Skip to content or view screen version

A Personal View of the Brighton Demo Today (30th)

A Previous Poster | 30.09.2001 23:08

Under total authoritarian control! No media impact!

In recent London demos such as Mayday, the Italian Embassy, and the DSEi Docklands, I have seen great creativity in challenging the continuing authoritarian clampdown on legal dissent. Marches don't always go the way police have planned them, and breakaway groups cause confusion and wrongfoot the authorities. I personally advocate peaceful demonstration, and this creativity and good-humoured approach can avoid violent confrontation and yet make powerful points and attract media attention. It can also sometimes shows up the illogicality of government response.

Today in Brighton I witnessed a model exercise in crowd control that surprised me. Coming down from London and being a lazy sod, I didn't arrive until near two and so made my way straight to the seafront and conference centre. There I found the surreal sight of a heavily protected centre and massive police presence overseeing an almost deserted promenade in the pouring rain. I met a a handful of other demonstrators infront of the centre and we waited for the main march and rally to arrive. Much later than scheduled, a crowd of some four to five thousand arrived, led by the ubiquitous SWP newspaper sellers, and then a very organised and loud samba band. From the banners around, it was apparent that there were many different interest groups involved - a wonderful reminder of the connectedness of all the issues that the current wave of popular dissent is about. Although there was an ample police presence between several sets of barriers, all tooled up in riot gear and armed with pepper sprays and batons, we then witnessed a militaristic parade of around forty Kent police vans each containg even more riot police.

After less than half an hour "organisers" were urging the crowd to make their way away past the pier, and surprisingly, virtually everyone followed. Once past the pier, many coaches were waiting to take people back home. There has been virtually no media coverage of the demo, and any mentions on national news have been dismissive. It all looked to me like 'corporate protesting' or some slick PR exercise.

From talking to others I heard that at the start of the march, the police targeted some parts of the crowd before the march began and made arrests of some of the 'Womblier' characters.

The conference was probably completely unaware of any protest and the media has effectively ignored it. Signs around the promenade informed the organisers that under Section 12 of the Public Order Act, the protest was only allowed to occur in a specified area and and within specified times (1.30 - 4.00) and astonishingly, everyone seemed to just go along with these restrictions on freedom and democratic rights to protest.

I felt that today was a very poor day for the anti-globalisation/globalised action movement. I wish that protestors were more prepared to challenge the narrow impositions enforced on our right to free speech. Having said that - given the 'pepper spray' warning, the militaristic show of force and the unbelievably torrential rain and greyness of the sky, I think it was marvellous that so many people at least took the trouble to come out. I hope too that many many people come out to Trafalgar Square at seven p.m. on the day of any bombing (or the day after if it starts in an afternoon or evening). I also hope everyone will come to Marble Arch on the 13th at midday and march to Trafalgar Square at one 'o' clock (CND organised protest), but I really really hope that a substantial number spontaneously move on to somwhere else like the American Embassy, or Downing Street - let's show the authorities what this movement is capable of (powerful exertion of will without violent intent).

A Previous Poster

Comments

Hide the following 8 comments

Brighton

30.09.2001 23:54

Today was an absolutely brilliant experience, bringing together old and young, socialists, trade unionists, students, opposers of war and globalisation.
The police estimate the turn out at 10,000, others at around 12,000; yet the BBC Radio 4 6 o'clock news sugessted 1,000, later amended to 3,000 and the last I heard on Radio 5, 4,000
People who don't make it to the well-organised march should not snipe at key organisers/builders, but 'GET OUT OF BED' and join it! Socialist Worker is currently the best informed anti-war paper. The chants were helped/enhanced by the fantastic musicians. My voice has crumbled!

Andy C


Andy
mail e-mail: a-coles.demon.co.uk


Wow Chants!

01.10.2001 02:16

Wow chants!

Free Earth
mail e-mail: earthfree@hotmail.com
- Homepage: http://www.struggle.ws/freeearth.html


ambigious

01.10.2001 06:28

S9me aspects of the protest were brilliant. Diversity. Our determination in the rain.
Some others, not so good. Media coverage is really pissing me off as they make out we were rained off. I certainly wasn't.. ahh well. Action stations. More struggle. More protest will follow. Fighting for better things. We can do it.

protester


traditional SWP tactics

01.10.2001 09:08

Speaking as someone who has been involved in most campaigns the Socialist Workers have jumped on since the mid 80's, I'm afraid that the tactics of the SWP/Globalise Resistance at Brighton are just par for the course. For them, stopping privatisation or preventing war in the Middle East are not the main objectives. The core aim is to recruit new members to the fold. The cause they use to achieve this is, relatively, incidental. This is not an opinion based on ignorance and anti-SWP prejudice but based on many years of working alongside - and talking to - SWP members. The important thing, as far as they are concerned, is that lots of people turn up to be "converted". Of course, you can't expect them to admit this publically (and no doubt some SWP member or another will respond to this in indignant tones) but in private, this is exactly how experienced members of the party put it themselves. Preventing the SWP from hijacking the burgeoning anti-globalisation and anti-capitalist movements is not sectarian, it is essential if these movements are to make real positive changes to our society.

red & black squirrel


Witnessed by their debating with al muhajis?

01.10.2001 09:57

See my post higher up.

brian
- Homepage: www.yahoogroups.com/group/londonlistings


Somoene sent me this SWP email

01.10.2001 12:24

The SWP still have me on their mailing list. This is brilliant:

People are looking for explanations for the attacks and devastation in
New York this week. Many do not feel that bombing Afghanistan or the
Middle East would solve the problem, rather make it worse. There are
many people who are very critical of Bush and American imperialism's
interventions and attacks over the last decade. We should go big on
recruiting these people.

We are likely to have long conversations with people over this but we
could also get some very big sales
ciao

I don't know if this really is an SWP email but it would be nice if the SWP could say that it wasn't.

.


fizzled out

01.10.2001 13:18

I want to agree with others further up. Absolutely no media impact - I heard several bulletins on different media saying only 1000 people turned up which is a blatent lie! I was impressed with the wide range of people from different groups which has got to be the most positive thing from the day.

But it was a bit of a wasted opportunity. All those people there and all we could do was be shepherded around by the stewards within the police baracades? I saw many people tryinh to leave the march to go to the toilet but were pushed back in to the crowd and threatened with arrest if they left the route of the march, but surely if a whole group of people decided they wanted to march through the town centre instead of being kept on the outskirts we could have done it together?

I think as has been said before a certain party was much more interested in increasing their membership list than doing something creative - I saw several people filling out membersip forms as we marched along, and if another person offers me a copy of a newspaper I think I might do something I might regret ;-)

It keeps getting called a 'movement' - lets keep it moving!!

a newbie


How ?

01.10.2001 16:56

sounds good ... how??

mickey finn