter Kropotkin were aristocrats when they werent working on their anarchistic theories.

DSB (yes, again)