Climate talks are dead - now it's time for action
Mark Lynas | 29.11.2000 15:40
Who will save the climate now? The UN negotiations have collapsed without a deal, and with Bush seemingly certain to win the White House, the chance for future success is slim. It's time for ordinary people to take up the struggle, argues Mark Lynas.
November 25th 2000 is a day that will go down in history. Not as a day to be celebrated with flags and songs, but as a day of mourning. For today is the day when the world failed to face up to the challenge of climate change.
It's also the day that government negotiators, blinded by political inertia and commercial interests, watched years of meticulous work collapse around them.
The final plenary session of the Sixth Conference of the Parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change gave few clues as to the reasons for this failure. Desperate to salvage some credibility from the ashes of this long and complex process, delegates queued up to deliver heart-felt statements of regret and willingness to resume in the near future. But the reality of the situation is that Kyoto is dead, that The Hague talks killed it, and that if the challenge of impending climate catastrophe is ever to be seriously dealt with policy-makers will need to start all over again.
The real criminals - yes, criminals - here are the United States. In full knowledge of the urgency of the situation, and presented only two weeks ago with concrete evidence that global warming in this century alone could exceed a deadly six degrees celsius, they riddled the Kyoto treaty with holes and then had the gall to complain when the Europeans wouldn't sign. Now Bill Clinton, who many thought would buckle at the last moment in order not to be remembered as an environmental villain, has lost the game. "How will he face Chelsea?" asked one baffled journalist. Although optimists say that the COP6 splits could be tackled further at a resumed session in May 2001, by then an oilman will be in the White House - and all bets on a US compromise will be off.
Many environmental groups, although publicly decrying the failure here at The Hague, are privately relieved that they won't have to carry out the dirty work of supporting an agreement that stinks. As it stood late last night, the text would have allowed logging companies around the globe to devastate tropical forests and establish pine plantations - then claiming financial credits for 'soaking up' carbon. It would have allowed the United States and other rich countries to meet their Kyoto targets of reducing greenhouse gas emissions, while behind the scenes giving them free license to do exactly the opposite. And it could even have provided cash for nuclear power and coal plants across Eastern Europe and the developing world.
In the longer term The Hague could turn out to have been a blessing in disguise. Nothing has been agreed, but at least now no-one can pretend otherwise. That's surely better than fake 'cuts' behind a green smokescreen.
Instead, it's time to move on. Now that governments have failed, it's time for the world's people to stand up and be counted. In truth COP6, like all previous COPs, was an obscure process understood only by a few thousand international policy-makers and lobbyists - all operating in a political vacuum without the participation or even the interest of the people they claimed to represent. Now that our leaders have failed, it's time for us citizens to act. Rather than being decided behind closed doors at the UN, strategies for dealing with climate change should be decided on the streets.
As the world continues to warm at an escalating rate, and more powerful storms batter coastlines and flatten whole towns, people in rich countries will have no choice but to wake up to the need to radically change their lifestyles and economies. At the moment, jobs, health and education always come top in any list of immediate political priorities. But as the death toll mounts, more and more people cannot fail to realise that climate change is an issue of basic human survival.
We can only hope - and hope against most of the current scientific evidence - that by then it won't already be too late.
It's also the day that government negotiators, blinded by political inertia and commercial interests, watched years of meticulous work collapse around them.
The final plenary session of the Sixth Conference of the Parties to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change gave few clues as to the reasons for this failure. Desperate to salvage some credibility from the ashes of this long and complex process, delegates queued up to deliver heart-felt statements of regret and willingness to resume in the near future. But the reality of the situation is that Kyoto is dead, that The Hague talks killed it, and that if the challenge of impending climate catastrophe is ever to be seriously dealt with policy-makers will need to start all over again.
The real criminals - yes, criminals - here are the United States. In full knowledge of the urgency of the situation, and presented only two weeks ago with concrete evidence that global warming in this century alone could exceed a deadly six degrees celsius, they riddled the Kyoto treaty with holes and then had the gall to complain when the Europeans wouldn't sign. Now Bill Clinton, who many thought would buckle at the last moment in order not to be remembered as an environmental villain, has lost the game. "How will he face Chelsea?" asked one baffled journalist. Although optimists say that the COP6 splits could be tackled further at a resumed session in May 2001, by then an oilman will be in the White House - and all bets on a US compromise will be off.
Many environmental groups, although publicly decrying the failure here at The Hague, are privately relieved that they won't have to carry out the dirty work of supporting an agreement that stinks. As it stood late last night, the text would have allowed logging companies around the globe to devastate tropical forests and establish pine plantations - then claiming financial credits for 'soaking up' carbon. It would have allowed the United States and other rich countries to meet their Kyoto targets of reducing greenhouse gas emissions, while behind the scenes giving them free license to do exactly the opposite. And it could even have provided cash for nuclear power and coal plants across Eastern Europe and the developing world.
In the longer term The Hague could turn out to have been a blessing in disguise. Nothing has been agreed, but at least now no-one can pretend otherwise. That's surely better than fake 'cuts' behind a green smokescreen.
Instead, it's time to move on. Now that governments have failed, it's time for the world's people to stand up and be counted. In truth COP6, like all previous COPs, was an obscure process understood only by a few thousand international policy-makers and lobbyists - all operating in a political vacuum without the participation or even the interest of the people they claimed to represent. Now that our leaders have failed, it's time for us citizens to act. Rather than being decided behind closed doors at the UN, strategies for dealing with climate change should be decided on the streets.
As the world continues to warm at an escalating rate, and more powerful storms batter coastlines and flatten whole towns, people in rich countries will have no choice but to wake up to the need to radically change their lifestyles and economies. At the moment, jobs, health and education always come top in any list of immediate political priorities. But as the death toll mounts, more and more people cannot fail to realise that climate change is an issue of basic human survival.
We can only hope - and hope against most of the current scientific evidence - that by then it won't already be too late.
Mark Lynas
e-mail:
mark@oneworld.net
Homepage:
http://www.oneworld.net/campaigns/climatechange/index.html
Comments
Hide the following 4 comments
God and you
29.11.2000 17:13
There has to be God. This God has talked to us by prohets. some prophets are false. Muhammad is the last prophet. I do not lose any thing if the reader did not follow islam. i gain mere mercy from Allah if he becomes muslim. Come to islam.you Europeans are disinformed ,uninforned,about islam.
a Humanbeing
Praise the lord
29.11.2000 18:22
Lemming
e-mail:
lemming@grandtheftcyber.com
Homepage:
http://www.grandtheftcyber.com
That's It.
29.11.2000 21:04
Now I'm just fucking angry. The outcome of this has left me feeling that there's now only one conclusion, one course of action.
I can't find the words to describe how disgusted I am with politicians and corporations after this. For me it defies all human principles, all common sense. They have one god and that god is money.
OK, this realisation is nothing new, but it beggars belief that our 'elected global representatives' have failed so totally to make any progress internationally on this most important of millennial issues.
After this there is only one conclusion, as stated in the above article. It's time for action. It's time for the peoples of the world to take action themselves. There seems little point trying to find a solution that relies on political lobbying or letter writing if those same politicians that people aim such campaigns at cannot themselves even act on the urgency of our global situation.
If the projections of climate change really do continue to come true then we as people will face much more than our local situations. Throughout the talking in the press during the recent rain and floods the focus was always on the uk - almost nowhere (and I'm saying almost nowhere because I'm assuming it was said somewhere, just that I didn't see it) was there mention of the political upheaval and mass movements of people that may arise in a multitude of places because of climate change.
If the world is to attempt any kind of equitable strategy for dealing with the effects of climate change we need to relatively quickly change our global priorities.
I remember a line from an old rts flyer which said something like 'It's never been so necessary, or, so possible' - and for me, that's it.
Disgusted of Britain.
We've been sold out again
30.11.2000 12:30
anarchist606
e-mail:
anarchist606@hushmail.com
Homepage:
www.globalclimatecoalition.org